Walter Ulbricht was a German communist politician and the dominant leader of the German Democratic Republic from 1950 until his removal in 1971. He shaped the SED state, imposed a Soviet-patterned socialist system, advanced economic reforms and bore political responsibility for the Berlin Wall. He remained chairman of the State Council until his death in 1973.
Background
Ulbricht was born in Leipzig on June 30, 1893, the first child of Ernst August Ulbricht, a trained tailor, and Pauline Ida Rothe. His parents were active Social Democrats. The family lived at Gottschedstraße 4, now number 25; Gustav Mahler had lived in the same building in 1886–1887, and Gustav Stresemann moved there as a student in 1899.
Ulbricht last saw his parents and siblings in the mid-1920s, at the wedding of his sister Hildegard. His mother died in 1926; his father was killed during an Allied air raid on Leipzig in 1943. Hildegard was living in Hamburg in 1961. His brother had emigrated to the United States in 1928, and neither sibling remained in contact with him.
Education
Ulbricht attended Volksschule and, in 1907, began an apprenticeship in cabinetmaking, which he completed in 1911. In 1908 he joined the Alt-Leipzig Workers' Youth Education Association. From 1913 he belonged to the Leipzig-Mitte group called the Corpora, originally formed as a cover organization to evade the Anti-Socialist Laws. Ulbricht called the group the Interna and described it as a close circle of functionaries; he said he had been admitted after distributing leaflets and undertaking other organizational tasks.
As a young activist he lectured to SPD youth groups and volunteered at the Workers' Education Institute and in the Leipzig workers' youth movement. During the First World War he supported the SPD's left wing around Karl Liebknecht and Rosa Luxemburg. At a Greater Leipzig SPD functionaries' meeting in December 1914 he urged its Reichstag representatives to oppose further war credits. The motion failed, and he was personally attacked for advocating it. He joined the USPD in 1917.
Career
Ulbricht served in the German army from 1915 to 1918 as a private in Supply and Transport Column 218, on the Eastern Front and in Serbia and Macedonia. He contracted malaria and spent part of 1917–1918 in a hospital in Skopje. Though he did not engage in agitation while in uniform, military authorities regarded him as politically suspect. In 1918 he deserted while being transferred to the Western Front, was caught and sentenced to two months' imprisonment. After release he was again assigned to military service in Brussels, where he was detained after antiwar leaflets were found in his possession. The November Revolution enabled him to flee before another military court proceeding. During the revolution he served on the soldiers' council of the XIX Army Corps in Leipzig.
Around 1920 Ulbricht transferred to the KPD and rapidly advanced as a party official, reorganizing the party district of Greater Thuringia. At the KPD's eighth congress in Leipzig in February 1923 he was elected as Thuringia's delegate to the party's central leadership and became a Politburo secretary. Ruth Fischer's ultra-left leadership removed him from that position in 1924 for alleged right deviation. He attended the Communist International's Fourth World Congress in Moscow and Petrograd in 1920, where he met Lenin, returned to Moscow in 1922, and worked for the Comintern from 1924. He advocated organizing the KPD through workplace cells instead of residential groups.
Ulbricht won election to the Saxon state parliament in 1926 and served through 1929. From 1928 he represented Westphalia-South in the Reichstag; he also won election in the Potsdam II constituency in July 1932, November 1932 and March 1933, after earlier successful candidacies in Reichstag elections. He became active in the KPD Central Committee. In 1928–1929 he worked on party trade-union policy, promoting a radicalized strike strategy against the free trade unions associated with the ADGB, and published essays on the subject. From 1929 he sat on the Reich Committee of the Revolutionary Trade Union Opposition (RGO), and became involved in disputes between the party and the RGO's structures.
In 1929 Ulbricht became political leader of the KPD district Berlin-Brandenburg-Lausitz-Grenzmark. In Berlin he directed the party's struggle against the SPD, which he considered the communists' main enemy in accordance with the social-fascism thesis. In January 1931 he accepted a Nazi invitation to debate Berlin Gauleiter Joseph Goebbels at the Friedrichshain assembly hall; the event ended in a fight among supporters of the two men. In summer 1931 he backed a referendum initiative, advanced by right-wing parties including the Nazis, to dissolve the Prussian parliament. When its failure became clear, the Berlin KPD leadership arranged the killing of police officers Anlauf and Lenck outside party headquarters at Bülowplatz on August 9. Historical accounts differ over whether Ulbricht knew of or was involved in the killings. In November 1932 he helped organize the Berlin Transport Company strike, which was also supported by the Nazi workplace organization.
After the Nazis took power on January 30, 1933, Ulbricht continued KPD work underground and chaired a secret party officials' meeting at Sporthaus Ziegenhals near Berlin on February 7. Berlin authorities sought him over a December 1932 general-strike appeal alleged to have sought violent constitutional change and over inflammatory remarks said to precede the Bülowplatz police murders. By Politburo decision he fled to Prague in October 1933, then moved with his wife and daughter to Paris. There he organized communist resistance in Germany through the KPD Politburo and, with Willi Münzenberg, led negotiations for a popular front. In 1935 he returned to Prague to negotiate cooperation with the SPD leadership in exile. Germany revoked his citizenship in April 1937. He went to Moscow in 1938 as the KPD's representative.
At the start of the Second World War Ulbricht defended the German-Soviet non-aggression pact, claiming that the Red Army's strength would compel Hitler's government to pursue peaceful relations with the Soviet Union. In 1940 he edited the Stockholm journal Welt and opposed other resistance figures' proposals to support Britain against Nazi Germany. He argued that such support would assist British imperialism rather than direct progressive forces against German terror and reaction. After Germany invaded the Soviet Union in June 1941, the Comintern assigned him to German-language programming at Radio Moscow. During the Battle of Stalingrad he addressed German troops from a trench by loudspeaker, urging them to surrender or defect. In Soviet prisoner-of-war camps he sought to recruit German soldiers to support a postwar order shaped by the KPD.
In 1943 Ulbricht co-founded the National Committee for a Free Germany (NKFD), an initiative devised by the Red Army's political department to bring communist émigrés and German prisoners of war together under a popular-front approach. In July of that year The Times first mentioned him as a co-author of the NKFD manifesto “Peace or Annihilation.” On April 30, 1945, he returned from Soviet exile to devastated Germany as head of the Ulbricht Group. In the Soviet occupation zone he organized the KPD's re-establishment and helped arrange its 1946 merger with the SPD to form the SED in Berlin. In a radio address in early July 1945 he called for a socialist youth organization, the Free German Youth (FDJ). From 1946 to 1950 he represented the SED in the provincial legislature of Saxony-Anhalt, which became the Land of Saxony-Anhalt in 1947, and served on its Legal and Constitutional Committee and Economic Committee.
After the GDR was founded on October 7, 1949, Ulbricht became deputy chairman of the Council of Ministers under Otto Grotewohl. On November 24, 1955, he became its first deputy chairman, serving in that capacity until 1960. He was a member of the People's Chamber from 1949 to 1973. After the SED's Third Party Congress, the Central Committee elected him general secretary on July 25, 1950; following the June 17, 1953 uprising, the office was renamed First Secretary. Though Grotewohl was prime minister and Wilhelm Pieck president, Ulbricht held the greatest political decision-making power. He led the SED Central Committee from 1950 until his removal in 1971 and helped build the apparatus of the later East German state in close cooperation with the Soviet occupying power.
The SED controlled the state apparatus inherited from the Soviet zone, mass organizations and public communication, and adopted Marxism-Leninism as state ideology. Ulbricht built a power base through careful personnel decisions and the design of the party organization. At his initiative, a small secretariat modeled on the Communist Party of the Soviet Union was created in January 1949, with Ulbricht as chair. It prepared Politburo agendas and proposals, and controlled appointments to senior party posts. From October 17, 1949, government proposals and measures had to be approved by the SED Politburo or its Small Secretariat before presentation to the People's Chamber. Ulbricht prepared agendas and decision papers and often dealt bilaterally with officials. He communicated in private correspondence with State Security official Erich Mielke, later minister, excluding other Politburo members.
Among Politburo members, Ulbricht had particularly strong links to Soviet authorities. During the KPD's re-establishment he placed his partner Lotte Wendt, fluent in spoken and written Russian, at an important communications point in the party apparatus. His biographer Mario Frank characterized his adjustment to successive Soviet policy changes as opportunistic. Ulbricht acted quickly against officials who did not adapt, as in the case of Anton Ackermann, and used these changes to remove some functionaries and promote others. Soviet representatives increasingly dealt with him directly, bypassing Grotewohl and Pieck. This occurred in the 1950 dissolution of internment camps and the subsequent Waldheim trials: Ulbricht's Central Committee secretariat selected the SED official who politically guided judges and prosecutors. He also controlled a secret SED investigation proposed by senior Soviet official Semenov in preparation for a show trial connected with the Noel Field affair; even the Central Party Control Commission was excluded.
Ulbricht exercised personal influence over death sentences in two 1955 cases. Before the proposed trial of members of the Combat Group against Inhumanity, the SED Central Committee's legal department sent him proposed sentences for defendants who had scouted sites for possible sabotage in 1950–1952 but had since provided only reports and individual information to West Berlin. None had committed violence. The department proposed death for Gerhard Benkowitz and 15 years' imprisonment for Hans-Dietrich Kogel. Ulbricht changed Kogel's proposed sentence to death, altered another proposed term to 15 years, marked the proposals approved and sent them to Grotewohl for comment. The following day he reviewed proposed sentences in the RIAS trial, involving informants who supplied information to the broadcaster but had committed no violent acts or scouted targets. He replaced the proposed life sentence for Joachim Wiebach with a recommendation for death. Benkowitz and Kogel were executed at Dresden's central execution site on June 29, 1955, and Wiebach on September 14.
After the Western governments' refusal of the Stalin Notes and the Treaty on Relations between the Federal Republic of Germany and the Three Powers, Ulbricht obtained Stalin's approval and imposed a Soviet-patterned program to build socialism at the SED's Second Party Conference in July 1952. The inner-German border, already subject to a Council of Ministers decision in May, was further sealed. The Barracked People's Police, created shortly before, became the GDR's first army and was expanded into the National People's Army in 1956. The Ministry for State Security, established in 1950, also grew and intensified action against actual and alleged opponents, particularly Protestant youth congregations; the state stopped collecting church taxes. The five Länder were abolished and government centralized. Nationalization accelerated, heavy industry took precedence over consumer-goods production, and agriculture was collectivized. The policy met resistance among farmers; only in 1960 had all farmers joined agricultural production cooperatives.
Stalin's death on March 5, 1953, left Ulbricht's position vulnerable because he was seen as an archetypal Stalinist. Plans for lavish celebrations of his sixtieth birthday on June 30 were abandoned amid the crisis around the June 17 uprising. A lavish commemorative volume was pulped, a finished film, Baumeister des Sozialismus – Walter Ulbricht, was withheld from release, and a planned postage stamp bearing his portrait was not issued. The uprising, partly provoked by the accelerated socialist program he had ordered, paradoxically helped preserve his leadership: Soviet authorities regarded his removal as a sign of weakness, while rivals Wilhelm Zaisser and Rudolf Herrnstadt lacked Soviet support. Ulbricht won the internal SED struggle. In 1958, critics including Karl Schirdewan, Ernst Wollweber, Fritz Selbmann, Fred Oelßner and Gerhart Ziller were denounced as faction-builders and politically removed.
In 1960 Ulbricht became chairman of the National Defense Council and of the new State Council, established after Pieck's death to replace the office of president. He thereby held the principal governing powers of party and state and became head of state. He chaired the National Defense Council until 1971 and the State Council until his death, although powers of the latter office were later transferred in part to the Council of Ministers.
Ulbricht bore political responsibility for construction of the Berlin Wall in 1961. He negotiated forcefully with Moscow and persuaded the Soviet leadership that the GDR needed to stop the departure of skilled workers and other members of the population. At a press conference on June 15, 1961, responding to West German journalist Annamarie Doherr, he denied that anyone intended to build a wall and became the first to introduce the word “wall” in this context. Whether he did so deliberately or inadvertently remained unresolved. At about 1 a.m. on Sunday, August 13, East German forces began sealing the boundary between East and West Berlin and the full boundary between West Berlin and the GDR, deploying large numbers of personnel and equipment to erect barriers along nearly 170 kilometers.
Ulbricht directed cultural and architectural policy as the state was being built. At the SED's Third Party Congress he called for a break with what he termed Western formalism, associated with the Bauhaus tradition, and insisted that architecture should have a national form. The policy accompanied the creation of the German Building Academy and the journal Deutsche Architektur, while producing contradictory demolition and construction decisions. In the 1950s and 1960s, many war-damaged but restorable historic buildings were razed to make way for socialist city centers. The Berlin Palace was demolished in 1950 and Potsdam City Palace in 1959. About 60 churches, including 17 in East Berlin, were demolished or blown up, among them Magdeburg's Ulrich Church in 1956, Dresden's Sophienkirche in 1963, the ruins of Potsdam's Garrison Church on June 23, 1968, and Leipzig University's 700-year-old church on May 30, 1968. Protests against the church demolitions led to arrests. New buildings included the socialist-classical architecture of Berlin's Stalinallee.
Ulbricht regarded socialism as a separate, extended stage and advanced a national road to socialism, distinguishing the GDR from other Council for Mutual Economic Assistance countries. The approach was reflected in National People's Army uniforms incorporating elements of Wehrmacht dress, military orders named for Prussian figures such as Blücher and Scharnhorst, and the wording of the GDR anthem, whose original text was later dropped under Honecker. After the Wall was built, the regime initially opened more space for domestic youth culture. Ulbricht sought to foster an East German youth culture independent of Western influence and criticized copying Western popular music. Referring to the Beatles' “Yeah, Yeah, Yeah,” he asked whether the GDR had to imitate “every piece of rubbish” from the West and called for an end to the monotony of “Je-Je-Je.”
The 1952 administrative reform eliminated the five Länder and divided the GDR into 14 districts, with East Berlin as capital, reducing regional self-government. Economic conditions became precarious amid higher production targets in the late 1950s, accelerated collectivization and the Berlin crisis intensified by Nikita Khrushchev's threats. The Wall's closure of the border in 1961 stabilized the state. Beginning in 1963, Ulbricht promoted the New Economic System of Planning and Management, later shortened to the New Economic System (NÖSPL/NÖS), with Wolfgang Berger and Erich Apel as important advocates. It retained an overall plan but gave individual enterprises greater authority, on the premise that local decisions and responsibility could improve efficiency.
Economic modernization was accompanied by social changes, including the 1965 Education Act. The GDR increasingly functioned as a socialist meritocracy in which qualifications as well as political reliability could shape occupational and social position, and trained specialists gained leadership roles. The 1968 constitution enshrined the economic and social changes. Ulbricht promoted scientific management of both the economy and political administration, drawing on economic cybernetics, operations research, psychology, sociology and natural-science and systems methods. The proposed expansion of computerization and electronic data processing was intended to link economic planning with scientific expertise and provide firms with greater autonomy. In spring 1972 the GDR still had about 11,400 medium-sized enterprises, including roughly 6,500 partly state-owned firms, many producing consumer goods and services, a sector regarded unfavorably by many SED members.
Ulbricht helped the GDR earn foreign currency for Comecon by arranging barter-financed products and raw materials from member states for onward sale to Western countries through intra-German trade. He unsuccessfully pressed for oil exploration to reduce dependence on the Soviet Union and catch up with West Germany, which then produced more than 30 percent of its own oil requirements. Negotiations failed in 1965, after which State Planning Commission chairman Erich Apel shot himself. Resistance to the New Economic System grew within the SED. Honecker, supported by Brezhnev and many party members, became the leading opponent and pushed through a major new wave of nationalization in 1972.
Ulbricht promoted the GDR as a model of an industrialized socialist society and used the phrase “socialist community of nations,” which was abandoned soon after his death. The GDR's comparatively strong economic performance within Comecon informed his claim, but his insistence on a distinctive path produced ideological disputes with the Soviet Communist Party. He supported the Warsaw Pact's military suppression of the Prague Spring in 1968 and opposed Czechoslovak efforts to examine Stalinism and the personality cult, which he saw as threatening his own position. The East German National People's Army did not participate in the invasion of Czechoslovakia, despite later official propaganda claiming that it had. Ulbricht's position on German relations, known as the Ulbricht Doctrine, held that normal diplomatic relations between the GDR and Federal Republic required each to recognize the other's full sovereignty. It contrasted with West Germany's Hallstein Doctrine, under which the Federal Republic broke relations with states recognizing the GDR.
From 1969 disputes with other Politburo members over the economy and foreign policy weakened Ulbricht. In the context of West German Chancellor Willy Brandt's Ostpolitik, Ulbricht was willing to defer negotiations on formal recognition, including the exchange of ambassadors, in expectation of economic benefits. Most Politburo members disagreed. Soviet support had already diminished from 1967, when Ulbricht described the GDR as moving toward a developed socialist system and as a distinct social formation. His claim that the GDR could match the Soviet Union's asserted progress toward communism challenged the CPSU's monopoly on interpreting Marxism-Leninism and drew criticism from Soviet leaders and social scientists.
Ulbricht shaped the political and administrative structure of the German Democratic Republic and consolidated the SED's control of the state.
He advanced the New Economic System of Planning and Management, retaining central planning while granting enterprises greater scope for decision-making.
The Ulbricht Doctrine set out the GDR leadership's position that normal relations with West Germany required mutual recognition of sovereignty.
He co-founded the National Committee for a Free Germany in 1943 and helped bring about the 1946 merger of the KPD and SPD into the Socialist Unity Party of Germany.
Works
journal
Welt
(Ulbricht edited this Stockholm-based journal and publishe...)
manifesto
Peace or Annihilation
(Manifesto co-authored by Ulbricht in connection with the ...)
1943
Politics
Ulbricht joined the Social Democratic Party of Germany (SPD) in 1912 and moved to its left-wing Independent Social Democratic Party (USPD) in 1917. Around 1920 he joined the Communist Party of Germany (KPD), whose leadership he served in the Weimar years, and in 1928 he also joined the Communist Party of the Soviet Union. He helped merge the KPD and SPD in the Soviet occupation zone in 1946 to create the Socialist Unity Party of Germany (SED), and became one of its dominant leaders.
His politics followed Marxism-Leninism and were closely aligned with the Soviet Union. In the late Weimar Republic he promoted the KPD's radical trade-union and strike strategy and opposed the SPD as the communists' principal enemy under the social-fascism thesis. In East Germany he built a one-party socialist state, centralized authority in the SED, and oversaw the suppression of political opposition. His government advanced nationalization and agricultural collectivization and sealed the border with West Berlin through construction of the Berlin Wall.
Ulbricht also argued for a distinct national path to socialism and for technocratic economic administration. His reforms sought to retain central planning while granting enterprises more decision-making scope, and he presented the GDR as a model for industrialized socialist societies. These positions brought him into ideological conflict with Soviet leaders. He supported the suppression of the Prague Spring and resisted reassessment of Stalinism. His authority ended in 1971 when Erich Honecker, with Soviet backing, displaced him.
Views
Ulbricht understood socialism as a distinct, extended stage of development and promoted a national path suited to an industrialized East Germany. He advocated scientific and technical methods in governance, including economic cybernetics, operations research, computerization and the application of specialist knowledge. His claim that the GDR represented a distinct and advanced socialist society challenged Soviet authority over the interpretation of Marxist-Leninist doctrine.
Personality
Ulbricht was generally distrustful and possessed little rhetorical flair. He built and exercised political authority through the close management of appointments, information and party procedure, often handling important matters through individual discussions with officials. His readiness to adjust to Soviet policy shifts and his swift removal of officials who failed to follow the new line were features of his political method.
He took a close interest in the planning and public presentation of major construction projects, appearing at topping-out ceremonies and openings as part of his political self-presentation. Authorities also publicized his sporting activities, including table tennis, skiing, rowing and volleyball with young people. Official propaganda portrayed him as the builder of socialism and as a leader closely connected with the population, but it failed to generate broad popular enthusiasm. The attempt to make him appear charismatic gave way to simply depicting him as charismatic.
Physical Characteristics:
Ulbricht was 1.65 meters tall and stockily built. His whistling, fistula-like voice had a Saxon accent and may have resulted from a laryngeal condition present at least from 1925. He often ended sentences with the confirming word “ja?”
Quotes from others about the person
Historian Steffen Alisch wrote in 2008 that Ulbricht possessed the concentration of power characteristic of a dictator; historian Ilko-Sascha Kowalczuk has likewise identified him as a dictator. Historian Rainer Gries observed that Ulbricht's propaganda shifted from trying to create charisma to merely presenting him as charismatic. Thomas Grimm and Thomas Kunze characterized Ulbricht's self-image as “builder of socialism” and concluded that his personality cult never produced the broad popular response associated with Wilhelm Pieck; in their view, he could not assume the role of a sympathetic father of the nation. Writer Gerhard Zwerenz called him a “gray, whistling mouse.”
Interests
Ulbricht took a personal interest in architecture, urban planning and the presentation of state construction projects. He engaged in table tennis, skiing, rowing and volleyball, and sought to cultivate a distinct East German youth culture rather than imitate Western popular music.
Politicians
Vladimir Lenin
Connections
Ulbricht married Martha Schmellinsky, a Leipzig machine sewer, in 1920. They had been friends since 1915, but their life together was limited to brief periods of days or weeks and they grew apart. He last visited her shortly before going underground in 1933; they divorced in 1949. Their daughter Dora, born in 1920, later lived with her husband and two sons in West Germany without contact with Ulbricht.
From the 1920s, particularly during his Paris years, Ulbricht had a relationship with Rosa Michel, born Marie Wacziarg in Warsaw in 1901. She was Polish, belonged to the French Communist Party and worked for the Communist International's Executive Committee. She later served in the French Resistance, was the Berlin correspondent for the party newspaper L'Humanité from 1945 to 1948, and then worked as a Paris correspondent for the East German ADN news agency. Their daughter Rose was born in Moscow in 1931. Ulbricht's family kept in touch with Michel's two daughters into the 1990s, including after Walter Ulbricht and Michel had died.
The relationship with Michel ended in 1935, when Lotte Kühn, then the wife of Erich Wendt, became Ulbricht's partner. Lotte remained his companion and married him in 1953; she was regarded as East Germany's first lady until his removal from power. Her sister Grete Winkler (1901–1986) lived in the Ulbricht household. When Walter and Lotte could not have a child together, they took Maria Pestunowa, a one-and-a-half-year-old Soviet citizen and half-orphan, into foster care from Saxon foster parents in 1946 and gave her the name Beate Ulbricht. She was their second foster child called Beate: the first, Beate Krause, born in 1942, had been returned to her mother after seven months. Maria's mother, a Ukrainian forced laborer, had been killed in the 1944 air raid on Leipzig. Beate lived in the Soviet Union from 1959; after returning in 1963 she became estranged from Walter and Lotte. She married twice, had two children and died in Berlin in 1991, living with alcoholism and on social assistance.
Father:
Ernst August Ulbricht
A trained tailor; he died in an Allied air raid on Leipzig in 1943.
Mother:
Pauline Ida Ulbricht
Born Pauline Ida Rothe; she died in 1926.
Wife:
Martha Schmellinsky
A Leipzig machine sewer; married Ulbricht in 1920, divorced in 1949, and mother of their daughter Dora.
Daughter:
Dora Ulbricht
Born in 1920; she later lived in West Germany with her husband and two sons.
Partner:
Rosa Michel
Born Marie Wacziarg in Warsaw in 1901; she was a French Communist Party member, a Communist International employee, a Resistance participant and a correspondent for L'Humanité and ADN.
Daughter:
Rose Ulbricht
Daughter of Walter Ulbricht and Rosa Michel, born in Moscow in 1931.
Wife:
Lotte Ulbricht
Born Lotte Kühn; she became Ulbricht's partner in 1935 and wife in 1953. She had previously been married to Erich Wendt.
Daughter:
Beate Ulbricht
Born Maria Pestunowa, she was taken into foster care by Walter and Lotte Ulbricht in 1946. She later lived in the Soviet Union, married twice and had two children.
Sister:
Hildegard Ulbricht
She lived in Hamburg in 1961.
Brother:
Erich Ulbricht
He emigrated to the United States in 1928.
political rival:
Erich Honecker
He succeeded Ulbricht as First Secretary of the SED Central Committee in 1971.
Political associate:
Vladimir Lenin
Ulbricht met Lenin at the Communist International's Fourth World Congress in 1920.
political opponent:
Joseph Goebbels
Ulbricht debated the Nazi Berlin Gauleiter at a public meeting in January 1931.
colleague:
Willi Münzenberg
He worked with Ulbricht on negotiations to form a popular front in exile in Paris.
Political associate:
Leonid Brezhnev
The Soviet leader withdrew support for Ulbricht and backed the transition to Honecker's leadership.
Political associate:
Willy Brandt
As West German chancellor, his Ostpolitik formed part of Ulbricht's negotiations and disagreements over relations between the two German states.