Career
Despite his relative anonymity, Smith faced off against some the best fighters of his era, including Harry Greb, Gene Tunney, Mike Gibbons, Georges Carpentier, Les Darcy and Tommy Loughran. He was inducted into the Ring Magazine Hall of Fame in 1969 and the International Boxing Hall of Fame in 2013. Smith made his pro debut in 1910 (the same year of the death of famed Middleweight Champion Stanley Ketchel), beating Ray Hatfield by newspaper decision over four rounds.
On February 20, 1912, Smith beat future World Middleweight Title holder George Chip on points over fifteen rounds in what turned out to be a heated battle.
His next notable challenge was against another future Middleweight titleholder in Mike Gibbons, with whom he drew over 10 rounds as decided by newspaper reporters. Despite a late rally by Smith, Carpentier used his vaunted technique beat him decisively in a twenty round decision.
Earning his nickname as the "Bayonne Globetrotter", Smith faced Eddie McGoorty in Australia, losing an extremely unpopular decision over twenty rounds. The decision was so despised that it was later rescinded, and Smith was awarded the Australian version of the World Middleweight Title.
Smith would lose the title to Australian pugilist Mick King on November 28, 1914 but regained it just one month later on December 26 of the same year.
On January 23, 1915 Smith faced famed Australian fighter Les Darcy, beating him by disqualification after Darcy"s handlers threw in a towel in protest to what they claimed was a low blow by Smith. During his career, Smith had a tremendous rivalry with the legendary Harry Greb. With the two squaring of a total of seven times.
Although he lost six times and drew once against the "Pittsburgh Windmill", Greb had great respect for Smith.
Stating "My toughest fight was with Jeff Smith. Near the end of his career, Smith faced the fabled Gene Tunney.
Losing a clear decision to the much larger "Fighting Marine" after being knocked down twice. Smith retired after being knocked out for the first time by Cuban Bobby Brown on November 18, 1927.
After retiring, he became a physical education instructor with the Bayonne Board of Education and the Fort Dix New Jersey Army Base, he also taught boxing lessons at the local Young Men’s Christian Association.