Boston Latin School, where Charles Sumner studied (until 1830). Photo: Kenneth C. Zirkel
College/University
Gallery of Charles Sumner
Harvard Law School, where Charles Sumner studied (Law degree, 1830–1834)
Career
Gallery of Charles Sumner
1880
$500 silver certificate of 1880, with Sumner's portrait
Gallery of Charles Sumner
1856
Lithograph of Preston Brooks' 1856 attack on Sumner
Gallery of Charles Sumner
1860
1860 steel-engraved portrait of Sumner
Gallery of Charles Sumner
1869
President Ulysses S. Grant, photographed by Mathew Brady in 1869.The Dominican Republic annexation treaty caused bitter contention between President Grant and Senator Sumner
Gallery of Charles Sumner
1863
Sumner and Henry Wadsworth Longfellow photographed by Gardner
President Ulysses S. Grant, photographed by Mathew Brady in 1869.The Dominican Republic annexation treaty caused bitter contention between President Grant and Senator Sumner
Charles Sumner was a Massachusetts lawyer and U.S. senator from 1851 to 1874, a leading abolitionist and a central Radical Republican during the Civil War and Reconstruction. He fought for emancipation, racial equality, and civil rights, and his early argument for equal treatment helped shape the phrase “equality before the law.”
Background
Sumner was born on January 6, 1811, at 58 Irving Street in Boston, the son of Charles Pinckney Sumner and Relief Jacob. His father, a Harvard-educated lawyer, had grown up in poverty and maintained a moderately successful practice while serving as clerk of the Massachusetts House of Representatives. His mother worked as a seamstress before her marriage. The family lived near the edge of the middle class in the predominantly Black Beacon Hill neighborhood, where Sumner encountered the accounts of injustice shared by Black Bostonians.
Charles Pinckney Sumner opposed slavery and anti-miscegenation laws and argued that emancipation without equal treatment would accomplish little. He believed that human potential could be developed through knowledge, virtue, and religion, and that social conditions shaped people's prospects. The family’s finances improved in 1825, when his father became sheriff of Suffolk County, an office he held until his death in 1838. The family attended Trinity Church and later worshipped at King's Chapel.
Education
Sumner attended Boston Latin School, where his schoolmates included Robert Charles Winthrop, James Freeman Clarke, Samuel Francis Smith, and Wendell Phillips. He graduated from Harvard College in 1830, lived in Hollis Hall, and joined the Porcellian Club. He then studied at Harvard Law School, where the jurist and legal scholar Joseph Story became his mentor. Sumner graduated in 1834.
In 1837, benefactors including Story and Congressman Richard Fletcher financed a European journey. Sumner reached France, learned French, and attended lectures at the Sorbonne on subjects including geology, Greek history, and criminal law. Observing Black students accepted among their white peers in Paris, he concluded that racial exclusion in the United States was learned rather than natural, and resolved to become an abolitionist. Over the next three years he also became fluent in Spanish, German, and Italian, met European statesmen, and traveled in Britain, France, Prussia, Scotland, and elsewhere. His European contacts included Alexis de Tocqueville, Alphonse de Lamartine, François Guizot, Ivan Turgenev, and Harriet Beecher Stowe. In 1838, Lord Brougham praised Sumner's legal knowledge and intellectual ability.
After graduating from law school, Sumner was admitted to the Massachusetts bar in 1834 and practiced in Boston in partnership with George Stillman Hillard. A visit to Washington convinced him against pursuing a political career at that point; he returned to Boston intending to concentrate on law. He contributed to the quarterly American Jurist, edited Joseph Story's court decisions and legal texts, and lectured at Harvard Law School from 1836 to 1837. After returning from Europe in 1840, he devoted increasing time to lectures, legal editing, and law journals, particularly writing on historical and biographical subjects. He also published a defense of the American position in the Maine–Canada boundary dispute, circulated by Lewis Cass, the minister to France.
Sumner entered public political life in 1845 as an outspoken Massachusetts critic of slavery. On July 4 that year he delivered The True Grandeur of Nations, an address opposing war with Mexico and advocating freedom and peace. After Texas entered the Union as a slave state, he became active in antislavery efforts. In 1847 he denounced the war with Mexico and emerged as a leader of the Massachusetts Whig Party's antislavery “Conscience” faction. He declined a Whig nomination for the U.S. House in 1848 and instead helped establish the Free Soil Party in Massachusetts, chairing its state executive committee and building a coalition of antislavery Whigs and Democrats.
His public work also encompassed education and prison reform. Working with Horace Mann, he supported improvements to Massachusetts public education. In Roberts v. City of Boston, he and Black lawyer Robert Morris represented plaintiffs challenging segregation in the city's public schools, forming the first interracial legal team to argue a case in American history. Sumner argued that Black schools were inferior and that segregation caused psychological and social harm. The Massachusetts Supreme Judicial Court ruled against the plaintiffs, but the Massachusetts legislature abolished public-school segregation in 1855. Sumner's early use of the phrase “equality before the law” became a lasting expression of the principle he advanced.
A coalition of Democratic and Free Soil legislators in the Massachusetts General Court selected Sumner for the U.S. Senate in 1851. After a three-month deadlock, he won election on April 24 by a one-vote majority, aided by Senate president Henry Wilson. His election marked a shift from the antislavery views of his predecessor, Daniel Webster, a leading supporter of the Compromise of 1850 and its Fugitive Slave Act. Sumner's maiden Senate speech, delivered on August 26, 1852, was titled Freedom National; Slavery Sectional. He spent more than three hours condemning the Fugitive Slave Act as unconstitutional and contrary to public conscience and divine law.
On May 19 and 20, 1856, during the Bleeding Kansas crisis, Sumner delivered his long “Crime against Kansas” speech, demanding Kansas's admission as a free state and attacking the Kansas–Nebraska Act and what he called the Slave Power. He excoriated Senators Stephen A. Douglas and Andrew Butler and compared David Atchison's conduct in Kansas to the conspiracy of the Roman politician Catiline. On May 22, Representative Preston Brooks, Butler's relative, attacked Sumner on the Senate floor with a gutta-percha cane, beating him until the cane broke. Representative Laurence Keitt used a pistol to hold back senators attempting to intervene. Sumner was severely injured and was absent from the Senate for an extended period. The assault became a symbol of the nation's sectional polarization: many Northerners rallied to Sumner, while Southern supporters praised Brooks. Black Americans wrote to Sumner in sympathy, some identifying with the beating as an emblem of the violence of slavery. More than a million copies of the speech circulated. Massachusetts reelected Sumner in November 1856, leaving his vacant Senate desk as a symbol of resistance to slavery and in defense of free speech.
Sumner returned to the Senate in 1857 but could not remain through a full day. On medical advice, he traveled to Europe, where the change of surroundings brought relief. In Paris he renewed friendships, attended the opera, and met prominent writers and statesmen. He toured several countries and made a second European journey beginning on May 22, 1858. In Paris, physician Charles-Édouard Brown-Séquard attributed Sumner's condition to spinal-cord injury and treated him by burning the skin along his spine; Sumner refused anesthesia. After treatment and further travels through central Europe, Italy, France, and elsewhere, he wrote that his health was improving. He returned permanently to the Senate in 1859. On June 4, 1860, he delivered “The Barbarism of Slavery,” rejecting claims that slavery was benevolent and arguing that it suppressed Southern economic development. He spent that summer campaigning against slavery and opposing compromise.
During the Civil War, Sumner became a leading Radical Republican and urged immediate abolition. He repeatedly met President Abraham Lincoln with Senators Zachariah Chandler and Benjamin Wade to discuss slavery and the rebellion. Sumner argued that emancipation should become the Union's central war aim, that military necessity could authorize it, and that abolition would strengthen the Union's moral standing abroad. He supported the enlistment of Black soldiers and the establishment of the Freedmen's Bureau. Lincoln consulted him while favoring a more gradual approach, and described Sumner as an embodiment of the national conscience. Sumner's advocacy preceded Lincoln's Emancipation Proclamation of January 1, 1863, and the Thirteenth Amendment's abolition of slavery.
After Southern senators left the Senate, Sumner became chairman of the Committee on Foreign Relations in March 1861, serving in that role until 1871. He supported U.S. recognition of Haiti, which had sought recognition since its independence in 1804; the United States recognized it in 1862. During the Trent affair in 1861, the Union Navy seized two Confederate diplomats traveling aboard a British ship, prompting a crisis with Britain. Sumner argued that the men were not contraband and should be released, and he discouraged open Senate debate to avoid embarrassing the Lincoln administration. At Lincoln's invitation, he presented the cabinet with correspondence indicating support in Britain for the diplomats' return. Lincoln ordered their release and apologized to Britain, easing the crisis.
In Reconstruction, Sumner and Thaddeus Stevens led congressional efforts to protect freed people's civil and voting rights and prevent former Confederates from regaining power. Sumner viewed the rebel state governments as having dissolved their constitutional status through secession, leaving Congress to set conditions for their return. He joined Republicans in overriding President Andrew Johnson's vetoes and supported Black suffrage, free homesteads, and public education in the South. He proposed a constitutional amendment combining abolition with equal legal status, but Congress adopted the Thirteenth Amendment instead. Sumner repeatedly sought to remove the word “white” from naturalization laws, including in 1868, 1869, and 1870, arguing that Chinese immigrants who sought citizenship could be loyal to American institutions. Those measures failed. He co-authored the Civil Rights Act of 1875 with John Mercer Langston and introduced it in the Senate in 1870; Congress passed it after his death. The Supreme Court invalidated the Act in 1883.
Sumner supported the 1867 treaty purchasing Alaska from Russia for $7.2 million. In a three-hour Senate address, he discussed the territory's history, resources, population, and climate, argued that it was strategically important in relation to British expansion from Canada, and advocated the name “Alaska,” derived from its Aleut name. He also called for public education and equal-protection laws there. The treaty passed the Senate by one vote above the required two-thirds majority. It did not formally recognize or compensate Native Alaskan peoples, whom it referred to as “uncivilized tribes”; under federal law they were entitled only to lands they inhabited, while Russian residents could become citizens and people of Russian and Indigenous descent were classified as Russian.
Sumner's position on claims against Britain arising from the Civil War strained his standing in the United Kingdom. He argued that Britain's recognition of Confederate belligerency made it responsible for the losses caused by Confederate raiders and the extension of the war. In 1869 he demanded $2 billion for broader “national claims,” in addition to $125 million for raider damage, and proposed that Britain cede Canada in settlement. The proposal offended many Britons and nearly disrupted negotiations, but the Geneva arbitration panel in 1871 declined to consider the broader claims. Sumner's influence over U.S. ambassador J. Lothrop Motley contributed to a dispute with Secretary of State Hamilton Fish and President Ulysses S. Grant; Grant later dismissed Motley.
Sumner opposed Grant's plan to annex the Dominican Republic, then commonly called Santo Domingo. Grant believed the island could provide a refuge for Black Americans facing repression in the South and offer valuable resources. In 1869 Grant's private secretary Orville Babcock negotiated a treaty with Dominican president Buenaventura Báez. Grant sent U.S. naval forces to protect the country during the negotiations, without congressional authorization. When the treaty reached the Senate in January 1870, Sumner warned that annexation could threaten Haiti, whose independence the United States had recognized in 1862, and that the naval action violated constitutional and international law. He helped lead opposition, and on June 30 the treaty failed to receive the necessary two-thirds vote. Grant retaliated by having Sumner's friend Motley dismissed and supported efforts to remove Sumner from the committee chairmanship. Sumner publicly condemned Grant and Babcock in December 1870. In March 1871, senators aligned with Grant removed Sumner as chairman. The dispute contributed to the deterioration of his health and his growing estrangement from fellow Republicans.
In 1872, Sumner joined the Liberal Republican Party, a reform movement that criticized corruption in Grant's administration and called for amnesty and “home rule” in the South. He opposed Grant's reelection and supported Horace Greeley, although the party did not support Sumner's civil-rights bill. Sumner continued to hold that equal rights were essential to genuine reconciliation. In December 1872, he proposed that U.S. Army regimental flags not carry Civil War battle names, renewing a proposal he had first advanced in 1862 and arguing that commemoration of battles between Americans perpetuated hostility. The Massachusetts legislature censured him. Poet John Greenleaf Whittier, with abolitionist Joshua Bowen Smith, helped secure rescission of the censure in early 1874; Sumner heard the resolution presented in the Senate on his final day there.
During the 1873 Virginius affair, Spanish authorities captured a ship aiding the Cuban rebellion and executed 53 crew members, including Americans and Britons. Sumner sympathized with the Cuban rebels and those executed but opposed U.S. military intervention and annexation of Cuba. He considered the ship's mission illegal despite its U.S. flag and said the United States should support Spain's First Republic. Secretary of State Hamilton Fish negotiated a peaceful settlement with Spanish president Emilio Castelar, averting war.
Sumner, long in declining health, died of a heart attack at his Washington home on March 11, 1874, while still a senator. He lay in state in the U.S. Capitol rotunda, the second senator and fourth person to receive that honor. He was buried on March 16 at Mount Auburn Cemetery in Cambridge, Massachusetts. His pallbearers included Henry Wadsworth Longfellow, Oliver Wendell Holmes, Ralph Waldo Emerson, and John Greenleaf Whittier. A eulogy by Mississippi senator Lucius Lamar later figured in the discussion of Lamar in John F. Kennedy's Profiles in Courage.
Sumner was one of the leading national opponents of slavery before the Civil War and a principal congressional advocate of emancipation, Black military service, and the Freedmen's Bureau.
His arguments for equal treatment in Roberts v. City of Boston made the case an early challenge to racial segregation in public education. Although the court ruled against the plaintiffs, Massachusetts abolished school segregation in 1855.
As a leading Radical Republican during Reconstruction, Sumner advocated civil and voting rights for freed people, equal access to public education, and the removal of racial barriers to naturalization.
Sumner co-authored the Civil Rights Act of 1875 and pressed for its passage until his final days. Passed after his death, it sought equal access to public accommodations and became a model for later civil-rights legislation, including the Civil Rights Act of 1964; the Supreme Court invalidated it in 1883.
Sumner's advocacy helped establish the phrase “equality before the law” as a concise expression of the principle of equal legal treatment.
His three-hour Senate address supporting the Alaska purchase helped secure ratification of the 1867 treaty by the required two-thirds majority, with only one vote to spare.
Sumner's beating by Preston Brooks in 1856 became a powerful symbol of sectional conflict and resistance to slavery. His empty Senate chair during his recovery was treated by supporters as a reminder of the attack and the cause he represented.
Numerous memorials bear Sumner's name, including schools and libraries in Camden, New York City, Roslindale, Washington, D.C., Topeka, Chicago, Kansas City, Minneapolis, St. Louis, and West Virginia; streets and avenues in Newton Centre, Springfield, Salem, Eastvale, Schenectady, and Humboldt; Sumner County, Kansas; and the towns of Sumner, Iowa, Nebraska, Washington, and Oregon. Other commemorations include Avenida Charles Sumner in the Dominican Republic, Avenue Charles Sumner in Port-au-Prince, Sumner Strait in Alaska, the Charles Sumner House in Boston, and the Liberty cargo ship SS Charles Sumner. Sumner Elementary School in Topeka played a role in Brown v. Board of Education and is listed on the National Register of Historic Places.
Sculptors Edmonia Lewis, Anne Whitney, and Thomas Ball created works commemorating Sumner; statues by Whitney and Ball stand in Cambridge and Boston. Wax figures depicting the Brooks assault on Sumner were exhibited at Barnum's American Museum.
Sumner was portrayed by Sam De Grasse in the 1915 film The Birth of a Nation, by John Hutton in the 2012 film Lincoln, and by Creed Bratton in the 2013 film Saving Lincoln.
(Pamphlet publication of Sumner's maiden Senate address, w...)
1852
Religion
Sumner's family attended Trinity Church and, from 1825, held a pew at King's Chapel. His father was a close associate of Unitarian leader William Ellery Channing, whose belief in the capacity of people to improve themselves informed Sumner's understanding of moral progress. Sumner held that moral law applied to governments as well as individuals, and that institutions obstructing personal advancement, including slavery and segregation, were morally wrong.
Politics
Sumner's political career began in the antislavery movement. In 1848 he helped organize the Free Soil Party in Massachusetts and chaired its state executive committee. Elected to the Senate in 1851 as a Free Soiler, he soon became a founder of the Republican Party and one of its leading antislavery voices. During the Civil War he led its Radical Republican faction, pressing for emancipation and a fundamental transformation of the South; after the war he fought for civil and voting rights for freed people and for restrictions on former Confederates' return to power.
Sumner's constitutional argument for Reconstruction treated secession as an act that had dissolved the rebel state governments, leaving Congress broad authority to shape their return. He favored Black male suffrage and supported congressional efforts to override President Andrew Johnson's vetoes, though he also proposed literacy requirements for Southern voters. His commitment to racial equality extended to naturalization: he sought to remove racial restrictions that barred Chinese and other Asian immigrants from citizenship.
As a Republican senator, Sumner supported the purchase of Alaska but opposed President Ulysses S. Grant's treaty to annex the Dominican Republic, fearing that annexation would threaten Haiti and violate constitutional and international principles. Their resulting dispute cost Sumner the chairmanship of the Senate Foreign Relations Committee in 1871. He joined the Liberal Republican Party in 1872, opposing Grant's reelection and supporting Horace Greeley, while remaining alienated from the party over its failure to back his civil-rights legislation. Sumner advocated reconciliation with the South only on the basis of equality, and opposed gestures that he believed kept sectional hostility alive.
Views
Sumner believed that human beings possessed a capacity for development and that social environment significantly shaped their prospects. He held that moral law governed public institutions as well as private conduct, and that slavery and segregation were evil because they obstructed human progress. His conviction that racial equality was fundamental to republican government informed his arguments for emancipation, citizenship, civil rights, and equal treatment under law. He also opposed imperial expansion in the Caribbean and treated the proposed Dominican annexation as a constitutional and international-law question.
Membership
Sumner belonged to the Massachusetts Society of the Cincinnati by hereditary succession from his father. He was elected to the American Philosophical Society in 1867 and to the American Antiquarian Society in 1843. His work with the latter included service on its board of councilors and, later, as secretary of foreign correspondence. These learned societies supported the study of history, science, and antiquarian subjects.
Hereditary member in succession to his father.
Massachusetts Society of the Cincinnati
,
United States
1840
Served on the board of councilors from 1852 to 1853 and as secretary of foreign correspondence from 1867 to 1874.
American Antiquarian Society
,
United States
1843
Elected a member.
American Philosophical Society
,
United States
1867
Personality
Sumner was known for formal, stately eloquence and a forceful public manner. His speeches were elaborate, rich in historical and literary allusion, and frequently drew on the Bible and classical writers. His delivery was imposing, with vigorous, unconventional gestures. He described his own humor as scarce, and Longfellow likened the force of his speech to a cannoneer loading cartridges.
He held strong convictions with unusual persistence and showed courage in maintaining them under intense political opposition. Sumner's uncompromising style, pride in his moral judgments, and difficulty with colleagues could also make him seem arrogant, inflexible, and dogmatic. His manner of dealing with allies and opponents contributed to political isolation, while his colleagues' accounts also emphasized sincerity, integrity, kindness, and devotion to principle.
Physical Characteristics:
Sumner stood 6 feet 4 inches (1.93 m) tall and had a massive frame. His voice was clear and powerful. The beating by Preston Brooks caused severe head injuries and prolonged physical incapacity. Sumner's physicians later attributed his continuing condition to spinal-cord damage; he also experienced exhaustion when attempting to resume Senate work.
Quotes from others about the person
Senator Carl Schurz praised Sumner's integrity, moral courage, sincerity, and freedom from selfish motives. Wendell Phillips recalled that Southerners in Washington wondered whether Sumner would return safely whenever he left home in the 1850s. Moorfield Storey, his former private secretary and biographer, described him as courageous, sincere, kind, and steadfastly devoted to duty, while also noting that success had made him more egotistical and dogmatic.
Ralph Waldo Emerson admired Sumner's independence in Congress and said he had never known a “whiter soul.” W. E. B. Du Bois called him a “magnificent figure” and a “seer of democracy.” Historian David Donald's first volume on Sumner portrayed him as an arrogant and self-regarding moralist; in a later volume, Donald gave greater recognition to Sumner's contribution to Reconstruction. Zaakir Tameez criticized Donald's emphasis on Sumner's personal conflicts and presented him as a major nineteenth-century civil-rights leader, comparing his oratory and political vision with those of Martin Luther King Jr.
Interests
Sumner enjoyed travel, the company of literary and political acquaintances, and attending the opera during his European stays. He maintained friendships with Henry Wadsworth Longfellow and other prominent Bostonians; Longfellow's daughters found Sumner's ceremonious manner amusing. Sumner regularly visited the Longfellow home from the 1840s.
Connections
Sumner's parents were Charles Pinckney Sumner, a lawyer, and Relief Jacob Sumner. He maintained a close friendship and lifelong correspondence with physician and fellow abolitionist Samuel Gridley Howe, with whom he spent considerable time as a young man. Sumner once expressed deep affection for Howe in a letter. Howe married Julia Ward Howe, and Sumner was distressed by the marriage; Howe later destroyed some of their correspondence, while Julia also discarded letters after her husband's death.
Sumner remained a bachelor for much of his life. In 1866 he began courting Alice Mason Hooper, the widowed daughter-in-law of Massachusetts representative Samuel Hooper, and they married that October. The marriage was unhappy. Alice continued to attend public events with Prussian diplomat Friedrich von Holstein after he was recalled to Prussia in spring 1867; she accused Sumner of arranging the recall, which he denied. They separated in September 1867, and Sumner obtained an uncontested divorce on grounds of desertion on May 10, 1873. Political opponents had mocked his bachelorhood and later used the marital conflict to attack his masculinity. The article's discussion of his possible sexuality is presented as a possibility, not a confirmed identity.
Father:
Charles Pinckney Sumner
Harvard-educated lawyer, abolitionist, and early advocate of racial integration in schools; sheriff of Suffolk County from 1825 until his death in 1838.
Mother:
Relief Jacob Sumner
Worked as a seamstress before her marriage.
Wife:
Alice Mason Hooper
Widowed daughter-in-law of Massachusetts representative Samuel Hooper; she married Sumner in October 1866, and they divorced in 1873.
Collegue :
Samuel Gridley Howe
Physician and fellow abolitionist; Sumner maintained a close friendship and lifelong correspondence with him.
Friend:
Henry Wadsworth Longfellow
Poet and longtime Boston friend; he was among Sumner's pallbearers.
Collegue :
Horace Mann
Massachusetts education reformer who worked with Sumner on public education.
Collegue :
Robert Morris
Black lawyer who joined Sumner in representing the plaintiffs in Roberts v. City of Boston.
Collegue :
John Mercer Langston
Co-authored the Civil Rights Act of 1875 with Sumner.
References
Charles Sumner
George Henry Haynes's book-length account of Sumner, published by G. W. Jacobs.