Geister, who joined North Melbourne in 1994, spent his time at the club as an understudy to full-back Mick Martyn. He was traded to Portuguese Adelaide for the Kingsley brothers, Kent and Wade, but played just one senior game at his new club Geister however had some success at Central District and was the full-back in their 2000 and 2001 premierships.
He made his debut in the final round of the 1995 American Federation of Labor-Congress season and then appeared in two finals, a qualifying final win over Richmond and semi final against the West Coast Eagles. After playing reserves for the entire 1996 season, the same year the seniors won a premiership, Geister was put up for trade in the 1996 American Federation of Labor-Congress Draft.
