Career
Sheffield United
Born in Burton upon Trent, Staffordshire, McAughtrie began his professional career as a trainee with Sheffield United, he joined the club on 1 August 1997, but failed to force his way into the first team He spent three seasons on the books at United, but left at the end of the 1999–2000 season, without making a first team appearance. Carlisle United
On 5 August 2000, McAughtrie joined Carlisle United.
He was not a regular with Carlisle, and during a two-year stint he made 10 appearances and scored once.
McAughtrie was released Carlisle at the end of the 2001-2002 season. Stafford Rangers
In the summer of 2002, McAughtrie made a move to Stafford Rangers of the Southern Football League Premier Division.
Since the arrival of former Northampton Town defender Fred Murray on 28 August, McAughtrie found first team chances hard to come by. Tamworth
On 13 September 2007, McAughtrie signed for Conference North side Tamworth for an undisclosed fee.
On 18 May 2009, McAughtrie was released by Tamworth, along with teammates Dean Lea and Callum Burgess.
Later career
After leaving Tamworth, McAughtrie had a spell at King"s Lynn and Eastwood Town before returning to Stafford Rangers in 2010. Hinckley United
After Stafford were relegated, McAughtrie signed for Hinckley United in June 2011. But after failing to establish himself at the club he was loaned out to lower league Mickleover Sports for the remainder of the season.
McAughtrie is a policeman, and it was suggested that he would struggle with the extra commitments and travelling following the clubs promotion to the Conference National.
Stafford Rangers
Conference North play-offs: 2005-2006
Tamworth
Conference North: 2008-2009.
