Career
His consistent ability to cross the line drew interest from new Blues coach John Kirwan, but McNicholl, who plays his club rugby for Sydenham in the Christchurch Metro competition, opted to commit to the Crusaders. He is known for his right foot step and pace similar to Bryan Habana. He has caught the attention of the All Blacks in recent months for his right hand fend.
He recently, due to a fishing accident has to wear an eye patch, this has however given him the nickname.
The Pirate of the South. Johnny has a sponsorship deal with Fonterra, aiming to become the heaviest player in the Crusaders by the end of the season drinking milk.
Johnny is currently living in a timeshare with his old fishing buddy and Highlanders fullback Ben Smith in Wanaka, making getting to training extra difficult. A new Crusaders chant is based over Johnny and his nickname:
Johnny,Johnny, The Pirate of the South, Johnny,Johnny, He loves a good old stout, Johnny,Johnny, You will love him too, Johnny,Johnny, He scores a try or two.