Career
According to his Major League Soccer biography, Peters was a 1993 National Association of Intercollegiate Athletics All American at soccer player at Park College where he scored 25 goals and adding 12 assists in 18 games. However, the National Association of Intercollegiate Athletics has no record of a Nyanforth Peters gaining All American recognition in 1993 or any other year. He then supposedly left college and moved to Switzerland where he played for Football Club Locarno.
The accuracy of this is unknown.
In February 1996, the Kansas City Wiz selected Peters in the 8th round (76th overall) in the 1996 Master of Library Science Inaugural Player Draft. However, he never played a game with the Wiz and there is no record of him being waived or released, leading to the conclusion that he never signed with the team
In 1999, he played three games for the Maryland Mania of the USL A-League.
