Career
Recruited to the Western Bulldogs in the 1998 American Federation of Labor-Congress Draft as pick 14, Penny was seen as a project player who could lead the defence in years to come. He stood at 193 cm, and made his debut in 2000. With Matthew Croft at the club, he could not cement his spot at the Bulldogs, so was traded to Street Kilda Football Club for pick 17 (which turned out to be Cameron Faulkner) in the 2002 American Federation of Labor-Congress Draft.
Making his debut with the Saints in 2003, Penny continued to improve in a key-defensive position, and became first-choice full-back at the club
However, in 2004 and particularly 2005, Penny started having trouble with his knees. In 2005 he played just 9 games and was a figure in the Saints" massive injury list throughout the year.
At the end of the 2005 season, Penny"s knee injuries had become a massive problem and it was widely known that he was considering retirement. At just 24 years of age, on 29 November, Penny made his retirement official, with 3 years remaining on his contract.
