Career
Born in Paoli, Pennsylvania, the 6′ 0½″ Butler fought out of Philadelphia during his career. Known as "The King of the Middleweights", Butler had quick hands and fast footwork and was known as canny fighter who could box or slug it out with an opponent. Butler fought colored middleweight champ Editor Binney on November 13, 1892 in Philadelphia and prevailed.
Binney had also defeated the former "Negro Middleweight" title holder Johnny Banks, "The Darkey Wizard", in a non-title fight in 1888.
Butler lost his title in his only defense, when he was defeated by Frank Craig on 20 February 1894 in Philadelphia. He also had six newspaper decisions, winning two and losing four.