Creavalle appeared in 73 career collegiate games, and he scored eight goals and had 10 assists. He played two years at before transferring to University of Central Florida. In 2010, he was named to the All-American Third Team, becoming first UCF player to earn All-America status since 1997.
The following year, Crevalle earned All-Conference United States of America First Team honors.
That year he played in 17 games with 16 starts. He scored one goal and three assists.
Creavalle was named to MAC Hermann Trophy Watch List. Creavalle was also named to All-Conference United States of America First Team once again.
He became the first player in program history to be named to the NSCAA/Performance Subaru All-South Region First Team.
In 2010, he played with the Carolina Dynamo in the Professional Development League.