George Pell was an Australian Catholic cardinal, priest, and author who served as Archbishop of Melbourne and Sydney and became the Vatican’s first prefect for the economy. A prominent advocate of Catholic orthodoxy, he also led church initiatives and faced extensive scrutiny over clergy abuse cases. His 2018 criminal convictions were quashed by the High Court of Australia in 2020; he died in Rome in 2023.
Background
Pell was born in Ballarat, Victoria, to George Arthur Pell and Margaret Lillian Pell, née Burke. His father, a heavyweight boxing champion and non-practising Anglican, had ancestors from Leicestershire, England. His mother was a devout Catholic of Irish descent.
As a child, Pell underwent 24 operations to remove an abscess in his throat.
Education
Pell attended Loreto Convent and St Patrick’s College in Ballarat. At St Patrick’s he played Australian rules football as a ruckman in the school’s first XVIII from 1956 to 1959 and reportedly signed with the Richmond Football Club in 1959. He later turned his ambitions toward the priesthood. Recalling his decision to enter seminary, he said he gradually became convinced that God wanted him to do His work and that he could not escape that conviction.
In 1960, Pell began priesthood studies at Corpus Christi College, then located in Werribee. He continued playing football and served as class prefect in his second and third years. In 1963 he was assigned to continue his studies at the Pontifical Urban University in Rome. He was ordained to the diaconate on 15 August 1966.
Pell received a Licentiate of Sacred Theology from the Pontifical Urban University in 1967. He then studied at the University of Oxford, earning a doctorate in church history in 1971 with a thesis on the exercise of authority in early Christianity from about 170 to about 270. While at Oxford, he served as chaplain to Catholic students at Eton College. He later earned a Master of Education degree from Monash University in Melbourne in 1982.
Pell was ordained a priest at St Peter’s Basilica in Rome on 16 December 1966 by Cardinal Gregorio Pietro Agagianian. He returned to Australia in 1971 and served as an assistant priest in Swan Hill for two years. From 1973 to 1983 he worked at a parish in Ballarat East and in 1984 became administrator of the parish of Bungaree. He was Episcopal Vicar for Education in the Diocese of Ballarat from 1973 to 1984, directed the Aquinas campus of the Institute of Catholic Education from 1974 to 1984, and was principal of the institute from 1981 to 1984. He edited the diocesan newspaper Light from 1979 to 1984. From 1985 to 1987 he led Corpus Christi College as rector.
Pell became an auxiliary bishop of Melbourne and titular bishop of Scala in 1987. Archbishop Frank Little consecrated him on 21 May, assisted by bishops Ronald Mulkearns and Joseph O’Connell. Pell was Bishop for Melbourne’s Southern Region from 1987 to 1996 and also served as a parish priest in Mentone. He became Archbishop of Melbourne in July 1996, received the pallium from Pope John Paul II in June 1997, and was appointed Archbishop of Sydney in 2001. He received the pallium again that June. The Sydney archbishop also serves as visitor of St John’s College, a residential college at the University of Sydney.
Soon after taking office in Melbourne, Pell consulted Victoria’s premier, governor, and retired judge Richard McGarvie about responses to child sexual-abuse complaints. He commissioned Corrs to prepare a scheme funded by, but operating independently of, the archdiocese. A public forum took place on 19 October 1996, and the resulting Melbourne Response was announced on 30 October, inviting victims to come forward. Its elements included independent commissioners to investigate complaints and recommend action, the Carelink counselling service, and a panel advising on ex-gratia payments. Compensation was initially capped at $50,000; the ceiling became $55,000 in 2000 and $75,000 in 2008. The first independent commissioner, Peter O’Callaghan, investigated 351 complaints and upheld 97 percent. This Melbourne initiative preceded the Australian Catholic Bishops’ Conference’s national Towards Healing process, approved in November 1996 and implemented from March 1997. The Melbourne Response later faced criticism for legalism and insufficient victim support.
Pell chaired Caritas Australia, part of Caritas Internationalis, from 1988 to 1997 and served on the National Catholic Commission during those years. He was pro-chancellor of the Australian Catholic University Foundation from 1991 to 1995 and secretary of the bishops’ education committee from 1994 to 1997. He was a delegate to the Australian Constitutional Convention in 1998. His Vatican appointments included consultor to the Pontifical Council for Justice and Peace from 1990 to 1995 and membership from 2002, as well as membership of the Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith from 1990 to 2000. In April 2002 John Paul II made him president of Vox Clara, which advised on English translations of liturgical texts. Pell had previously been a consultor to the Pontifical Council for the Family and became a member in December 2002. He joined the Congregation for Bishops in September 2012 and was appointed a papally selected Synod Father for the October 2012 Synod of Bishops on the New Evangelization. In September 2014 he joined the Congregation for the Evangelization of Peoples.
Pope John Paul II announced in September 2003 that Pell would be among 29 new cardinals. At the October consistory Pell became cardinal priest of Santa Maria Domenica Mazzarello. Australia then had three cardinals eligible to vote in a papal election: Pell, Edward Bede Clancy, and Edward Idris Cassidy. Pell took part in the 2005 conclave that elected Joseph Ratzinger as Pope Benedict XVI. He was said to have acted as an unauthorized campaign manager for Ratzinger and was mentioned as a possible successor to Benedict as head of the Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith. In February 2007 Pell set rules for funeral addresses: a eulogy was not to displace the celebrant’s homily, which was to center on scripture, God’s compassion, and Jesus’s resurrection.
Pell campaigned for Sydney to host World Youth Day in 2008. The event brought about half a million young people from 200 countries and drew roughly one million people to see Benedict XVI during his first papal visit to Australia. During the visit, Benedict publicly expressed regret to people harmed by sexual abuse by Catholic clergy, marking his first apology of that kind. In their 2010 Good Friday sermons, Pell and Anglican Archbishop Peter Jensen criticized atheism; they were also aligned on several policy questions, and Jensen launched Pell’s biography. Pell hosted iftar dinners marking Ramadan’s end in 2012 and 2013. In 2009 he accepted the Oxford University Newman Society’s invitation to become its patron and delivered the inaugural St Thomas More Lecture on 6 March.
Pell’s public comments addressed climate, the environment, and population. In a 2006 speech he associated extreme environmental claims with what he called the pagan emptiness of Western culture, comparing demands to cut carbon emissions with ancient offerings intended to appease deities. A 2007 newspaper article acknowledged that climate changes but rejected what he considered extravagant forecasts of imminent human-caused catastrophe, on the grounds that evidence was insufficient. In response to Anglican environmentalist George Browning, Pell argued that environmental campaigners could promote their moral agenda without church leaders and that Christian leaders should engage with reality and challenge claims they considered unsupported. At World Youth Day’s opening Mass in July 2008, he said humanity must not ruin or exploit the environment at future generations’ expense, while disputing that human activity was driving climate change. He identified slower population growth and indifference to God as major challenges for the Church, and said Western countries were not having enough children to maintain stable populations. Sustainable Population Australia disputed his account using Australian population-growth and birth figures; economist Jeffrey Sachs argued that global pressures on food, energy, and land were already severe and questioned projections of further population growth. In 2015 Pell criticized Pope Francis’s encyclical Laudato si’ for involving the Church in climate policy, saying it lacked particular scientific expertise and a mandate to pronounce on science.
In 2001 Pell argued that monotheism had nearly been overwhelmed by Baal’s followers in Elijah’s time. In 2009 he favored the priest facing east with the congregation during the Canon of the Mass as a principle, while emphasizing that there was no immediate consensus to adopt the practice. Pell’s Sydney archbishopric ended in 2014, when he left Australia for Rome. His final sermon in Sydney included another apology to victims and their families and acknowledged that church procedures could be improved. His stated anticipation of the Royal Commission’s findings was criticized as lacking empathy. In a 2012 Christmas address he had expressed shock and shame at the abuse and wrongdoing and urged people to assist those harmed.
Pope Francis appointed Pell in February 2014 as the inaugural prefect of the newly established Secretariat for the Economy, giving him responsibility for the Holy See’s annual budget. In July, with Francis’s approval, the Ordinary Section of the Administration of the Patrimony of the Apostolic See was transferred to the Secretariat so it could exercise economic oversight; APSA staff who remained were to concentrate on treasury functions for the Holy See and Vatican City State. After the Pope confirmed the Institute for the Works of Religion’s mission in April, the Vatican Bank’s next development plan was entrusted to a new executive team led by Jean-Baptiste de Franssu. In November Pell’s Secretariat circulated financial-management guidance to Vatican offices, effective 1 January 2015, intended to align practices with international standards and make reports more consistent and transparent. Cardinal Francesco Coccopalmerio questioned the Secretariat’s authority and Pell’s role in consolidating management. In June 2016 the Vatican said Pell would remain prefect despite the customary resignation at age 75 and emphasized Francis’s confidence in him. His five-year prefecture ended on 24 February 2019. Pell also sat on Francis’s Council of Cardinal Advisers from 2013 to 2018. In December 2018 the Pope announced that Pell and two other senior cardinals would leave the council after their terms and thanked them for their work.
Pell lobbied for Sydney’s World Youth Day, and in May 2001 his installation as Archbishop of Sydney brought renewed public attention to his positions on sexuality, marriage, and family life. He argued that church teaching on sexuality was essential to human well-being and the flourishing of families. He opposed same-sex relationships and adoption by same-sex couples, spoke against ending clerical celibacy and women’s ordination, and supported discouraging divorce, especially where children were involved. He proposed consideration of measures to deter divorce and support couples who stayed together. In 1998, as Archbishop of Melbourne, he refused communion to Rainbow Sash Movement members attending Mass and rebuked them. In 2006 he opposed proposed legislation allowing same-sex couples to adopt, and in 2007 said discrimination against LGBT people was not comparable to racial discrimination. In 2009 he backed Benedict XVI’s position that abstinence and monogamy, rather than condom distribution, were the answer to AIDS; when Benedict later called condom use a possible first step toward reducing infection risk, Pell said this did not amount to a major shift in Vatican policy. He supported adult stem-cell research but opposed embryonic research involving destruction of human life. After New South Wales parliamentarians voted in 2007 to permit therapeutic cloning, Pell warned Catholic politicians that their votes had consequences for their place in the Church. Politicians condemned his remarks, and Greens MLC Lee Rhiannon referred them to the parliamentary privileges committee. Pell called the referral an effort to restrict religious freedom and free speech. The committee cleared him in September and recommended no further action. Legal scholar and theologian Cathleen Kaveny judged that his intervention backfired: the bill passed both houses by substantial margins.
Pell welcomed the federal Royal Commission into Institutional Responses to Child Sexual Abuse, established in late 2012, as an opportunity to aid victims and clarify events, while also alleging a persistent press campaign against the Church. He testified three times: in Sydney in March 2014, by video link from the Vatican in August 2014, and by video link in February and March 2016. In 2013 he appeared before Victoria’s parliamentary inquiry into the handling of child abuse by religious and other organizations. He said he was fully apologetic and sorry, and agreed that his predecessor had covered up matters for fear of scandal. A former pupil alleged Pell had heard him seek help weeks after a 1969 assault at St Alipius Primary School; Pell denied the claim. NewsCorp outlets later said his passport showed that he had not been living in Australia that year. During Pell’s Sydney tenure, allegations were made against about 55 priests, largely concerning events before he became archbishop, and reparations totaled just under $8 million.
The seal of confession became a point of public debate alongside the Royal Commission. Pell said abuse disclosed outside confession could be reported to police, but insisted that the sacramental seal could not be broken. He advised that a priest who knew beforehand about abuse should refuse to hear the confession, and said he would not hear a suspected abuser’s confession. The statement drew disapproval; Catholic politician Barry O’Farrell told Parliament that confessions should not be secret. Pell’s Commission appearances attracted intense public interest, and he was heckled from the galleries. He complained of unfair media treatment and relentless attacks on his character. SBS journalist Debi Marshall raised claims that Pell had ignored reports of physical and sexual abuse and attempted to bribe a victim. Counsel assisting Gail Furness questioned Pell about David Ridsdale’s allegation of a 1993 bribe. Furness later said the claim was unlikely to reflect Pell’s intent, since Pell knew Gerald Ridsdale was already under police investigation and David had asked for a private process rather than proposing to go to police.
In 2014 the Royal Commission heard that lawyers representing Pell and the Archdiocese of Sydney had incurred A$1.5 million in costs against survivor John Ellis while vigorously contesting his case despite warnings about Ellis’s fragile psychological condition. The resulting New South Wales Court of Appeal ruling, known as the Ellis Defence, held that the Church could not be sued as a legal entity for a priest’s abuse; Ellis eventually received $568,000 from the Church. Pell changed his earlier position in support of the defence, saying the Australian Church should be open to suit in such cases. He compared institutional responsibility to that of a trucking firm whose driver molested someone contrary to company policy. Cathy Kezelman of Adults Surviving Child Abuse called the comparison outrageous, Nicky Davis of the Survivors Network of those Abused by Priests described it as highly offensive, and ABC commentator Michael Bradley criticized it as insensitive and as evading the Church’s responsibility.
Pell appeared by video link from a Rome hotel before the Royal Commission in February and March 2016 because his doctors considered his heart condition too serious for him to fly to Australia. Commission chair Peter McClellan excused in-person testimony; survivor advocate Nicky Davis opposed the decision, and counsel Paul O’Dwyer renewed a request to make Pell’s medical records public. A crowdfunding appeal to send 15 survivors to Rome reached its A$55,000 target within a day, doubled the following day, and trebled the day after. Tim Minchin wrote and recorded “Come Home (Cardinal Pell),” directing proceeds to the appeal; within a day the video had exceeded 400,000 views and the song had reached the top of Australia’s iTunes chart. Fifteen survivors and supporters watched the testimony. After taking an oath on the Bible, Pell said the Church’s institutional structure was not the source of abuse, but acknowledged grave mistakes and failures. He said credible complaints had sometimes been dismissed in scandalous circumstances, described the institutional instinct as protecting the Church, and called the handling of Gerald Ridsdale disastrous for both victims and the Church. He also said that, at the time, he had tended to accept a priest’s denial. Counsel assisting said he understated the broader failings of the Church hierarchy in Australia, Rome, and elsewhere.
Pell had served as assistant priest at St Alipius’ Church in Ballarat East and shared a house with Gerald Ridsdale in 1973. Ridsdale was later convicted from 1993 to 2017 of sexual abuse and indecent assault against children in the 1970s and 1980s; his 79 known victims were thought to be only part of the total. Pell was among Ballarat priests who met in 1982 to discuss moving Ridsdale from Mortlake to Sydney. Pell denied knowing about Ridsdale’s crimes. Asked in 2016 why he had accompanied Ridsdale to court in 1993, Pell said he had been invited in the hope his status as an auxiliary bishop might reduce the sentence. Survivor advocate and former priest Peter Saunders said the explanation showed what Saunders considered Pell’s callousness and contempt for victims. In 2002 David Ridsdale, Gerald’s nephew and a survivor, alleged that Pell had offered him a bribe in 1993 to prevent public disclosure. Furness later considered that an inducement was unlikely, given the police investigation and David’s request for private handling. The Royal Commission also considered reports concerning Edward Dowlan. A witness said he had visited Pell’s Ballarat presbytery to warn him; Pell submitted that he did not live there or in Ballarat at the time, and counsel assisting said Pell’s evidence about his residence and duties in 1973–74 made his presence there on a weekday afternoon less likely.
The Commission’s findings about Pell were completed by 2017 and released on 7 May 2020, after his criminal case concluded. It found that he knew of clergy abuse by the 1970s but did not take adequate action; Pell said the conclusions lacked evidentiary support. In relation to Ridsdale, the Commission concluded that in 1973 Pell considered whether it was prudent for Ridsdale to take boys on overnight camps, and was conscious of clergy abuse and the risk of circumstances that could provoke gossip. Concerning Peter Searson, it found that Pell should have advised the Archbishop in 1989 to remove him in light of information Pell had received. The grievances included harassment of children, parents, and school staff; unnecessary use of children’s toilets; showing children a dead body; and cruelty to animals. The Commission rejected Pell’s claim that education officials had misled him. Pell removed Searson in 1997, after becoming archbishop. Regarding Wilfred James Baker, the Commission found that Pell could have removed him in August 1996, when he learned Baker was about to be charged, but did not do so until May 1997. Baker remained a priest at a parish with a primary school in the intervening period and was imprisoned for child sexual abuse in 1999.
In June 2002 Phil Scott, a Melbourne man, accused Pell of abusing him at a Catholic youth camp in 1961, when Scott was 12 and Pell a seminarian. Pell denied the accusation and stood aside during the inquiry. Scott pursued the matter through the Church’s National Committee for Professional Standards. Retired Supreme Court Justice Alec Southwell, appointed by the Church to investigate, considered Scott generally convincing as a speaker recalling events, but found the complaint unestablished in view of the long delay, difficulties for the defence, questions about credibility, lack of corroboration, and Pell’s sworn denial. Pell said the finding exonerated him; Scott’s solicitor said Scott had been vindicated.
Victoria Police began Operation Tethering in March 2013 to examine possible unreported crimes by Pell. With no complainants at first, police sought them through newspaper notices and received complaints in 2014. In February 2016 the Herald Sun reported that the SANO Taskforce had investigated allegations involving between five and ten boys, concerning events from 1978 to 2001 during Pell’s priesthood in Ballarat and his Melbourne archbishopric. His office denied the claims and sought an inquiry into police leaks; police initially would not say whether he was under investigation. Chief Commissioner Graham Ashton confirmed an investigation in July 2016 and said he was awaiting advice from the Director of Public Prosecutions. Police disclosed in August that advice had arrived but not its recommendations. Three SANO officers travelled to Rome in October to interview Pell, who cooperated voluntarily. Police said in February 2017 that the evidence brief had gone back to the Office of Public Prosecutions, which supplied advice in May.
As Archbishop of Melbourne, established the Melbourne Response in 1996, an early church protocol using independent commissioners, counselling and support, and a compensation panel to address child sexual-abuse complaints. The system was later criticized for its legalistic approach and inadequate support for victims.
Helped secure Sydney's hosting of World Youth Day in 2008, an event that brought approximately half a million young people from 200 countries and about one million people to see Pope Benedict XVI.
As inaugural prefect of the Vatican Secretariat for the Economy, oversaw the transfer of the Ordinary Section of APSA to the new Secretariat and issued financial-management guidance intended to standardize reporting and bring Vatican financial practices in line with international standards.
(Edited by Tess Livingstone and published by Connor Court.)
2010
Catholicism in Australia
(Published in Bundoora, Victoria, by La Trobe University.)
1988
The Sisters of St Joseph in Swan Hill 1922–72
(Book on the Sisters of St Joseph in Swan Hill.)
1972
Rerum Novarum – One Hundred Years Later
(Work published by Boston University.)
1992
collected writings
Pell Contra Mundum
(Edited by Robert A. Sirico, with contributions by Oswald ...)
2023
essay collection
Be not afraid: collected writing
(Collection of homilies and reflections, edited by Tess Li...)
2004
God and Caesar: Selected Essays on Religion, Politics, and Society
(Selected essays, edited by M. A. Casey and published by C...)
2007
journal
Prison Journal, Volume Two: The State Court Rejects the Appeal, 14 July 2019–30 November 2019
(Second volume of Pell's prison journal, published by Igna...)
2021
Prison Journal, Volume One: The Cardinal Makes His Appeal, 27 February–13 July 2019
(First volume of Pell's prison journal, published by Ignat...)
2020
Prison Journal, Volume Three: The High Court Frees an Innocent Man
(Third volume of Pell's prison journal, published by Ignat...)
2021
lecture
Catholicism and the Architecture of Freedom
(The inaugural Acton Lecture on Religion and Freedom, publ...)
1999
master's thesis
An Evaluation of the Goal of Moral Autonomy in the Theory and Practice of Lawrence Kohlberg
(Master of Education thesis submitted at Monash University...)
1982
pamphlet
Bread, Stones or Fairy Floss: Religious Education Today
(Pamphlet on religious education, published in Melbourne b...)
1977
Are our secondary schools Catholic?
(Pamphlet published in Melbourne by Australian Catholic Tr...)
1979
Religion
Pell was a Roman Catholic priest and cardinal whose public teaching emphasized adherence to Catholic doctrine, worship, service, and religious duty. He defended Church teaching on the priesthood, marriage, sexuality, and bioethics; opposed women’s ordination and ending priestly celibacy; and supported ad orientem celebration of the Mass in principle, though not as an immediate proposal. In a 2012 discussion of Adam and Eve, he called their story a sophisticated mythological account of creation, humanity, evil, and suffering rather than a scientific explanation.
He described a Catholic as someone who believes Christ is the Son of God, accepts Christ’s teachings, and lives through worship, service, and duty in the community, rather than someone who remains Catholic merely through ancestry. Pell supported research into adult stem cells but opposed embryonic stem-cell research because he believed it involved destruction of human life after conception. He defended the seal of confession as inviolable, while advising a priest who knew beforehand of an abuse allegation to refuse to hear the confession.
Pell called for deeper friendship and understanding with Muslims after the September 11 attacks and said that moderates held sway in Australia. He also made critical comparisons between Islam and communism, questioned Islam’s capacity for theological renewal, and argued in 2006 that it was not a tolerant religion when considered on its own terms. At the same time, he hosted Ramadan iftar dinners in 2012 and 2013, describing such gatherings as signs of respect for religious diversity and opportunities for friendship and peace.
He took part in Jewish-Christian dialogues and said in 2001 that his family had been strongly pro-Jewish. His study of history had saddened him by revealing Christian mistreatment of Jews; he stressed remembering the Holocaust, supported Israel’s right to exist, and praised Vatican II and Pope John Paul II for advancing Jewish-Christian dialogue. He spoke warmly of the Jewish Psalms and of the prophets Isaiah, Jeremiah, and Ezekiel, and regarded Elijah as particularly significant. After remarks in a discussion with Richard Dawkins caused offence, Pell reaffirmed his esteem for Judaism and said the Holocaust was a uniquely destructive crime.
Pell’s views on environmental policy combined a stated duty not to damage the environment at the expense of future generations with skepticism about claims of imminent human-caused climate catastrophe. He criticized what he regarded as pagan elements in environmental rhetoric, challenged claims by Anglican environmentalist George Browning that Pell was out of touch, and argued that church leaders should engage with reality rather than amplify what he considered unsupported claims. In 2015 he criticized Pope Francis’s encyclical Laudato si’ for involving the Church in climate questions, saying that the Church had no particular scientific expertise or mandate to pronounce on science. He also warned about declining population growth and religious indifference, while his claims about population and resource pressures were contested by Sustainable Population Australia and economist Jeffrey Sachs.
Politics
Pell had no documented political-party affiliation or elected political office, but spoke publicly on political and social questions from a socially conservative Catholic perspective. He criticized Australia’s bipartisan policy of mandatory detention for asylum seekers, calling for empathy, humane treatment, and investigation of maltreatment. He considered deterrence defensible in principle but said that its implementation came at too great a moral cost, and argued that a prosperous country could afford to treat refugees generously. He was wary of what he called the callousness of unrestrained capitalism.
He opposed same-sex relationships, same-sex adoption, and legislative changes he considered contrary to Catholic teaching. In 1990 he said that homosexual activity was wrong and should not be encouraged; he also linked it to health risks and youth suicide. In 1998 he refused communion to members of the Rainbow Sash Movement attending Mass in Melbourne and rebuked their actions. He opposed legislation in 2006 that would have allowed same-sex couples to adopt and later argued that discrimination against gay people was not comparable to racial discrimination. He favored discouraging divorce, particularly where children were involved, and proposed considering penalties and benefits intended to encourage couples to stay together. He opposed the liberalization of laws on embryonic stem-cell research and criticized what he regarded as the politicization of environmental debate.
Pell supported the Catholic teaching that abstinence and monogamy within marriage, rather than condom distribution, were the solution to AIDS. He defended Pope Benedict XVI’s 2009 comments on condoms, calling AIDS a spiritual and health crisis and saying condoms could encourage promiscuity and irresponsibility. After Benedict later said condom use could sometimes be a first step toward reducing infection risk, Pell said this did not represent a major change in Vatican thinking.
In a 2022 memorandum published after his death under the pseudonym Demos, Pell sharply criticized Pope Francis’s pontificate, calling it a disaster in many respects. He faulted Francis for what Pell viewed as insufficient resistance to the Chinese Communist Party, inadequate support for Ukraine and the Ukrainian Greek Catholic Church, and insufficient opposition to challenges to traditional Catholic teaching in Germany concerning LGBT issues and women’s ordination. In a posthumous Spectator article, Pell called Francis’s Synod on Synodality a “toxic nightmare.”
Views
Pell’s public thought combined defense of Catholic orthodoxy with criticism of unrestrained capitalism and calls for humane treatment of refugees. He said Catholic identity involved belief, worship, service, and communal duty rather than inherited identity alone. He treated the Genesis account of Adam and Eve as a sophisticated mythological explanation of creation, humanity, evil, and suffering, rather than a scientific account.
He argued that people must not exploit the environment at the expense of future generations, while rejecting what he considered extravagant claims of imminent human-caused climate catastrophe. He maintained that the Church had no special mandate to settle scientific questions. His speeches and writing also addressed religious freedom, Christian-Jewish dialogue, and peaceful relations among religious communities. In a 2022 memorandum written as Demos, he criticized Pope Francis’s leadership and positions on China, Ukraine, and doctrinal debates in Germany.
Membership
Pell participated in Catholic church governance through the National Catholic Commission, the bishops’ education committee, the Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith, the Pontifical Council for Justice and Peace, the Pontifical Council for the Family, the Congregation for Bishops, the Congregation for the Evangelization of Peoples, and the Council of Cardinal Advisers. These bodies address doctrine, pastoral and social questions, family life, episcopal appointments, evangelization, and Vatican administration.
He chaired Caritas Australia, part of the international Catholic humanitarian network Caritas Internationalis, from 1988 to 1997. He was a founding member of the Catholic Education Commission of Victoria and chaired Vox Clara, which advised on English translations of liturgical texts. He also accepted the Oxford University Newman Society’s invitation to serve as patron. His prefecture of the Secretariat for the Economy was an executive office rather than a membership.
Chairman.
Caritas Australia
,
Australia
1988 - 1997
National Catholic Commission
,
Australia
1988 - 1997
Founding member.
Catholic Education Commission of Victoria
,
Australia
Member.
Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith
,
Holy See
1990 - 2000
Consultor; later member from 2002.
Pontifical Council for Justice and Peace
,
Holy See
1990 - 1995
Member; previously served as a consultor.
Pontifical Council for the Family
,
Holy See
2002
Member.
Congregation for Bishops
,
Holy See
2012
Member.
Congregation for the Evangelization of Peoples
,
Holy See
2014
Member; advised Pope Francis on reform of the Roman Curia.
Council of Cardinal Advisers
,
Holy See
2013 - 2018
President; advised on English translations of liturgical texts.
Vox Clara Commission
,
Holy See
2002
Personality
Pell maintained a prominent public presence and expressed his religious and political views forthrightly. He was strongly conservative on Catholic doctrine and morals, while taking a more progressive position on asylum seekers than Australia’s bipartisan mandatory-detention policy. He said public debate should engage with reality, open people’s minds, and challenge claims he considered unsupported.
Physical Characteristics:
As a child, Pell underwent 24 operations to remove an abscess in his throat. Doctors later considered his heart condition serious enough to prevent air travel to Australia, so he gave evidence to the Royal Commission by video link from Rome. A health assessment in February 2019 found him fit to be held in Melbourne Assessment Prison.
Quotes from others about the person
In 2017 the Royal Commission into Institutional Responses to Child Sexual Abuse reported that the Melbourne Response had been widely criticized as legalistic and insufficiently supportive of victims.
Survivors’ advocate Peter Saunders said Pell’s explanation of accompanying Gerald Ridsdale to court displayed what Saunders regarded as callousness and contempt for victims. Counsel assisting Gail Furness later considered the claim that Pell had offered David Ridsdale an inducement unlikely to be an accurate account of Pell’s intent. Justice Mark Weinberg dissented from the Victorian Court of Appeal majority and concluded Pell should be acquitted.
After Pell compared the Church’s responsibility to that of a trucking company whose driver acted against policy, survivor advocate Cathy Kezelman called the comparison outrageous, while Nicky Davis of the Survivors Network of those Abused by Priests deemed it highly offensive. ABC commentator Michael Bradley argued that the analogy was insensitive and failed to address institutional responsibility. At the 2013 Victorian inquiry, critic David Marr said Pell had acknowledged a cover-up motivated by fear of scandal and alleged that Pell’s predecessor had destroyed records and moved abusive priests between parishes.
Interests
As a schoolboy Pell played Australian rules football as a ruckman and reportedly signed with the Richmond Football Club in 1959. He continued playing football during his early seminary studies.
Sport & Clubs
Australian rules football
Connections
Pell was the son of George Arthur Pell and Margaret Lillian Pell, née Burke.
Father:
George Arthur Pell
A non-practising Anglican and heavyweight boxing champion; his ancestors came from Leicestershire, England.
Grand Prior of the New South Wales Lieutenancy of the Order of the Holy Sepulchre
Grand Prior of the Australian Lieutenancy – Southern of the Order of the Holy Sepulchre
National Chaplain
Awards
Centenary Medal,
Australia
Australian award for service to Australian society through the Catholic Church; awarded in 2001.
Australian award for service to Australian society through the Catholic Church; awarded in 2001.
Companion of the Order of Australia,
Australia
Appointed in the 2005 Queen's Birthday Honours for service to the Catholic Church in Australia and internationally, ethical and spiritual debate, education, and social justice.
Appointed in the 2005 Queen's Birthday Honours for service to the Catholic Church in Australia and internationally, ethical and spiritual debate, education, and social justice.
Knight Grand Cross,
Holy See
Holy See distinction, conferred in 2001.
Holy See distinction, conferred in 2001.
Ecclesiastical Grand Cross and Ecclesiastical Grand Cross of Merit of the Order of Saint Lazarus
Conferred in 2003 for longstanding commitment to ecumenism and service as National Chaplain in 2001.
Conferred in 2003 for longstanding commitment to ecumenism and service as National Chaplain in 2001.