Career
He is also said to have been one of the first to have consistently thrown to second base without coming out of the squat. Baseball writers Harry Daniels and Jimmy Smith both put Petway on their 1909 "All-American Team" saying as a catcher he was "the greatest since Arthur Thomas"s time."
Petway left a career in medicine to pursue baseball, playing for a number of Negro League teams, most notably the Leland Giants (1906, 1910), Philadelphia Giants (1907–1909), (1911–1918), and the Detroit Stars (1919–1925). While playing in Cuba in 1910, he reportedly threw Ty Cobb out three times, in three attempts to steal.
That year, he batted.390, showing off his hitting skills as well.
He also led the Cuban League in stolen bases in 1912, when he picked up 20, a rarity for a catcher even at the time. Petway traveled with the 1913 when they toured the United States.
He remained with the team until he moved to the Detroit Stars in 1919. He played with the Stars into the 1920s when he continued to post solid numbers, while simultaneously managing the team, as many stars did in that day.
With Detroit, he played with such greats as Pete Hill and future New York Black Yankees" star Bill Holland.
