Career
He served as the head football coach at Saint Norbert College from 1934 to 1942 and at Carroll College—now known as Carroll University—in Waukesha, Wisconsin from 1949 to 1957, compiling a career college football record of 69–57–9. McCormick was also the head basketball coach at Saint Norbert from 1934 to 1943 and again during the 1944-1945 season, tallying a mark of 62–74. He was one of the more outspoken coaches against the National Collegiate Athletic Association rule change on "free substitution" in 1953.
Marquette
McCormick played college football and was a forward on the basketball team at Marquette University.
Duluth Eskimos
Saint Norbert
McCormick coached at Saint Norbert College in De Pere, Wisconsin starting with the 1934 season until the conclusion of the 1942 season. His record with the Green Knights was a total of 32 wins, 26 losses, and 8 ties and included a 7–1 season in 1936.
Also at Saint Norbert, McCormick was the head basketball coach. Carroll
McCormick the 20th head football coach for the Carroll College Pioneers (now called "Carroll University") located in Waukesha, Wisconsin and he held that position for nine seasons, from 1949 until 1957.
His career coaching record at Carroll College was 37 wins, 31 losses, and 1 tie.
This ranks him fourth at Carroll College in total wins and 11th at Carroll College in winning percentage. Carroll would be his last coaching position as he died in August 1958 before the season began, but the school would later induct him into their "Athletic Hall of Fame" for his contributions to the school and athletic programs. Highlights of his coaching at Caroll included a strong offense in the 1951 season.
McCormick began the 1949 season with twenty eager players that were considered "strong on talent but weak on depth" with team drills beginning in early September 1949.
He felt that his most talented team was 1955, a team he called the best Carroll had in ten years. McCormick was selected to coach the "South" team for the 1951 Upper Peninsula All-Star Football exhibition game.
Free substitution
In 1953, McCormick was outspoken among the small-college football coaches against the idea of free substitution in college football. Becoming more common in professional football, the idea paved the way of the "specialist athlete" in college football where one person could focus on one position such as quarterback or punter.
Foreign large colleges and professional teams, the idea of free substitution worked well.
McCormick pointed out that smaller colleges would suffer under this rule. Free substitution generally prevented a player from returning to gameplay in the same quarter after he was taken out for a substitute and it required either a very large squad that could handle all the substitutions or a highly talented small squad that would not need to substitute. McCormick was a 1929 graduate of Antigo High School in his hometown of Antigo, Wisconsin.