Career
Her story was documented on an episode of Cold Case Files. These led to over 20 visits to a hospital, including one in which she was hospitalized for a month. On August 9, 1961, Mary held Michelle under water and stomped her violently, believing that the child had lied about something.
These actions were seen by Michelle"s older brother, George.
At dinner, Michelle threw up blood clots. The next day she died of her internal injuries.
An autopsy was conducted by the pathologist at the army base where the Morgans lived, and the cause of death was found to be massive trauma to the chest. Due to a technical error, the report was not completed until some time later, when an inexperienced coroner listed the cause of death as pneumonia and also stated that it had occurred in 1976.
The local prosecutor never pursued the case.
In 1996, George Morgan (Michelle"s older brother) was serving time in prison for rape. That year, he decided to research his family genealogy and was surprised when he saw his sister"s death certificate. He recalled the circumstances surrounding her death and was certain that it was not caused by pneumonia — and that it had occurred in 1961, not in 1976.
Morgan then corresponded with Deputy Coroner Bob Shay and disclosed to him how Michelle"s death really occurred.
Shay subsequently got the case reopened. Investigators discovered the original autopsy report and Michelle"s hospital record, which showed multiple visits.
To get further evidence, Michelle"s body was exhumed. Though the body had been buried for over 30 years, it still showed the marks of brutal child abuse.
George Morgan"s claims were thus substantiated.
Mary Morgan was tracked down in West Columbia, Texas, and initially denied the allegations leveled against her. She then attempted to flee the country but was caught and placed under arrest. She eventually pled guilty to involuntary manslaughter and was sentenced to five years in prison.
In the years after Michelle"s death, Mary raised four children.
Hospital records showed that the four of them had collectively visited the hospital over 150 times for medical care before the age of five.