In 1896 she lost the all-comers final in three sets to Alice Pickering. In her last two Wimbledon appearances in 1913 and 1919 she also played in the doubles and mixed doubles events. Arbuthnot failed to convert two matchpoints.
The following year, 1895, she lost her title in the challenge round to Charlotte Cooper.
In 1896 she was a runner-up at the South of England Championships in Eastbourne, losing the final to Blanche Bingley Hillyard in three sets.
Between 1893 and 1919 she participated 16 times in the single event of the Wimbledon Championships and achieved her best result in 1894 and 1896 when she reached the final of the all-comers tournament. She won the singles title at the Kent Championships on six occasions (1894-1897, 1899, 1900). In 1894 she defeated May Arbuthnot in a three-set final to win the singles title of the British Covered Court Championships, played on wood courts at the Queen"s Club in London. From 1896 to 1899 she won four consecutive titles, defeating Cooper twice in the final. In 1894, 1899 and 1901 she won the Queen"s Club Championships grass court tournament.
In 1894 she lost to Blanche Bingley Hillyard in straight sets, winning just two games and Bingley Hillyard became champions as the title holder Lottie Dod did not defend her title.
