The club finished second-bottom of Division Three and were relegated, though McIlhargey only started 22 of the 46 games. Blackpool finished the campaign in fifth place, but missed out on promotion after losing to Torquay United in the play-off final.
During his career, he played for Walsall, Chester City and He also represented Scotland at schoolboy level He is currently goalkeeping coach at Fleetwood Town.
McIlhargey joined from Walsall in the summer of 1989.
He made his league debut in the opening game, against Wigan Athletic at Bloomfield Road on 19 August, and kept a clean sheet in a goalless draw. His first season with the Seasiders wasn"t a successful one.
In October 1989, McIlhargey required fifty stitches in a facial injury sustained during a training-ground accident three weeks earlier. In the 1990-1991 season, McIlhargey missed only two league games and kept seventeen clean sheets.
The conclusion of the following season, 1991-1992, was the moment for which he is best remembered. made the Wembley play-off final for the second consecutive season, this time against Scunthorpe United.
After 90 minutes, the score was tied at 1–1, and the match went to extra time and then a penalty shoot-out. lieutenant was in the latter that McIlhargey"s save from Scotland international Graham Alexander"s penalty, combined with Jason White"s subsequent miss, sent the Seasiders into the new Division Two. In an act of sportsmanship, McIlhargey broke away from celebrating with his teammates and was the first to commiserate with White.
With Lee Martin and Mel Capleton selected as goalkeeper numbers one and two, the Scot traded the seaside for that of nearby in the summer of 1993 for the remaining decade of his playing career.
He helped the Shrimps to secure their place in the Conference, and his league experience was crucial in their push for promotion. In the years leading up to his retirement, McIlhargey became the Shrimps" back-up goalkeeper but was rarely named on the substitutes" bench, with manager Jim Harvey preferring to have five outfield players to choose from.
McIlhargey retired from playing in May 2004 but remained at in the capacity of goalkeeping coach. He was named on the bench for both of "s Johnstone"s Paints Trophy regional final matches during the 2007-2008 season, due to first-choice goalkeeper Jalal being cup-tied.
