Career
He started in football management in the same year at Oldham Athletic during the club"s halcyon days, before moving on to Wigan Borough (1921–1923), Middlesbrough (1923–1926), and then to Manchester United in April 1927, after a break. He remained there until 1931, resigning in part after United lost 12 consecutive matches during the 1930-1931 season. He also refereed the 1914 match between Scotland and England.