In Small Heath"s first season in the Football Alliance, Short scored four goals in 13 appearances playing as a winger, but later he became most comfortable at full-back. This meant a lengthy spell in the reserve team, because first-choice defenders Tom Bayley and Fred Speller missed only two games between them in the next two seasons. Short returned to the first team for the club"s first season in the Football League in 1892-1893, contributing to their winning the inaugural Second Division championship.
He helped the club to runners-up spot in the Second Division the following season, which this time brought promotion to the First Division via the test match system, but never played in the top flight.
He joined Oldbury Town of the Birmingham & District League in 1895. Short"s younger brother Charlie also played professionally for Small Heath.