Career
Hibernian
He made just one more substitute appearance that season and did not play again until 3 February 2007, and on 21 April that year he was given a straight red card for a foul on Chris Clark, with teammate Dermot McCaffrey also dismissed in the 2–2 draw with Aberdeen at Pittodrie. He did not feature at all for Hibs during the 2007-2008 season and was sent on an emergency loan to First Division Street Johnstone in February. He was returned to Hibs after being injured in his first game for Saints, a 3–2 Tayside derby defeat away to Dundee on 1 March.
Falkirk
Lynch was released by Hibs manager Mixu Paatelainen in August 2008, and signed for fellow SPL club Falkirk a month later.
Lynch was released by Falkirk after the club was relegated from the Scottish Premier League in May 2010. Street Mirren
Following a trial spell, Lynch signed for Street Mirren in July 2010.
He made his league debut for the club in a 1–1 draw against Dundee United on 14 August, and scored a volley from the edge of the penalty area. He made 14 appearances over the season for the Buddies, scoring one more goal, a consolation in a 2–1 loss at Street Johnstone on 18 September.
Airdrie United
Lynch signed for Airdrie United of the Second Division in July 2011.
Stenhousemuir
He left Airdrie in May 2013 and subsequently signed for Stenhousemuir. Lynch scored the winning penalty in a shootout against Dundee that allowed Stenhousemuir to progress to the semi-finals of the 2013-2014 Scottish Challenge Cup. Lynch was released by Stenhousemuir in May 2014.