Career
Alderdice"s first term as Prime Minister was short-lived, however, as his government lost that year"s general election to the Liberals led by Sir Richard Squires. Alderdice joined with Liberals dissatisfied with Squires to form the United Newfoundland Party with himself as leader. The Great Depression embroiled the dominion in a severe economic crisis which was compounded by corruption in the Squires government taking the dominion to the brink of bankruptcy.
Widespread unemployment added to the crisis and resulted in an anti-government riot in Saint John"s on April 5, 1932.
The Squires government collapsed and Alderdice swept to power in the ensuing June election on the promise that if elected, his government would examine the possibility of suspending the constitution and having a commission administer the country until conditions improved. The Alderdice government was unable to deal with the economic crisis and proposed a partial default on the dominion"s debts.
Britain and Canada (whose currency was shared by Newfoundland) agreed to give the dominion financial aid in exchange for the creation of an Imperial Royal Commission to investigate the dominion"s future. The Commission recommended the suspension of responsible government and the institution of an appointed Commission of Government to rule the dominion.
Alderdice was pressured by the British to accept the recommendations without calling a new election or submitting the proposals to a referendum.
Alderdice agreed and, at the end of 1933, the legislature voted to accept the recommendations and voted itself out of existence. Alderdice was appointed to the Commission of Government when it was established in February 1934 and served as Commissioner for Home Affairs and Education in the new Commission of Government as well as Vice-Chairman until his death in 1936.