logo logo

Jacob Marschak (until 1933 Jakob Marschak)

Jacob Marschak was an American economist of Ukrainian Jewish origin. During his studies he joined the social democratic party. In 1918 he was the minister for labor in the Soviet republic Terek, then he emigrated to Germany, where he studied in Berlin and Heidelberg. His scholarly career spanned 55 years and 3 very different environments: Germany of the Weimar period, the UK of the Great Depression, and the USA in the World War II.

Background

  • Jacob Marschak's work ranged over a great variety of topics in a long and productive intellectual career. Starting in the 1930s, his articles on measurement of economic variables and estimation of economic relationships provided foundation stones for the field now known as econometrics. Other early papers made seminal contributions to the theory of asset holding, with particular reference to demand for money and liquidity under conditions of incomplete information. This led to a third phase of his work, which combined axiomatic and experimental approaches to rational decision making under uncertainty. From this he moved to the topic of interindividual communication of information, and by a further extension, to the problem of optimal organization for collective decision. The work of this fourth phase was summarized in the classic monograph Economic Theory of Teams, coauthored with Professor Roy Radner of UC, Berkeley. A fifth phase was represented by interest in scientific method as a particular instance of decision making under uncertainty. And there was also a host of significant papers not fitting readily into the above classificatory system, among them works on statistical theory, labor mobility, inventory policy, and economics of atomic energy.

  • Education

    • Jacob Marschak learned German and French from governesses but at age nine was refused admittance to gymnasium because of the very small Jewish quota. He went instead to the First Kiev School of Commerce. In 1915, after engaging in the very common group discussions about which revolutionary group to join, he became a Marxist and, in the same year, entered the Kiev University of Technology. He joined the Menshevik Internationalist (antiwar) faction, was arrested with others in December 1916, and was released with the fall of the Czar in February 1917. He then joined the Kiev municipal government, but in October that coalition broke into a three-cornered struggle: Bolsheviks, supporters of the Kerensky government, and Ukrainians wanting a separate state. The last group won. Marschak and his entire family left Kiev to settle in a resort in the Terek region of the northern Caucasus, where political activity was also intense. Bolsheviks there were organizing all Russian political parties against the Moslemmountaineers—a coalition also intended as a counterweight to the Cossacks, with whom there was an uneasy alliance. In this government Marschak became Secretary of Labor, leading the Menshevik and Socialist Revolutionary movement to

      withhold recognition of the Bolshevik government in Petrograd until the elected constituent assembly was allowed to meet. But by June 1918 another three-sided conflict had arisen—this time among Mensheviks, Cossacks, and Bolsheviks (who were by then allied with the mountaineers). Marschak composed manifestos explaining the Menshevik government's aims, acting essentially as a press relations officer. But when the government eventually came under the control of a local dictator, he and his family returned to Ukrainian-run Kiev.

      By this time Marschak, like many of his friends and political colleagues, had decided there was no longer a viable political cause in Russia to support. In 1919, after studying statistics briefly at the Kiev Institute of Economics, he decided to study economics at the University of Berlin for six months. This brief period was, according to his later accounts, extremely important in his life, for it was in the lectures of Berlin economist and statistician Ladislaus von Bortkiewicz

      that he first learned the importance of mathematical and statistical methods in economic analysis. He then moved to the University of Heidelberg, where he received his Ph.D. in 1922.

    Career

    • After studying with Bortkiewicz in the summer semester 1919 Marschak moved to Heidelberg which became his home base in the fourteen years he spent in Germany, interrupted by two years each he spent as an economic journalist with the liberal newspaper Frankfurter Zeitung , as a researcher at the department of economic policy of the trade unions in Berlin, and at the Kiel Institute where he wrote his habilitation thesis Elasticity of Demand. However, he submitted this work to the University of Heidelberg where he had strong support by Lederer and Alfred Weber, whereas in Kiel there had been some opposition in the faculty despite the fact that Marschak

      had become a German citizen in 1929. On February 22, 1930 Marschak became Privatdozent and subsequently a very popular teacher in the University of Heidelberg with the best students. But his serious study of economics began with his move to the University of

      Heidelberg in the winter semester 1931-32 and his participation in a seminar on Keynes Treatise and on integrating fiscal flows into the national income accounts given by Marschak. The Nazis’ rise to power caused Marschak’s second emigration in spring 1933. His first

      station in exile was Oxford where he became Chichele lecturer in economics at All Souls College in 1933 and Reader of statistics and the founding director of the Oxford Institute of Statistics in 1935. English economics was in general far in advance of German at that time, but Marschak brought with him quantitative skills that Oxford lacked. There he published his article “Money and the Theory of Assets”. In 1940 he was appointed professor of economics in the graduate faculty of the New School for Social Research. In 1943 Marschak was appointed director of the Cowles Commission for Research in Economics and professor of economics at The University of Chicago. In 1955 Marschak and the Cowles Commission, now renamed the Cowles Foundation for Research in Economics, left Chicago for Yale University. He did not stay long; in 1960 he accepted the post of professor of economics and business administration at the University of California at Los Angeles. Official retirement did not change his activities at all; he remained as active in teaching and research when emeritus as he had been before.

    Works

    • A Cross-Section of Business Cycle Discussion
    • Economics of Inquiring, Communicating, Deciding
    • A Discussion on Methods in Economics
    • Von Neumann's and Morgenstern's New Approach to Static Economics

    Politics

    Party affiliation: Social Democratic Labour Party

    Religion

    Jacob Marschak received some formal Jewish education but was never religious.

    Connections

    • Richard Musgrave participated in a seminar on Keynes Treatise and on integrating fiscal flows into the national income accounts given by Marschak.
    • Collegue: Hans Philip Neisser
    • Notable student: Franco Modigliani
    • In 1933 after Hitler’s rise to power Joseph A. Schumpeter gave his priority “list of Hebrew colleagues in Germany” who should be supported. Later he attended some Marschak's lectures.
    • Teacher, mentor: Emil Lederer
      Jacob Marschak was probably the most outstanding student among the many excellent doctoral students Lederer had at the University of Heidelberg
    • opponent: Ludwig Heinrich Edler von Mises
      They debated about economic calculation in the socialist commonwealth.
    Jacob Marschak
    See on larger map
    Born July 23, 1898
    Died July 27, 1977
    (aged 79)
    Nationality
    Ethnicity:
    • 1915 - 1918
      Technological Institute at Kiev
    • 1919 - 1922
      Heidelberg University
    • 1919 - 1919
      University of Berlin
    • 1919 - 1919
      Kiev Institute of Economics
    • 1924 - 1926
      economic journalist, Frankfurter Zeitung (liberal newspaper)
      Frankfurt, Germany, Germany
    • 1926 - 1928
      researcher, The Department of Economic Policy of theTrade Unions
      Berlin, Germany, Germany
    • 1928 - 1930
      Kiel Institute
      Germany, Kiel
    • 1930 - 1933
      assistant professor, Heidelberg University
      Heidelberg, Germany, Germany
    • 1933 - 1935
      Oxford University
    • 1933 - 1938
      lecturer in economics, All Souls College
      Oxford, England, England
    • 1935 - 1939
      director, Oxford Institute of Statistics
      Oxford, England, England
    • 1940 - 1943
      professor of economics, New School for Social Research
    • 1943 - 1948
      director, Cowles Commission for Research in Economics at The University of Chicago
      Chicago, USA
    • 1943 - 1955
      professor of economics, University of Chicago
    • 1955 - 1960
      professor of economics, Yale University
      United States, Connecticut, New Haven
    • 1960 - 1977
      emeritus, professor of economics and business administration, University of California
      Los Angeles, USA
    • show more ...

    Contributor  

    Marina Kiselyova last changed 12/11/2012 view changes
    Yuliya Yefimchik last changed 07/06/2017 view changes
    • Nationalities
      • American
      • United States
    • School
      • First Kiev School of Commerce
        • present
        • Main photo
    • College/University
      • Technological Institute at Kiev
        • present
        • Main photo
      • Heidelberg University
        • present
        • Main photo
      • University of Berlin
        • present
        • Main photo
      • Kiev Institute of Economics
        • present
        • Main photo
      • Oxford University
        • present
        • Main photo
    • Career
      • The Department of Economic Policy of theTrade Unions
        • Location
        • Address
        • mainPhoto
      • Heidelberg University
        • Location
        • Address
        • mainPhoto
      • Frankfurter Zeitung (liberal newspaper)
        • Location
        • Address
        • mainPhoto
      • Kiel Institute
        • Address
        • mainPhoto
      • All Souls College
        • Location
        • Address
        • mainPhoto
      • Oxford Institute of Statistics
      • Cowles Commission for Research in Economics at The University of Chicago
        • Address
        • mainPhoto
      • Yale University
        • Address
        • mainPhoto
      • University of California
        • Address
        • mainPhoto
      • New School for Social Research
        • Address
        • mainPhoto
      • University of Chicago
        • Address
        • mainPhoto
      • Oxford Institute of Statistics
    • Address
    • Family description
    • Membership description
    • Works
      • Archive for the Social Sciences: Wirtschaftsrechnung und Gemeinwirtschaft
        • Link
        • Works description
        • mainPhoto
      • Article in "Grundriss der Nationalökonomik": Der Neue Mittelstand
        • Link
        • Works description
        • mainPhoto
      • Article in "Magazin der Wirtschaft": Das Kaufkraft-Argument in der Lohnpolitik
        • Link
        • Works description
        • mainPhoto
      • article: Die Lohndiskussion
        • Link
        • Works description
        • mainPhoto
      • article: Elastizität der Nachfrage
        • Link
        • Works description
        • mainPhoto
      • Article in "Magazin der Wirtschaft": Annual Survey of Statistical Information
        • Link
        • Works description
        • mainPhoto
      • article: The New Middle Class
        • Link
        • Works description
        • mainPhoto
      • Article in "Econometrica": Money and the Theory of Assets
        • Link
        • Works description
        • mainPhoto
      • Article in "Economica": Assets, Prices and Monetary Theory
        • Link
        • Works description
        • mainPhoto
      • Article in "JPE": A Discussion on Methods in Economics
        • Link
        • Works description
        • mainPhoto
      • Article in " Econometrica": Random Simultaneous Equations and the Theory of Production
        • Link
        • Works description
        • mainPhoto
      • Article in "AER": A Cross-Section of Business Cycle Discussion
        • Link
        • Works description
        • mainPhoto
      • Article in "JPE": Von Neumann's and Morgenstern's New Approach to Static Economics
        • Link
        • Works description
        • mainPhoto
      • Article in "Econometrica": Mathematics for Economists
        • Link
        • Works description
        • mainPhoto
      • Proceedings of the International Statistical Conference: Statistical Inference from Non-Experimental Observation: An Economic Example
        • Link
        • Works description
        • mainPhoto
      • Article in " AER": The Role of Liquidity under Complete and Incomplete Information
        • Link
        • Works description
        • mainPhoto
      • Article in "Econometrica": Rational Behavior, Uncertain Prospects and Measurable Utility
        • Link
        • Works description
        • mainPhoto
      • Article in "Metroeconomica": The Rationale of the Demand for Money and of `Money Illusion
        • Link
        • Works description
        • mainPhoto
      • Article in "Econometrica": Optimal Inventory Policy
        • Link
        • Works description
        • mainPhoto
      • Proceedings of the Second Berkeley Symposium: Why "Should" Statisticians and Businessmen Maximize Moral Expectation?
        • Link
        • Works description
        • mainPhoto
      • lectures: Three Lectures on Probability in the Social Sciences
        • Link
        • Works description
        • mainPhoto
      • book: Towards an Economic Theory of Organization and Information
        • Link
        • Works description
        • mainPhoto
      • book: Note on Some Proposed Decision Criteria
        • Link
        • Works description
        • mainPhoto
      • Article in "Management Science": Elements for a Theory of Teams
        • Link
        • Works description
        • mainPhoto
      • Article in "Measurement Definitions and Theories": Experimental Tests of a Stochastic Decision Theory
        • Link
        • Works description
        • mainPhoto
      • Article in "Modern Organization Theory": Efficient and Viable Organizational Forms
        • Link
        • Works description
        • mainPhoto
      • Bulletin of the AMS: An Identity in Arithmetic
        • Link
        • Works description
        • mainPhoto
      • in Contributions to Probability and Statistics: Random Orderings and Stochastic Theories of Responses
        • Link
        • Works description
        • mainPhoto
      • in Contributions to Scientific Research in Management: Remarks on the Economics of Information
        • Link
        • Works description
        • mainPhoto
      • article: Theory of an Efficient Several-Person Firm
        • Link
        • Works description
        • mainPhoto
      • Article in "Mathematical Methods in the Social Sciences.": Binary-Choice Constraints and Random Utility Indicators
        • Link
        • Works description
        • mainPhoto
      • Article in "AER": Economics of Inquiring, Communicating, Deciding
        • Link
        • Works description
        • mainPhoto
      • article: Economics and Information Systems
        • Link
        • Works description
        • mainPhoto
      • book: Economic Theory of Teams
        • Link
        • Works description
        • mainPhoto
      • book: Economic Information, Decision and Prediction
        • Link
        • Works description
        • mainPhoto
    • Friends & colleagues
      • Richard Abel Musgrave
        • mainPhoto
      • Hans Philip Neisser
        • mainPhoto
      • Franco Modigliani
        • mainPhoto
      • Joseph Schumpeter
        • mainPhoto
      • Emil Lederer
        • mainPhoto
      • Ludwig Heinrich Edler von Mises
        • mainPhoto
    • College/University Description
    • Career Description
    • Personality
    • Quotes from others about the person
    • Physical Characteristics
    Go
    up
    Edit Profile