Career
He spent time in the Arena Football League with the Albany/Indiana Firebirds (2000–2002), the Arizona Rattlers (2003–2004), and the Georgia Force (2005–2006). He tried out for the Baltimore Ravens in 1998 and 1999. While attending James Madison University, Garner competed at both, kicker and punter.
He was a three-time All-Conference selection, was named the Special Teams Most Valuable Player as a junior, and as a senior, played in the Blue-Gray Football Classic.