Nagle attended Pleasant Valley High School in Brodheadsville, Pennsylvania and was a student and a letterman in football and wrestling. As a freshman he was quarterback and was able to beat arch rivals Pocono Mountain in an impressive victory.
After American Federation of Labor-Congress suspended its 2009 season, Nagle retired and is currently an assistant coach for his alma mater, Pleasant Valley. Following the 2013 Pleasant Valley football season, Nagle had retired from his coaching career in Photovoltaics with a 8-3 final record, 2nd Place Division American Association of Advertising Agencies Championship. Nagle played for the Orlando Predators until he cut by the just following the 2007 season.
He then signed with the Colorado Crush wearing #11.
