James Coonan is an American organized-crime figure who led the Westies, an Irish-American gang based in Manhattan’s Hell’s Kitchen. His criminal career included racketeering, extortion, loansharking, gambling, narcotics, and violence. Convicted in federal court in 1988, he received a 75-year prison sentence and remained incarcerated decades later.
Background
James Coonan was born on December 21, 1946, in the Hell’s Kitchen neighborhood of Manhattan, New York City. He was raised in an Irish-American family; his father, John Coonan, worked as an accountant and operated a tax office in the neighborhood.
When Coonan was a young man, Mickey Spillane, a prominent Hell’s Kitchen mobster, kidnapped and severely beat his father. The incident became closely associated with Coonan’s later hostility toward Spillane and his rise within the neighborhood’s organized-crime world. Coonan left school as a teenager and entered street crime before establishing his own criminal organization.
Career
Coonan became a leading figure in organized crime in Hell’s Kitchen during the 1960s and 1970s. He formed and led the Westies, an Irish-American gang operating on Manhattan’s West Side. The organization’s activities included loansharking, extortion, gambling, counterfeiting, narcotics, kidnapping, and violence. Its criminal operations developed within the densely populated Hell’s Kitchen neighborhood, which had long been associated with competing street gangs and protection rackets.
Coonan’s conflict with Mickey Spillane helped define the Westies’ rise. Coonan assembled a stronger crew, including Mickey Featherstone, and gradually displaced Spillane’s influence in the neighborhood. Spillane later went into hiding and was killed in 1977; accounts connected his death with the Gambino crime family, although the circumstances were widely disputed.
In 1979, Coonan and Featherstone were tried in connection with the murder of bartender Harold Whitehead and were acquitted. Coonan was nevertheless convicted on federal weapons charges and received a four-year sentence. After his release, he resumed leadership of the Westies.
Federal authorities indicted Coonan and other Westies members in 1987. A jury convicted him in 1988 on multiple charges arising from the gang’s racketeering enterprise, including racketeering-related offenses and crimes involving murder, kidnapping, loansharking, gambling, drug dealing, and counterfeiting. On May 11, 1988, the court imposed an aggregate sentence of 75 years’ imprisonment and a $1 million fine.
In later proceedings, federal courts described Coonan as the former leader of the Westies and noted that he had sought parole and sentence relief after decades in custody. In 2025, the United States Court of Appeals for the Second Circuit affirmed the denial of his motion for a sentence reduction under the First Step Act, holding that the statute did not apply to his pre-November 1, 1987 offenses.
Achievements
Coonan established and led the Westies, an organized-crime gang that became a major criminal presence in Manhattan’s Hell’s Kitchen during the 1970s and 1980s.
Connections
Coonan was married to Edna Coonan, who was convicted in the same federal prosecution and received a 15-year prison sentence. His father, John Coonan, was an accountant whose kidnapping and beating by Mickey Spillane became a formative event in accounts of Coonan’s criminal career.
Mickey Featherstone was a leading associate in the Westies and served as Coonan’s lieutenant. Coonan and Featherstone were tried together in 1979 in connection with the death of Harold Whitehead and were acquitted.
Father:
John Coonan
He worked as an accountant and operated a tax office in Hell’s Kitchen.
Wife:
Edna Coonan
She was convicted in the federal Westies prosecution and received a 15-year prison sentence.
Collegue :
Mickey Featherstone
He was a leading Westies associate and Coonan’s lieutenant; the two were tried together in 1979 in connection with the death of Harold Whitehead and were acquitted.
Federal jury convicts Westies gang members
The contemporary report covers the federal convictions of Coonan and other Westies members and summarizes the prosecution’s allegations concerning murder, kidnapping, loansharking, gambling, drug dealing, insurance fraud, and counterfeiting.