John Gardiner Calkins Brainard was an American lawyer, editor and poet. His reputation evoked a eulogy from Whittier and a sneer from Poe.
Background
John Gardiner Calkins Brainard was born on October 21, 1796 in New London, Connecticut. He was the youngest son of Sarah (Gardiner) Brainard and Jeremiah G. Brainard, a graduate of Yale College in the class of 1779, and a judge of the superior court of Connecticut. His father was also a descendant of Lion Gardiner, an early English settler and soldier, who founded the first English settlement in what became the state of New York.
Education
Brainard was tutored at home by an elder brother and entered Yale College at the age of 15 in 1811. His taste for poetry appeared early in boyhood, and at Yale, where he was graduated in the class of 1815. The traditions of his family (the Brainards or Brainerds, of Flemish origin, had come to Hartford about 1649) led into the practise of the law, a profession for which he was temperamentally unsuited. His lovable nature which had made him a favorite at college shrank from the rough professional business of the day.
Career
After studying faithfully in the law office of his brother, William F. Brainard, John Brainard was admitted to the bar (1819) with honor; he developed a small clientele in Middletown, Connecticut; but he was, throughout this unlucky episode, thoroughly unhappy. In his own words he could not endure the "personal altercation, contradiction and hard collision" of his contemporaries. To understand this, one needs only to look at his portrait which mirrors clearly his gentle and introspective spirit. He retired from the law, and returned to his birthplace, New London, where, had he possessed energy, he might have matured his gift for verse.
Yet, though his mild nature recoiled from the world, he needed its stimulus, and in the winter of 1822 he became associated with P. B. Goodsell, the Hartford publisher, as editor of the Connecticut Mirror. This was a compromise, for Brainard was ruffled by the severe tasks of journalism.
It was so in college that he had interested his classmates; even as a lawyer he had written "The Memoirs of Gabriel Gap" for a New Haven paper, the Microscope; and he now composed steadily for the Connecticut Mirror. He had all the ambition of the sensitive man, and in this period was to be the crisis of his career. It occurred in 1825, in the publication of his Occasional Pieces of Poetry, an attractive volume made up of some fifty pieces culled from the Mirror. The book made a stir, and might have stimulated anyone save Brainard to further effort.
It was now that Brainard's friends rightly urged a second volume to solidify his reputation. He tried to respond to this sensible advice, but as usual procrastinated, and the only other volume brought out in his lifetime was the unimportant Fort Braddock Letters (1827).
The literary fulfilment came in the spring of 1827 when Brainard resigned from the Connecticut Mirror because of ill health, and again settled in New London. Never endowed with robust animal spirits, he now fell into moods of deep dejection. These coupled with his piety lent a religious gloom to his later poetry, such as, "The Invalid on the East End of Long Island. "
By the spring of 1827, he was in failing health, suffering from tuberculosis, and he died on September 26, 1828.
For the weakness of Brainard's life there is confirmation in the revised edition of his poetry (1832), in Fugitive Tales (1830), and in the new gleanings from his verse in the Mirror (1842).
Religion
At his father's home in New London John Brainard studied the doctrines of Christian grace; he became a communicant in the First Congregational Church.
Views
The militant politics of the age aroused in Brainard no enthusiasm for editorial or controversy. Yet the necessity of regular writing overcame his timidity, and he had now in the periodical a medium for his delicate poetic talent. Thus he found, in spite of recurrent indolence and excessive sensibility, his vocation: to write was, if we consider his life as a whole, his one passion. He also had that curious temperament, often found in literary men, of extravagant ambition inhibited by the profound and disheartening conviction of failure.
All that he wrote reveals his carelessness, and lack of self-control. His poetry imitated sentimental models.
Quotations:
Brainard could not, he told S. G. Goodrich despairingly, sustain the necessary continuity of thought to hold to his purpose. "There was, " says an intimate friend, "a sad prophecy in this presentiment--a prophecy which he at once made and fulfilled. "
Personality
Brainard was well-known as a clumsy little man with paddling walk, pale sensitive face, abstracted air, careless dress, and great personal charm. Towards the end of his life he was in failing health, suffering from tuberculosis. The image of his personality had always been clearly reflecting his gentle and introspective spirit.