Otto Everett Graham was an American football quarterback and coach best known for leading the Cleveland Browns to seven championships in ten seasons, with a championship-game appearance every year from 1946 through 1955. He also played championship-winning basketball, coached the Coast Guard Academy and Washington Redskins, and was inducted into the Pro Football Hall of Fame.
Background
Graham was born on December 6, 1921, in Waukegan, Illinois, into a family of four boys. His parents, Otto Everett Graham and Cordonna (Hayes) Graham, were music teachers; his father had taught comedian Jack Benny. Graham weighed 14 pounds 12 ounces at birth.
Education
Graham entered Northwestern University in 1940 on a basketball scholarship. He played varsity basketball as a freshman, studied music, and began playing football during his sophomore year after coach Pappy Waldorf noticed him throwing in an intramural game and invited him to practice. He also played baseball and remained on the basketball team. As a senior, he earned first-team All-American recognition in basketball. His football debut for the Wildcats came on October 4, 1941: he returned a Kansas State punt 90 yards for a touchdown, then ran and passed for two more scores in a 51–3 win. He scored twice more against Wisconsin and threw two touchdown passes against Ohio State, giving Paul Brown's team its only loss of the 1941 season; Northwestern finished 11th in the Associated Press poll.
After the United States entered World War II, Graham enlisted in the U.S. Coast Guard but remained at Northwestern while awaiting active duty. In 1942, when many Wildcats had entered military service, the team won only once; Graham completed 89 passes, setting a single-season Big Ten record. Military enlistees from other schools joined Northwestern in 1943 while the U.S. Navy operated a training station there. The Wildcats beat defending national champion Ohio State and a Great Lakes Naval Station team, lost to Notre Dame and Michigan, and finished 8–2 and ninth in the AP poll. Graham set another Big Ten passing record, was named the conference's Most Valuable Player, received football All-American honors, and placed third in Heisman Trophy voting. He completed his Northwestern career with a Big Ten record 2,132 passing yards.
In February 1944, Graham moved to Colgate University in Hamilton, New York, for the Navy's V-5 pilot-training program, playing basketball there. Later in 1944 he moved to North Carolina Pre-Flight and played football for the Cloudbusters under Glenn Killinger and Bear Bryant. His Northwestern degree was a Bachelor of Arts, awarded in 1944.
While Graham was still at Northwestern, he entered the Coast Guard as the United States' involvement in World War II expanded. He remained at the university until called to active duty and later undertook Navy flight training through the V-5 program and North Carolina Pre-Flight. In 1945, Paul Brown offered him a Cleveland professional football contract worth $7,500 a year, with a $250 monthly allowance until the war ended; Graham later recalled accepting by asking where to sign. The NFL's Detroit Lions also drafted him, but he signed no contract and played no games for them.
Before the Browns began play in 1946, Graham joined the Rochester Royals of the National Basketball League, a forerunner of the NBA. The Royals swept the Sheboygan Red Skins in a best-of-five series in March 1946 to win the league championship. Graham's 1946 basketball and football titles made him one of only two people, along with Gene Conley, to win championships in two of the four major North American sports.
Graham joined the Cleveland Browns after his Navy discharge late in the summer of 1946. Coach Paul Brown initially started Cliff Lewis, but Graham soon took over at quarterback in the T-formation offense. With fullback Marion Motley and receivers Dante Lavelli and Mac Speedie, he led Cleveland to a 12–2 regular-season record and the AAFC championship game against the New York Yankees. Graham threw the go-ahead touchdown to Lavelli with 4:31 left and later intercepted a pass on defense as the Browns won. Cleveland captured all four AAFC championships from 1946 to 1949, and in 1948 became professional football's first undefeated championship team. The Browns went 29 consecutive games without a defeat from 1947 to 1949.
Graham averaged 10.5 yards per pass and recorded a 112.1 passer rating in 1946, then a professional-football record that Joe Montana surpassed in 1989. Graham was the AAFC's Most Valuable Player in 1947 and shared the award with San Francisco's Frankie Albert in 1948. He led the league in passing yards from 1947 through 1949 and finished as its all-time leading passer with 10,085 yards and 86 touchdowns. When the AAFC dissolved after the 1949 season, Cleveland was among three of its teams to enter the NFL.
The Browns continued their success in the NFL. In 1950, Graham was named United Press NFL Player of the Year and led Cleveland to a 10–2 record. After a playoff against the New York Giants, the Browns faced the Los Angeles Rams for the championship. Graham rushed for 99 yards and passed for 298 yards and four touchdowns, driving Cleveland downfield in the closing moments to set up Lou Groza's winning field goal in a 30–28 victory. Cleveland returned to the championship game in 1951 after an 11–1 season, but lost 24–17 to the Rams. Graham threw for 280 yards and a touchdown, although a third-quarter fumble led to a Rams score and three of his passes were intercepted. He was named the league's Most Valuable Player after the season.
The 1952 Browns went 9–3 and met the Detroit Lions for the NFL title. Cleveland gained 384 yards to Detroit's 258 but lost 17–7. Several long drives ended with missed field goals, and a fourth-quarter pass to Pete Brewster was ruled incomplete after Ray Renfro touched it first, under the rules then in force. Graham was named NFL Player of the Year. On January 2, 1953, while practicing for the Pro Bowl in Los Angeles, he and his wife Beverly lost their six-week-old son Stephen, who died from a severe cold.
In 1953, Graham opened the season with 292 passing yards and two rushing touchdowns in a 27–0 win over Green Bay. Cleveland won its first eleven games and finished 11–1, then lost the championship to Detroit 17–16. Near the end of the season, a forearm from San Francisco's Art Michalik cut Graham's chin and required 15 stitches; he returned to play wearing a clear plastic face mask. Graham took responsibility after the title loss, saying that his performance had let his teammates down. He led the NFL in passing and again won its Most Valuable Player award. Before Cleveland's 1954 training camp, he was questioned in the Sam Sheppard murder investigation. Sheppard and his pregnant wife were friends of Graham and Beverly; Graham told police they liked the couple but knew little about their relationship.
Graham told Brown he planned to retire after the 1954 season, a transitional year in which many of the Browns' original players had retired or were nearing the end of their careers. After Cleveland lost its first three games, the team won eight straight and reached the championship against Detroit. Graham ran for three touchdowns and passed for three more in a 56–10 victory, becoming the first player to accomplish both in a game; Josh Allen matched the feat in 2024. Graham announced his retirement after the game, but returned for one final season when his potential replacements struggled in training camp and preseason. At $25,000, he was the NFL's highest-paid player in 1955. The Browns finished 9–2–1 and defeated the Rams 38–14 in the championship, with Graham throwing two touchdowns and running for two. When Brown removed him in the fourth quarter, Los Angeles Coliseum spectators gave him a standing ovation. Graham retired after ten seasons, all of which had ended with a championship-game appearance; Cleveland won seven of those games. He was the NFL's passing leader and Most Valuable Player in 1955 and received the Hickok Belt as the year's outstanding professional athlete. Without him, the Browns finished 5–7 in 1956, their first losing season.
Graham and Paul Brown helped shape the modern T-formation quarterback role and professional offense. Graham led his league in major passing categories in multiple seasons and finished with a career yards-per-attempt average of 9.0. His 44 career rushing touchdowns as a professional quarterback stood as a record until 2016. The Browns' record with him as starting quarterback was 57–13–1, including 9–3 in the playoffs. He never missed a game. He held the NFL career record for yards per pass attempt at 8.63 and the best winning percentage for an NFL starting quarterback, 0.810, as cited in career summaries. The NFL record listing also gives his qualifying career winning percentage as .813. His Cleveland number 14 was retired; he had worn number 60 for much of his career until a 1952 NFL rule reserved numbers 50–79 for offensive linemen. Number 60 remains in circulation, while at Northwestern he wore 48. Graham was inducted into the Pro Football Hall of Fame in 1965 and was named to the NFL 75th Anniversary and 100th Anniversary All-Time Teams, the NFL 1950s All-Decade Team, and the Cleveland Browns Ring of Honor.
After retiring as a player, Graham planned to concentrate on insurance and appliance businesses he owned. In 1957 he became an assistant coach for the College All-Star Game, an annual exhibition between the NFL champion and selected college players; he became its head coach the next year. His 1958 all-star team defeated the Detroit Lions 35–19. He continued coaching the all-stars while at the Coast Guard Academy, including a 20–17 upset of Vince Lombardi's Green Bay Packers in 1963. He coached the team for the tenth and final time in 1970, when the college players lost 24–3 to the Kansas City Chiefs, their seventh consecutive defeat.
With assistance from his friend George Steinbrenner, Graham became head football coach and athletic director at the United States Coast Guard Academy in New London, Connecticut, in 1959. The Division III academy played a relatively short schedule against smaller New England schools. Its team went 3–5 in Graham's first season and improved over the next three years, reaching an undefeated season in 1963 and its first postseason bowl, the Tangerine Bowl, where it lost 27–0 to Western Kentucky. Graham recruited and coached Merle J. Smith, the academy's first African American cadet to graduate. Though offered NFL coaching jobs, Graham said in 1964 that he was content at the academy on a $9,000 salary and objected to the professional game's 'win at all costs' approach.
Graham worked part-time as a television and radio commentator for the New York Jets of the American Football League in 1964 and 1965. In 1966 he left the academy to become head coach and general manager of the NFL's Washington Redskins. Washington went 7–7 in his first season, 5–6–3 in 1967, and 5–9 in 1968. A November 1968 front-page editorial in the Washington Daily News called for his dismissal. Although two years remained on his five-year contract, with an option for another five, Vince Lombardi replaced him in early February 1969.
Graham returned to the Coast Guard Academy as athletic director and intended to remain until retirement. Blanton Collier replaced him as the College All-Star coach in 1971. Graham resumed coaching the academy's football team in 1974, then resigned two years later to focus on athletic administration. His Coast Guard teams had a combined 44–32–1 record over nine coaching years. After eight additional years as athletic director, he retired in 1984.
An avid golfer and tennis player, Graham later retired to a home on a Florida golf course and partnered with Joe DiMaggio in golf tournaments. He overcame colon cancer in 1977, then experienced heart ailments and other health problems. Diagnosed with early-stage Alzheimer's disease in 2001, he died of a heart aneurysm in Sarasota, Florida, on December 17, 2003. Northwestern's fundraising department established the Otto Graham Society in 2013 to honor his university achievements and support its athletics programs. A new gymnasium at Waterford Country School was dedicated in his memory in 2014.
Led the Cleveland Browns to a championship-game appearance in each of his ten seasons as quarterback, winning seven titles. With Graham at quarterback, the team recorded 105 wins, 17 losses, and 4 ties; its AAFC and NFL playoff record was 9–3.
Helped shape the modern T-formation quarterback position and professional offense with Browns coach Paul Brown. His professional career yards-per-attempt average was 9.0; he recorded 44 rushing touchdowns as a professional quarterback, a record that stood until 2016.
The Browns went 57–13–1 in games in which Graham started. He never missed a game during his professional football career.
His 1946 championship season included titles in both the National Basketball League and the All-America Football Conference, a rare achievement in two major North American sports.
As head coach, led the Coast Guard Academy football team to an undefeated 1963 season and its first postseason bowl appearance. His Coast Guard teams compiled a 44–32–1 record over nine coaching seasons.
Membership
Graham belonged to Alpha Delta Phi, a social fraternity, during his Northwestern years. He later served as president of Fellowship of Christian Athletes and on the board of directors of the Washington Young Men's Christian Association, participating in organizations connected with athletics and community life.
Member during his Northwestern years; the fraternity was formerly known as The Wranglers.
Alpha Delta Phi
,
United States
President.
Fellowship of Christian Athletes
,
United States
1956 - 1957
Served on the board of directors.
Washington Young Men's Christian Association
,
United States
1967
Personality
Graham was regarded by teammates as approachable rather than distant. His consistency and toughness on the field earned him the nickname “Automatic Otto.” He remained composed and dependable through a career in which he did not miss a game, and he publicly took responsibility when he believed his play had contributed to a defeat.
Physical Characteristics:
Graham weighed 14 pounds 12 ounces (6.7 kilograms) at birth. A 1953 facial injury left a cut on his chin that required 15 stitches. He later overcame colon cancer and experienced heart ailments and other health problems; he was diagnosed with early-stage Alzheimer's disease in 2001.
Quotes from others about the person
Former teammate Mike McCormack said Graham was “just one of the guys” and “not aloof.” Coach Paul Brown praised Graham's peripheral vision, athletic ability, anticipation of receivers' routes, and capacity to throw accurately and far with a short arm motion. Receiver Dante Lavelli recalled that Graham's passes had excellent touch and that he often caught them one-handed. Long-time New York Yankees owner George Steinbrenner, a friend of Graham's, called him “as great of a quarterback as there ever was.”
Interests
Graham was an avid golfer and tennis player. In later life he partnered with Joe DiMaggio in golf tournaments. He had planned after his playing career to focus on his insurance and appliance businesses.
Sport & Clubs
Football, basketball, baseball, golf, and tennis.
Music & Bands
Graham's parents were music teachers, and he studied music at Northwestern. He learned to play the piano, violin, cornet, and French horn.
Connections
Graham was the son of Otto Everett Graham and Cordonna (Hayes) Graham, both music teachers. He married Beverly Jean Collinge on October 7, 1945. They had children named Duey, Sandy, and David; a six-week-old son, Stephen, died in January 1953. Graham and Beverly were friends of Sam Sheppard and his wife, Marilyn.
Father:
Otto Everett Graham
Music teacher; Graham's father had taught comedian Jack Benny.
Mother:
Cordonna (Hayes) Graham
Music teacher.
child:
Duey Graham
child:
Sandy Graham
child:
David Graham
Wife:
Beverly Jean Collinge
Married Graham on October 7, 1945; they had children named Duey, Sandy, and David.
Son:
Stephen Graham
Died at six weeks old in January 1953 from a severe cold.
Other:
Jack Benny
Comedian whose music teacher was Graham's father.
colleague:
Paul Brown
Cleveland Browns coach who recruited Graham and helped develop the team's offense.
colleague:
Pappy Waldorf
Northwestern football coach who invited Graham to practice after seeing him throw in an intramural game.
Friend:
George Steinbrenner
New York Yankees owner who helped Graham obtain the Coast Guard Academy coaching position.
colleague:
Joe DiMaggio
Partnered with Graham in golf tournaments later in life.
Friend:
Sam Sheppard
Graham and his wife Beverly were friends with Sheppard and his wife.
References
Browns Essential
Mary Schmitt Boyer's book on the Cleveland Browns, published by Triumph Books.