Career
Negroni"s family moved from Puerto Rico to New York City in the 1930s during the Great Depression era. The family lived in Manhattan where Negroni met and befriended Herman Santiago. Negroni, who had a baritone voice, and his friends called themselves the "Ermines" with Santiago as lead singer.
On one occasion, the Ermines performed alongside the "Cadillacs" at P.S. 143 (Public School 143).
The Ermines changed their name to "Coupe de Villes" and later to "The Premiers". In 1954, 12-year-old Frankie Lymon worked in a grocery store.
One night, The Premiers and Lymon"s brother performed in a talent show held at JHS Stitt (Junior High School Stitt). Frankie approached The Premiers, telling them how good they sounded.
They started jamming together, and the Premiers were impressed with the sound of Frankie"s high tenor/soprano voice.
Lymon sang a few numbers with them, like "You Painted Pictures" and "Lily Maebelle," and by early 1955, they had invited him to join, with Lymon singing first tenor behind Santiago"s lead. In 1955, Richard Barrett, a scout for "Gee Records," heard them singing and introduced them to George Goldner, the owner of Gee. Upon hearing them sing, Mr.
Goldner signed them to a contract and changed the group"s name to "The Teenagers."
The following day, the group was supposed to meet with Mr.
Goldner in the studio for a recording session. Santiago, who was the lead singer, was ill and could not accompany the other members.
Therefore, he gave Negroni the music sheet with the words to the song that he had written. The song was "Why Do Fools Fall In Love" (which was originally reworked from a poem called "Why Do Birds Sing So Gay").
Since Santiago was not present, Mr.
Goldner asked Frankie if he could sing the song. Frankie accepted, and they recorded the song. Mr. Goldner then changed the group"s name to "Frankie Lymon and the Teenagers" and released the record.
The song became an instant hit in the United States, and in the United Kingdom, it also became the first top British hit of an American vocal group.
In London, the group played at the Palladium. Upon hearing them sing, young girls acted wild, a matter that bothered the establishment more than somewhat.
Alan Freed signed them for two movies. In 1957, Frankie Lymon, upon the urging of Mr.
Goldner, left "the Teenagers" and went solo.
Eventually the group broke up. Santiago tried to reunite "the Teenagers" in the 1970s and 1980s, in ill–fated comeback attempts. By the 1970s, Garnes had died from a heart attack, and on September 5, 1978, Joe Negroni died from a cerebral hemorrhage.
In the 1998 film "Why Do Fools Fall In Love," the role of Negroni was played by actor Jon Huertas.
