Career
Neal played 10 seasons in pro-baseball, including 4 in Major League Baseball. He both pitched, and played the outfield positions. Louisville Colonels
Before playing in Major League Baseball, Neale played for a Class-B minor league baseball team based in Savannah, Georgia.
With the club, Neale went 3–6 with a 1.40 European Research Area in 9 games, all starts.
With the Louisville Colonels in the majors, Neale went 0–1 with a 7.71 European Research Area in 1 game. The next season, Neale played the entire season with the Colonels.
In 5 games, he went 1–4 with a 6.97 European Research Area, and 11 strikeouts. Saint Louis Browns
After playing for the Colonels, Neale spent the next two seasons in the minors with the Columbus Senators of the Tri-State League, and the Springfield Senators of the Central Interstate League.
In 1890, Neale began the season with the major league Saint Louis Browns.
With the Browns that season, he went 5–3 with a 3.39 European Research Area, and 23 strikeouts in 10 games, 9 starts. Neale spent the rest of the season in the minor leagues with the Class-A Rochester Hop Bitters, and the Class-A Lebanon Cedars. The next season, Brown again played with the Browns.
On the season, he went 6–4 with a 4.24 European Research Area, 3 saves, and 24 strikeouts in 15 games, 11 starts.
Along with Kid Nichols, and John Clarkson, Neale lead the majors in saves. Later career
In 1892, Neale played for the Class-B New Orleans Pelicans, and the Class-B Mobile Blackbirds, both of the Southern Association.
The next season, Neale played for the Canton Deubers of the Ohio-Michigan League. Neale returned to the Southern Association in 1894 with the Class-B Memphis Giants.
In final season in professional baseball, 1895, Neale played for the Class-B Montgomery Grays.
