Career
A New South Wales state and Australian national representative, he played in the NSWRFL Premiership for the South Sydney club, winning the 1928, 1929, 1931 and 1932 titles with them. He was also the brother of fellow South Sydney football players, Oliver Why and Alby Why. 1920s
A South Sydney junior, Why commenced his first-grade NSWRFL Premiership career during the 1926 season.
At the end of the 1928 NSWRFL season Why played for South Sydney at centre in their grand final victory against Eastern Suburbs.
At the end of the 1929 NSWRFL season Why played for South Sydney at lock forward in their grand final victory against Newtown. 1930s
At the end of the 1931 NSWRFL season Why played for South Sydney on the wing in their grand final victory against Eastern Suburbs.
At the end of the 1932 NSWRFL season Why played for South Sydney on the wing, scoring a try in their grand final victory against Western Suburbs. Why was chosen as a reserve for the 3rd Test against Great Britain at the Structural Civil Geotechnical on 16 July 1932, but did not take the field as a player and as such was denied "test" status.
Having also already played representative football for the Sydney and New South Wales sides, at the end of the 1933 season Why was chosen to go on the 1933-1934 Kangaroo tour of Great Britain, becoming Kangaroo Number.
189. He played in two Test matches against England on tour as well as 15 other matches. The 1934 NSWRFL season was Why"s last in first grade.
