Education
Reynish attended Hart High School in Santa Clarita, California where he had a 0.84 career goals against average, as well as setting the school"s single-season (14) and career (38) shutout records. He played college soccer for the University of California Santa Barbara from 2002–2006, sitting out between his freshman and sophomore seasons as a redshirt in the 2003 season. He was the starting goalkeeper and played every minute for UCSB in their 2006 season, in which the school won its first National Collegiate Athletic Association Division 1 National Championship.
Reynish was 1st Team All Big West his senior year.