Ram Boolchand Jethmalani was an Indian lawyer and politician who served as Union Minister of Law and Justice and held senior positions in India’s legal profession. A prominent advocate in high-profile criminal and public cases, he was elected to both houses of Parliament and remained active in public debate until retiring from legal practice in 2017.
Background
Jethmalani was born in Shikarpur, in the Sindh division of the then Bombay Presidency, to Boolchand Gurmukhdas Jethmalani and Parbati Boolchand. Shikarpur is now in Pakistan. The 1947 Partition of British India displaced him from his home region and reshaped the course of his life.
Education
Jethmalani advanced rapidly through school, receiving double promotion and completing matriculation at 13. At 17 he earned an LL.B. with first-class distinction from the University of Bombay, and later completed an LL.M. there. Sindh had no university of its own at the time, so his higher studies took place in Bombay.
The minimum age for admission to legal practice was then 21. Jethmalani challenged that restriction in court and secured a special exception, enabling him to qualify as a lawyer at 18.
Career
Jethmalani began practising law in Shikarpur and worked there until Partition. He also taught law in Sindh before Partition. He and his friend A. K. Brohi, seven years his senior, established a law firm in Karachi. In February 1948, as riots broke out in the city, Brohi advised him to flee. Jethmalani reached India with only ten rupees and spent several days in a refugee camp before beginning again in Bombay, later Mumbai.
At 17, Jethmalani argued his first case before the Sindh High Court, challenging the Bar Council of Sindh’s minimum-age rule before Justice Godfrey Davis. As a refugee in Bombay, he then brought a case in the Bombay High Court against the Bombay Refugees Act, arguing that its treatment of refugees was inhumane and unconstitutional. The court ruled in his favour. In 1954 he became a part-time professor at Government Law College, Mumbai, teaching graduate and postgraduate students. He also taught comparative law at Wayne State University in Detroit, Michigan.
His appearance in the 1959 Nanavati case, alongside Y. V. Chandrachud, later Chief Justice of India, brought wider notice. In the late 1960s, he defended a series of people accused of smuggling, earning the public image of a “smuggler’s lawyer”; he said he was performing his duty as an advocate. His later defence work ranged across commercial, criminal and constitutional matters. He represented Harshad Mehta in a stock-market scam case and in the Narasimha Rao bribery case, and defended Ketan Parekh in a separate stock-market scam. He appeared in a case involving Mumbai underworld leader Haji Mastan and defended the alleged assassins of Indira Gandhi, challenging testimony about medical evidence from All India Institute of Medical Sciences forensic expert Tirath Das Dogra.
Jethmalani defended L. K. Advani in the Hawala scandal and Amit Shah in the Sohrabuddin encounter case. He represented Amit Jogi in the Jaggi murder case and appeared for Sanjay Chandra’s bail in the 2G spectrum case, for Kulbhushan Parashar’s bail in the navy war-room leak case, and for Kanimozhi in another 2G spectrum case. He appeared in Y. S. Jagan Mohan Reddy’s special-leave petition seeking a stay of a Central Bureau of Investigation probe into alleged money laundering in his companies, and defended B. S. Yediyurappa in an illegal-mining case. He defended A. G. Perarivalan, T. Suthendraraja, also known as Santhan, and Sriharan, also known as Murugan, who had been convicted in the Rajiv Gandhi assassination case. He also defended Ramdev over alleged force used against his followers at Delhi’s Ramlila grounds on 4 June 2011, Shiv Sena in the Krishna Desai murder case, and Asaram in a Jodhpur sexual-assault case.
Other clients included Lalu Prasad Yadav, whom he represented in the Supreme Court and for bail in the fodder scam case on 13 December 2013; Subrata Roy in the Sahara–SEBI case; and J. Jayalalithaa in relation to her conviction by the Karnataka High Court in a disproportionate-assets case. He represented Arvind Kejriwal in a defamation action brought by Arun Jaitley. He took up the defence of Manu Sharma, the principal accused in Jessica Lal’s murder, but did not secure Sharma’s acquittal. Jethmalani was also expected to defend former Indian Premier League chairman and commissioner Lalit Modi. Although he spoke publicly against the death sentence imposed on Afzal Guru, he did not take up Guru’s case.
During the Emergency, Jethmalani chaired the Bar Association of India and strongly criticized Prime Minister Indira Gandhi. Kerala issued an arrest warrant against him; the Bombay High Court stayed it after more than 300 lawyers, led by Nani Palkhivala, appeared on his behalf. That stay was later nullified following the habeas corpus judgment in Additional District Magistrate of Jabalpur v. Shiv Kant Shukla. Jethmalani went into exile in Canada and continued his campaign against the Emergency. Ten months later, after it had ended, he returned to India. While he was abroad, his candidacy was filed for the Mumbai North West Lok Sabha constituency.
Jethmalani won a Lok Sabha seat in the 1977 general election, defeating serving Union Law Minister H. R. Gokhale, and retained the Mumbai North West seat in 1980. He lost to Sunil Dutt in 1985. Although the 1977 victory began his parliamentary career, he was not appointed law minister in Morarji Desai’s government; Desai disapproved of his lifestyle. Jethmalani became a Rajya Sabha member in 1988. In 1996 he was appointed Union Minister of Law and Justice and Company Affairs in Vajpayee’s cabinet. In 1998 he received the Union portfolio for Urban Affairs and Employment. On 13 October 1999 he was sworn in again as Minister of Law, Justice and Company Affairs. Vajpayee later asked him to resign following disagreements involving Chief Justice of India Adarsh Sein Anand and Attorney General Soli Sorabjee; Home Minister L. K. Advani had insisted that Jethmalani be included in the cabinet.
Jethmalani contested the 2004 general election as an independent candidate against Vajpayee in Lucknow. The Indian National Congress did not field a candidate there, but Jethmalani lost. In 2010 he returned to the BJP, won election to the Rajya Sabha on its Rajasthan ticket, and served on the Committee on Personnel, Public Grievances, Law and Justice. He was criticized as opportunistic. At a Pakistan High Commission reception on 28 July 2011 for visiting Pakistani Foreign Minister Hina Rabbani Khar, and in the presence of China’s ambassador, he called China an enemy of both India and Pakistan and warned people in both countries to be wary of it.
In December 2009, Jethmalani joined Shanti Bhushan, Fali Sam Nariman, Anil B. Divan, Kamini Jaiswal and Prashant Bhushan in a statement by the Committee on Judicial Accountability and Judicial Reforms. It called for public debate and review by members of the affected high courts before recommendations for judicial appointments, amid controversy over the proposed appointments of Chandramauli Kumar Prasad and P. D. Dinakaran. In 2012 Jethmalani wrote to BJP president Nitin Gadkari, accusing BJP leaders of remaining silent about alleged corruption in the United Progressive Alliance government and saying the party was “sick.” In November he said Gadkari should have kept away from office while serious allegations were being made against him, and asserted that the RSS was trying to influence the BJP because its leaders had grown up with the organization. The BJP expelled Jethmalani for six years in May 2013 over statements it deemed anti-party. That October, defamation charges were framed in a BJP action seeking ₹50 lakh in damages over his statement that he was not fit to be a party member.
Jethmalani launched the Bharat Mukti Morcha as a mass movement in 1987 and established the Pavitra Hindustan Kazhagam in 1995 with a stated commitment to transparency in Indian democracy. He also announced his candidacy for President of India, saying that he owed the nation an offer of his services. In later years he was regarded as an elder statesman while remaining India’s oldest practising lawyer. In 2017 he wrote an open letter advising Justice C. S. Karnan of the Calcutta High Court, then embroiled in controversy, to withdraw his statements and seek pardon; Jethmalani sharply criticized Karnan’s conduct and questioned his mental state. Karnan retired shortly afterward.
On 9 September 2017, Jethmalani announced his retirement from legal practice. He died at his home in New Delhi on 8 September 2019, aged 95, six days before his 96th birthday. His son Mahesh said that Jethmalani had been unwell for several months; he died at 7:45 a.m. Indian Standard Time. Former colleagues later wrote remembrances of him. Jethmalani was portrayed by Sachin Khedekar in the 2016 film Rustom, by Mithilesh Chaturvedi in the Sony LIV series Scam 1992, by Sumeet Vyas in the Hindi web series The Verdict, and by Ram Kapoor in the film The Big Bull. The latter three screen portrayals drew on the Harshad Mehta stock-market case, the Nanavati case, and Mehta’s life and crimes, respectively.
As a refugee in Bombay, challenged the Bombay Refugees Act in the High Court, seeking to have it declared unconstitutional; the court ruled in his favour.
Built a high-profile legal practice spanning major criminal, public-law and commercial cases, including the Nanavati case and representation in several prominent investigations and trials.
Authored books on law and public life and co-authored legal scholarship in criminal, administrative and media law.
Jethmalani’s political outlook included advocacy of improved relations between India and Pakistan, shaped by his experience of displacement during Partition. He entered electoral politics as an independent candidate backed by the Shiv Sena and Bharatiya Jana Sangh, later contested and won parliamentary elections as a Janata Party candidate, and subsequently held office with Bharatiya Janata Party support. In 1987 he launched the Bharat Mukti Morcha as a mass movement; in 1995 he founded the Pavitra Hindustan Kazhagam, which called for transparency in Indian democracy.
During the 1975–1977 Emergency, Jethmalani publicly opposed Prime Minister Indira Gandhi’s government and continued his campaign from exile in Canada. He later served in Parliament and in Union cabinets led by Atal Bihari Vajpayee. After returning to the BJP in 2010 and winning a Rajya Sabha seat on its ticket, he criticized the party’s response to alleged corruption in the United Progressive Alliance government and questioned Nitin Gadkari’s leadership. The BJP expelled him for six years in May 2013 over statements it considered anti-party. His political career also included a 2004 independent challenge to Vajpayee and a declared offer of his services as a candidate for President of India.
Membership
Jethmalani took part in professional legal organizations through leadership roles at the Bar Association of India, Bar Council of India and Supreme Court Bar Association. The Bar Council of India is the national body for the regulation of legal practice and legal education, while the Supreme Court Bar Association represents advocates practising before India’s highest court. He also joined the International Bar Association, an international organization of legal practitioners and bar associations.
Member.
International Bar Association
1996
Chairman during the Emergency.
Bar Association of India
,
India
1975 - 1977
Served as chairman for four terms.
Bar Council of India
,
India
President.
Supreme Court Bar Association
,
India
2010
Personality
In an interview, Jethmalani acknowledged shortcomings in his married life, saying, “I plead guilty to being a bad husband.”
Connections
Jethmalani married Durga in an arranged marriage at about 18. In 1947, shortly before Partition, he married Ratna Shahani, a lawyer. He had four children: Rani, Shobha and Mahesh with Durga, and Janak with Ratna.
His two sons and two daughters pursued varied public and professional work. Mahesh and Rani became Supreme Court lawyers; Mahesh also became a BJP leader, while Rani was a social activist. Actress Kamna Jethmalani, known for Telugu and Tamil films, was the granddaughter of one of Ram Jethmalani’s brothers.
Wife:
Durga Jethmalani
They had three children: Rani, Shobha and Mahesh.
Wife:
Ratna Shahani
A lawyer; they married in 1947 and had one child, Janak.
Daughter:
Rani Jethmalani
A Supreme Court lawyer and social activist.
Daughter:
Shobha Jethmalani
Son:
Mahesh Jethmalani
A Supreme Court lawyer and BJP leader.
Son:
Janak Jethmalani
colleague:
A. K. Brohi
A lawyer and friend who partnered with Jethmalani in a Karachi law firm and advised him to leave during the 1948 riots.
colleague:
Nani Palkhivala
Led more than 300 lawyers who appeared for Jethmalani when an arrest warrant had been issued during the Emergency.