Alastair Sim (1900–1976) was a Scottish stage and screen actor whose career ranged from Shakespearean roles to British film comedy. He became especially known for Scrooge (1951), while his distinctive comic performances, later stage work, and more than fifty film appearances made him a prominent figure in British entertainment.
Background
Sim was born in Edinburgh, the youngest child and second son of Alexander Sim, a ladies' tailor and clothier, and Isabella (née McIntyre). His father served on several Edinburgh committees and was both a school governor and a justice of the peace. His mother had moved from the Hebridean island of Eigg to Edinburgh as a teenager and spoke Gaelic as her native language.
The family initially lived above Alexander's shop on Lothian Road. As the family's finances improved, they moved to Viewforth in Bruntsfield, a more prosperous part of the city.
Education
Sim attended Bruntsfield Primary School, then received secondary education at James Gillespie's High School and George Heriot's School. In 1918 he entered the University of Edinburgh to study analytical chemistry, but his studies were interrupted when he was called up for army training. He was released after the First World War ended in November 1918 and decided not to return to university, choosing instead to pursue acting.
Before establishing himself as an actor, Sim helped in his father's shop, probably part-time, and worked for the men's outfitters Gieve's, where retail work did not suit him. After leaving home following his decision to abandon university, he spent about a year in the Scottish Highlands with itinerant labourers. Back in Edinburgh, he took a clerical post in the burgh assessor's office. In his spare time he attended poetry-reading classes and won the gold medal for verse speaking at the Edinburgh Music Festival. That success led to teaching elocution at a further-education college in Dalry from 1922 to 1924.
In 1925 Sim became Fulton Lecturer in Elocution at the University of Edinburgh, a post he held for five years. Alongside it, he taught private pupils and established a drama school for children in Edinburgh. He directed productions there and sometimes acted in them. The playwright John Drinkwater, having seen one of the school's productions, encouraged Sim to take up professional acting. Sim made his stage debut in Othello at London's Savoy Theatre in 1930, understudying the three principal male roles played by Paul Robeson, Maurice Browne, and Ralph Richardson, and appearing as the messenger.
His early professional stage work included The Venetian, in which he made his Broadway debut in October 1931, and a sixteen-month engagement with the Old Vic company in 1932–33. There he appeared in ten Shakespeare plays, two each by George Bernard Shaw and Drinkwater, and one by Richard Brinsley Sheridan. In 1934 a slipped disc left him unable to work for several months; osteopathic treatment enabled his recovery. He returned to the West End as Ponsonby, a sycophantic bank director in Youth at the Helm, earning notice for his performance. His film debut followed in The Riverside Murder (1935), as Sergeant McKay.
Further early films included Wedding Group (1936), in which his wife also appeared; The Squeaker (1937), following a stage production; and Alf's Button Afloat and The Terror (both 1938). In the latter he played the revenge-seeking former convict Soapy Marks. From 1939 to 1941 he appeared as the bumbling assistant to Gordon Harker in the Inspector Hornleigh films. His stage work also included appearances at the last Malvern Festival. In James Bridie's What Say They? he played Professor Hayman, beginning a professional association with Bridie that lasted until the playwright's death in 1951. Sim acted in and directed Bridie's plays, including Holy Isle (1942), Mr Bolfry (1943), The Forrigan Reel (1945), Dr Angelus (1947), and Mr Gillie (1950).
From the mid-1940s through much of the 1950s Sim was a leading British film actor. His roles included a police detective in Green for Danger (1946), the headmaster of Nutbourne College in The Happiest Days of Your Life (1950), and a writer of lurid crime fiction in Laughter in Paradise (1951). Other films of this period included Waterloo Road (1944), London Belongs to Me (1948), Stage Fright (1950), Scrooge (1951), and Folly to Be Wise (1953). Scrooge, released in the United States as A Christmas Carol, became one of his best-known performances. He also played the dual parts of headmistress Millicent Fritton and her disreputable brother Clarence in The Belles of St. Trinian's (1954). He had initially accepted the role of Clarence, then agreed to play Miss Fritton when Margaret Rutherford could not take the part and director and co-producer Frank Launder found no suitable replacement.
Sim declined the role of Joseph Macroon in Whisky Galore! (1949), explaining that he could not bear “professional Scotsmen.” Professor Marcus in The Ladykillers (1955) was written with him in mind, but Alec Guinness took the part; Mark Duguid later observed that Guinness's performance carried a strong resemblance to Sim's style, and Simpson noted that viewers have sometimes attributed the role to Sim. Sim's film and television production The Anatomist first appeared on television in 1956 and was released theatrically in the United States in 1961. He remained among Britain's leading film stars in the early and middle 1950s, although critic Michael Brooke regarded many of his later-1950s films as weaker because of their scripts or direction. He made no films from 1961 through 1970; Brooke suggested that he may have rejected the available scripts, while Simpson proposed that filmmakers considered him unsuited to the kitchen-sink dramas then in vogue.
After Bridie's death, Sim appeared in only two stage productions during the rest of the 1950s: a 1956 revival of Mr Bolfry, in which he switched from the puritanical clergyman to the Devil, and William Golding's The Brass Butterfly (1958), playing an urbane Roman emperor opposite George Cole. In 1959 he sued H. J. Heinz over a baked-beans television advertisement whose voice sounded remarkably like his own. He objected to using his art to advertise a product, but lost the case and was ridiculed by some observers. He was conscious of his voice's importance to his acting career; Michael Brooke later called it his “crowning glory” and praised its tonal control and sensitivity to English speech.
Sim returned to frequent stage work in the 1960s. His roles ranged from Prospero in The Tempest (1962) and Shylock in The Merchant of Venice (1964) to Captain Hook in Peter Pan (1963, 1964, and 1968) and Mr Posket in The Magistrate (1969). He directed the productions of Michael Gilbert's Windfall (1963), William Trevor's The Elephant's Foot (1965), and Ronald Millar's Number Ten (1967), in which he also acted. Critics found fault with the plays, but The Times praised the comic force of his performance in Windfall. Two particularly successful appearances were The Clandestine Marriage at the Chichester Festival in 1966 and The Magistrate. His other stage engagements included Too True to Be Good, Siege, A Private Matter, and The Jockey Club Stakes. He played Augustin Jedd in Dandy Dick at Chichester and later in the West End, and made his last stage appearance as Lord Ogleby in a new Savoy production of The Clandestine Marriage in April 1975.
On television, Sim played Mr Justice Swallow in Misleading Cases (1967–71), with Roy Dotrice as the litigious Mr Haddock. Sim returned to cinema as the voice of Scrooge in the 1971 animated A Christmas Carol. His later screen work included The Ruling Class (1972), Royal Flash (1975), Escape from the Dark (1976), and the 1976 remake of Rogue Male. His last role was the Earl in Rogue Male, opposite Peter O'Toole; despite being ill, he got out of bed to perform, saying, “Peter needs me.”
Sim was elected Rector of the University of Edinburgh in 1948 and served until 1951. He was appointed Commander of the Order of the British Empire in 1953 and declined a knighthood in the early 1970s. An English Heritage blue plaque was unveiled at his former Hampstead home in July 2008 by his daughter, Merlith McKendrick, at a ceremony attended by George Cole. A separate plaque commemorates his birth outside the Filmhouse Cinema on Lothian Road in Edinburgh. Sim died in London on 19 August 1976, aged 75, from complications of lung cancer.
Sim became one of the leading British film actors of the early and middle 1950s, appearing in more than fifty British films over the course of his career.
His performance as Ebenezer Scrooge in the 1951 film became one of the best-known screen portrayals of the character.
Sim was elected Rector of the University of Edinburgh for 1948–1951 and received an honorary Doctor of Laws when he left the post.
(Film series, 1939–1941, in which Sim played Gordon Harker...)
1939
play
The Clandestine Marriage
(Sim appeared with Margaret Rutherford in the Chichester F...)
1966
The Magistrate
(Pinero farce in which Sim played Mr Posket; the productio...)
1969
Othello
(Stage production at the Savoy Theatre; Sim played the mes...)
1930
Mr Bolfry
(James Bridie play in which Sim acted and directed; he lat...)
1943
The Brass Butterfly
(William Golding comedy in which Sim played an urbane Roma...)
1958
Dandy Dick
(Pinero farce in which Sim played Augustin Jedd at Chiches...)
What Say They?
(James Bridie comedy in which Sim played Professor Hayman ...)
As You Like It
(Shakespeare play in which Sim played Duke Senior with the...)
Hamlet
(Shakespeare play in which Sim played Claudius with the Ol...)
The Venetian
(Clifford Bax play; Sim made his Broadway debut in this pr...)
1931
Peter Pan
(Sim played Captain Hook in productions in 1963, 1964, and...)
1963
Windfall
(Michael Gilbert play in which Sim acted and directed.)
1963
The Elephant's Foot
(William Trevor play in which Sim acted and directed.)
1965
Number Ten
(Ronald Millar play in which Sim acted and directed.)
1967
Holy Isle
(James Bridie play in which Sim acted and directed.)
1942
The Forrigan Reel
(James Bridie play in which Sim acted and directed.)
1945
Dr Angelus
(James Bridie play in which Sim acted and directed.)
1947
Mr Gillie
(James Bridie play in which Sim acted and directed.)
1950
Youth at the Helm
(West End comedy in which Sim played Ponsonby.)
Too True to Be Good
(Stage work in which Sim appeared.)
Siege
(Stage work in which Sim appeared.)
A Private Matter
(Stage work in which Sim appeared.)
The Jockey Club Stakes
(Stage work in which Sim appeared.)
The Tempest
(Sim played Prospero.)
1962
The Merchant of Venice
(Sim played Shylock.)
1964
television play
The Anatomist
(Sim appeared in the television production, first broadcas...)
1956
TV series
Misleading Cases
(Television comedy series, 1967–1971; Sim played Mr Justic...)
1967
Membership
Sim belonged to the Garrick Club, a London club associated with the theatrical world.
Garrick Club
,
United Kingdom
Personality
Sim and his family guarded their privacy. He rarely gave interviews and refused to sign autographs, believing that public judgment should rest on his performances rather than publicity. He maintained this view in a rare interview, saying that publicity could neither rescue a poor performance nor diminish a good one.
He and Naomi encouraged younger actors, offering George Cole and other young people a welcoming home at Forrigan. His professional range encompassed classical drama, farce, television comedy, and film, while his distinctive voice was a defining feature of his performances.
Physical Characteristics:
Sim had a slipped disc in 1934 that temporarily incapacitated him; osteopathic treatment enabled him to return to work.
Quotes from others about the person
The Times praised Sim and George Devine for giving their dukes in As You Like It a suitably magical quality. Ivor Brown found Sim's Claudius in Hamlet slyly roguish and vividly alive, and called his Ponsonby in Youth at the Helm a delightful blend of contrasting qualities. The Manchester Guardian described his Professor Hayman in What Say They? as both ominous and lean, and judged it a fine performance.
J. C. Trewin praised Sim's work in The Clandestine Marriage as enchantingly apt. Michael Brooke singled out the control and musicality of Sim's voice, comparing its tonal sensitivity with that of John Gielgud. In his final film role, Sim explained his return to work by saying, “Peter needs me.”
Interests
Sim's documented interests included poetry reading and verse speaking. His gold-medal performance at the Edinburgh Music Festival helped lead him into teaching elocution.
Connections
Sim married Naomi Plaskitt, a former pupil at his drama school, on 2 August 1932. They had a daughter, Merlith Naomi, who later lived with her family at Forrigan, the woodland retreat the couple built near Henley-on-Thames in 1947. Naomi and Alastair supported young acting talent. George Cole, one of their protégés, lived with them intermittently from 1940, when he was 15, until 1952; he later married and settled nearby. Cole appeared with Sim in eight films, from Cottage to Let (1941) to Blue Murder at St Trinian's (1957). Naomi's 1999 obituary recalled that several other young people, many unhappy at home, were welcomed at Forrigan. Naomi Sim published a memoir of their life together, Dance and Skylark: Fifty Years with Alastair Sim, in 1987; she died on 3 August 1999.
Father:
Alexander Sim
Ladies' tailor and clothier, Edinburgh committee member, school governor, and justice of the peace.
Mother:
Isabella McIntyre
Native Gaelic speaker who moved from Eigg to Edinburgh as a teenager.
Wife:
Naomi Plaskitt
Actress and former pupil of Sim; they married in 1932 and encouraged young acting talent together. She published Dance and Skylark: Fifty Years with Alastair Sim in 1987.
Daughter:
Merlith Naomi Sim
Later known as Merlith McKendrick; she unveiled a blue plaque commemorating her father at his former Hampstead home in 2008.
colleague:
George Cole
Young actor whom Sim and Naomi encouraged; Cole lived with the couple intermittently from 1940 to 1952 and appeared with Sim in eight films.
colleague:
John Drinkwater
Playwright who encouraged Sim to enter the professional theatre and whose plays Sim performed with the Old Vic company.
colleague:
James Bridie
Playwright whose professional association with Sim lasted from 1939 until Bridie's death in 1951; Sim acted in and directed several of his plays.
colleague:
Margaret Rutherford
Actor who appeared with Sim in The Happiest Days of Your Life and The Clandestine Marriage.
colleague:
Peter O'Toole
Co-star in The Ruling Class and Rogue Male; Sim returned to work for his last screen role, saying, “Peter needs me.”