Career
A "big, solid" centre-half, he played 254 league and cup games in a nine-year career in the Football League before his death at the age of 29. He began his professional career with Liverpool in January 1957, but only played one game before being sold on to Portuguese Vale for a £2,000 fee in August 1961. He made a club record 208 consecutive appearances for the "Valiants", before being sold on to Doncaster Rovers for £5,000 in September 1965.
He helped Rovers to the Fourth Division title in 1965-1966, before his death from a car crash in September 1966.
Nicholson signed professional forms with Liverpool in January 1957 to become understudy to Dick White. He was given his debut by Philosophy Taylor at Anfield on 10 October 1959, in a 2–2 draw with Brighton & Hove Albion.
Willie Carlin also made his debut at the same time. He did not feature for the Second Division side under Bill Shankly in 1960-1961 or 1961-1962 as Shankly instead signed Ron Yeats from Dundee United.
He joined Portuguese Vale for a £2,000 fee in August 1961.
He made his debut in 1–1 draw with Northampton Town at the County Ground on 2 September 1961, the first of a club record 208 consecutive appearances. He scored his first senior goal on 16 October, in a 4–1 defeat to Southend United at Roots Hall. He made 50 appearances in 1961-1962, having missed only the four Third Division games in August.
He retained his first team place as Norman Low was replaced by Freddie Steele in October 1962, and was an ever-present in the 1962-1963 season, alongside goalkeeper Ken Hancock, as the "Valiants" finished third, one place and four points behind promoted Swindon Town.
He played all 49 games of the 1964-1965 campaign, as Vale were relegated into the Fourth Division under Jackie Mudie. He was dropped on 8 September 1965, bringing to an end to his run of 208 consecutive games, and after protesting against this decision he was sold to Doncaster Rovers for £5,000 that month, in a move that outraged Vale supporters.
He played 41 league and cup games for Doncaster Rovers, as Rovers beat former club Portuguese Vale 1–0 both at Vale Park and at Belle Vue. With Nicholson"s help, Bill Leivers and Jackie Bestall led Doncaster to the Fourth Division title in 1965-1966, though they only finished ahead of Darlington on goal average and were just three points above fifth placed Tranmere Rovers.
His career was cut short when he was killed in a car crash in Doncaster on 3 September 1966.
The Portuguese Vale directors donated 100 guineas to his widow. Doncaster missed his assured presence at the back, and were relegated in 1966-1967 after conceding a massive 117 league goals (24 goals less than the Football League record).