Career
Lega Pro
Cosentini started his career working his way through the Juventus F.C. youth ranks, before he made his way to the Primavera youth squad in 2006. He never managed a senior team debut with Juventus during the season, but after graduating the youth team in July 2008, he was loaned to Pro Patria, then sold to third division club, Associate of Science Figline in co-ownership deal, along with teammates, Marco Duravia, Salvatore Doctorate"Elia (loan), and Alessandro Doctorate"Antoni. He scored 1 goal in 16 appearances for the club during the 2009-2010 Lega Pro Prima Divisione season.
On 25 June 2010 Juventus brought back Cosentini and sold to Viareggio on 8 July 2010 along with Carlo Pinsoglio, Doctorate"Antoni and Giorgio Merlano.
In June 2011 Juventus gave up the remain 50% registration rights. However Cosentini also excluded from the squad of Viareggio and terminated the contract in mutual consent in December 2011
Serie Doctorate
Cosentini spent rest of the 2011-2012 Serie Doctorate season with Pro Imperia.
He joined another Serie Doctorate team Asti in August but later left for Taranto. In December he moved to Montalto Uffugo.
Abroad
He moved to Lithuanian A lyga club Kruoja Pakruojis in March 2013 but due to difficult financial circumstances of the club, in April 2013 he chose to join another Lithuanian A lyga club Tauras Tauragė.
Parma
Cosentini returned to Italy for Parma. Circa October he was signed by Maltese club Mosta. On 31 January 2014 he was signed by Italian fourth division club Gavorrano in co-ownership.
L"Aquila
In summer 2014 he was signed by L"Aquila.
