Career
Born Edward Phinney in Washington, District of Columbia, the 5-foot-9-inch (175 cm) middleweight fought out of Boston and Cambridge, Massachusetts during his career. He was known a clever fighter whose punch carried a sting. They had been scheduled to box 13 rounds, but the fight was scored a draw after the 13th.
Binney took the title from The Black Pearl on November 30, 1891 in San Francisco, California.
On February 29, 1892, The Black Pearl fought Charley Turner, "The Stockton Cyclone", and was defeated. Binney was considered the lineal champ.
He had also defeated the Negro Middleweight title holder. Binney lost his title on November 13, 1892 in Philadelphia to Joe Butler.