Peter Van Schaack was an American lawyer, legal scholar, and educator from Kinderhook, New York. He revised the colonial statutes of New York, maintained neutrality during the American Revolution, endured exile in England, and later operated one of the early organized law schools in the United States.
Background
Peter Van Schaack was born on March 24, 1747, in Kinderhook, New York, the seventh child and fourth son of Cornelius Van Schaack and Lydia Van Dyck. His family belonged to the Dutch-descended mercantile and landholding society of the upper Hudson Valley. Cornelius Van Schaack was a river trader, landowner, and local public figure, while Lydia descended from the prominent Van Dyck and Schuyler families of Albany.
Van Schaack was baptized in the Reformed Dutch Protestant Church at Kinderhook. His early education began locally and continued under the Reverend Richard Charlton, a classical scholar who had studied at Trinity College Dublin. Van Schaack became especially accomplished in Latin and developed the polished English style later evident in his legal papers and correspondence.
In 1765, while still an undergraduate, he eloped with Elizabeth Cruger, daughter of the New York merchant Henry Cruger. The marriage was eventually accepted by her family. After Elizabeth's death in 1778, Van Schaack married Elizabeth Van Alen of Kinderhook on April 27, 1789. His family life included children from both marriages.
Education
Van Schaack entered King's College in New York in 1762 and graduated in 1768 with a Bachelor of Arts degree. King's College, founded in 1754 by royal charter and later renamed Columbia College, was colonial New York's principal institution of higher education and trained many figures who became prominent in the law and government of the early United States. Van Schaack ranked at the head of his class and formed lasting friendships with John Jay, Egbert Benson, Gouverneur Morris, Robert R. Livingston, and other future New York leaders.
After leaving college in 1766, he studied law in Albany with his brother-in-law Peter Silvester, then continued his legal apprenticeship in New York with William Smith, a leading lawyer and historian of the province. This combination of collegiate classical education and supervised legal apprenticeship reflected the principal route to admission at the colonial New York bar. Van Schaack was admitted to practice in 1769.
Career
Van Schaack opened a law office in New York City after passing the bar in 1769. His early practice developed during the final years of British colonial rule, when lawyers commonly combined private practice with public legal commissions. In 1773 he was appointed reviser of the statutes of the Colony of New York. His work produced Laws of New-York, from the Year 1691 to 1773 Inclusive, published in 1774 by Hugh Gaine; the compilation preserved and organized the colony's statutory enactments from the first assembly through 1773.
Van Schaack participated in the political committees formed in New York during the imperial crisis. He served on the Committee of Fifty-one in 1774, the Committee of Sixty, the Committee of One Hundred, and the local Committee of Safety at Kinderhook. Although he supported colonial measures such as non-importation and non-consumption, his reading of Locke, Grotius, and other political writers led him to reject armed resistance to the Crown. At a meeting of the Committee of Safety in Albany on May 29, 1776, he declined to pledge himself to take up arms against Great Britain and attempted thereafter to maintain neutrality.
His position brought severe consequences. In January 1777 he refused to take the oath of allegiance to New York, was ordered toward Boston, and was later permitted to remain on parole at Kinderhook. After receiving permission to travel to England for treatment of his failing eyesight, he again refused the oath in July 1778 and became subject to the Banishment Act. He sailed for England in October 1778 and remained there for approximately seven years, studying legal and political affairs, attending parliamentary debates, and maintaining connections with lawyers and statesmen including John Jay and Lord Eldon.
The New York Legislature restored his citizenship in 1784, and he returned to Kinderhook in 1785 after taking the required oath. He was readmitted to the bar in 1786 and resumed legal practice. His eyesight deteriorated seriously, and by the early 1790s he required an amanuensis; nevertheless, he continued advising clients and preparing legal writings for many years. His practice was especially associated with difficult property and title disputes, and his briefs were noted for extensive research and precise, elegant reasoning.
In 1786 Van Schaack established the Kinderhook Law School. The school combined legal apprenticeship with instruction and lectures, an important development at a time when New York generally required aspiring lawyers to train in a practicing attorney's office. It operated until about 1830 and provided all or part of the legal education of more than one hundred young men. Van Schaack continued teaching even as blindness increasingly limited his own practice.
Achievements
Van Schaack revised and organized the statutes of the Colony of New York from 1691 through 1773. The resulting two-volume compilation, published in 1774, became an important reference to the province's colonial legislation.
Van Schaack established and operated the Kinderhook Law School from 1786 to about 1830, providing legal instruction through a combination of apprenticeship and lectures to more than one hundred students.
Despite severe and eventually disabling loss of eyesight, Van Schaack continued legal practice, legal writing, and instruction for many years, using an amanuensis when necessary.
(Van Schaack revised and prepared this compilation of the ...)
1774
Religion
Van Schaack was baptized in the Reformed Dutch Protestant Church at Kinderhook, placing his religious background within the Dutch Reformed tradition established in the colonial Netherlands and carried into New Netherland and the English province of New York. The tradition was Calvinist in theology and organized around congregational worship, scriptural teaching, and disciplined church life.
His documented religious affiliation belongs to the Dutch Reformed cultural environment of Kinderhook, where Dutch language, family networks, and Reformed congregations remained important into the eighteenth century. The available record does not establish a detailed account of his later devotional practice.
Politics
Van Schaack sympathized with the Federalist party and was keenly interested in the adoption of the federal Constitution, although he did not take an active part in electoral politics. His political outlook developed from opposition to British measures that infringed colonial rights while also rejecting armed resistance and refusing to swear allegiance to the revolutionary government of New York.
The Federalists supported the Constitution of 1787, a stronger national government, public credit, commercial development, and a stable legal order. Van Schaack's constitutional sympathies were consistent with his legal training and his preference for ordered government, even though his neutrality during the American Revolution led revolutionary authorities to exile him as a loyalist or Tory sympathizer.
During his exile in England from 1778 to 1785, Van Schaack gradually became critical of the British government's colonial policy. After returning to New York and taking the required oath of allegiance, he resumed his legal career and remained associated with the Federalist political tradition.
Views
Van Schaack's political thought emphasized the rights of the colonies, constitutional government, and the authority of law. He supported resistance to British commercial measures through non-importation and non-consumption, but he concluded that armed rebellion could not be justified and refused to swear allegiance to the revolutionary government of New York.
His correspondence reflects sustained engagement with John Locke, Hugo Grotius, and other writers on natural law, government, and political obligation. His later career as a lawyer and legal instructor likewise centered on ordered constitutional authority, close textual analysis, and the transmission of legal learning through apprenticeship.
Personality
Van Schaack was described as a learned classical scholar, an exact legal reasoner, an elegant writer, and a cultivated conversationalist. Accounts of his legal career emphasize thorough preparation, logical precision, and careful anticipation of opposing arguments. His correspondence and conduct during the Revolution show a strong commitment to personal conscience and constitutional principle, even when that position resulted in exile and the loss of his professional opportunities.
Physical Characteristics:
Van Schaack suffered progressive impairment of his eyesight. By the early 1790s he required an amanuensis, and he was totally or nearly totally blind during the later part of his life.
Quotes from others about the person
Van Schaack's contemporaries and later legal historians regarded him as one of the leading lawyers of the Hudson Valley and as an influential teacher of early American law. His legal briefs were remembered for deep research, logical structure, and polished style.
Interests
Classical scholarship; political and legal history; parliamentary debates
Philosophers & Thinkers
John Locke; Hugo Grotius
Politicians
John Jay
Connections
Van Schaack's family and professional connections linked him with several prominent legal and political families of colonial and early national New York. His first wife, Elizabeth Cruger, was the daughter of the merchant Henry Cruger, while his second wife, Elizabeth Van Alen, came from Kinderhook. His brother-in-law Peter Silvester was a lawyer, Federalist attorney, and later a member of the United States House of Representatives.
At King's College, Van Schaack formed enduring friendships with John Jay, Egbert Benson, Gouverneur Morris, Robert R. Livingston, and Richard Harrison. His correspondence and legal papers also document connections with Henry Cruger, Theodore Sedgwick, James Duane, and other figures involved in the political and legal controversies of the Revolution and early United States.
Father:
Cornelius Van Schaack
Lived from October 17, 1705, to October 13, 1776; he was a merchant, river trader, landowner, magistrate, militia colonel, and church elder.
Mother:
Lydia van Schaack (Van Dyke)
Lived from July 16, 1704, to June 10, 1785.
Brother:
Cornelius Van Schaack
Died March 18, 1797.
Brother:
John Wesley Van Scyoc
Died February 12, 1838.
Brother:
David Van Schaack
Brother:
Henry Van Schaack
Lived from 1733 to 1823.
Sister:
Jannetje Silvester (Van Schaack)
Born in 1739.
Sister:
Lydia Van Vleck (Van Schaack)
Lived from 1745 to 1774.
Wife:
Elizabeth Van Schaick (Cruger)
Van Schaack's first wife and the daughter of Henry Cruger; she died in 1778.
Wife:
Elizabeth Van Alen
Van Schaack's second wife, whom he married on April 27, 1789.
Daughter:
Elizabeth Frey (Van Schaick)
Born in 1770.
Daughter:
Elizabeth Van Schaack
Son:
Cornelius Van Schaack
Born in 1772.
Son:
Hendrick Van Schaack
Born October 8, 1768; died in February 1797.
Son:
Henry Cruger Van Schaack
Lived from April 3, 1802, to December 16, 1887; he was an American author and antiquarian.
brother-in-law:
Henry Cruger
Lived from November 22, 1739, to April 24, 1827; he was a merchant associated with both New York and Bristol, England.
brother-in-law:
Peter Silvester
Lived from 1734 to October 15, 1808; he was a Federalist lawyer and politician from New York who served in the United States House of Representatives.