Career
At age fourteen, he began working at a racetrack then joined the United States Army during World World War World War II During the intense action in the Italian Campaign following Operation Shingle, Neloy was seriously wounded in Anzio and lost an eye. In the mid-1950s he trained for Maine Chance Farm and in 1964 was voted the National Turf Writers Trainer of the Year following an outstanding season that included Gedney Farms" outstanding colt, Gun Bow. In 1966, Eddie Neloy was chosen by the Phipps family to replace the retiring Bill Winfrey as their head trainer.
In his first year, Neloy met with outstanding success, including winning thirteen straight races with Buckpasser who was voted American Horse of the Year honors.
During the five years he was with the Phipps family until his death in 1971, Neloy would be the United States. leading money-winning trainer for 1966 through 1968 and the trainer of five Champions. Eddie Neloy died suddenly of a heart attack in 1971.