Career
New York Fury
Spencer was selected by the Philadelphia Independence during the 2012 WPS Draft. However, the league suspended operations before play began. She later joined the New York Fury in the Women"s Premier Soccer League Elite.
Brøndby
Spencer opted to join Brøndby IF during the 2012–2013 season.
She made two appearances for the club for the Union of European Football Associations Champions League logging a total of 25 minutes. Washington Spirit
In 2013, Spencer signed with the Washington Spirit for the inaugural season of the NWSL. Apollon Limassol
In September 2013, Spencer was loaned by Washington Spirit to Apollon Limassol in the Cypriot First Division.
Western New York Flash
Sydney Football Club
In September 2014, Spencer signed with Sydney Football Club of the Australian West-League.