Career
A well travelled player, he played for eight different teams in three different leagues during his six seasons. Wheeler began his career with the Providence Grays as a pitcher, where he pitched well. A good start to his career, but the next two years, he pitched in only five games for the Cincinnati Reds, and played in one game for the Cleveland Blues, he had one hit in four at bats and played left field
He was formally converted as an outfield upon his return the majors in 1882 after an absence in 1881, when he joined the American Association Cincinnati Red Stockings.
Harry did well with the bat that season, finishing in the top ten in many hitting categories, highest among them were his 11 triples, in which he finished third. He played for the Columbus Buckeyes the following season.
The 1883 season saw his hitting decline, and his fielding, which was already a liability, was getting worse. This was his last full season he played.
He ended his career in the failed Union Association in 1884, including a four-game stint as player-manager for the Kansas City Cowboys, losing all of them.
Wheeler died at the age of 42, of syphilitic locomotor ataxia. He was interred at Spring Grove Cemetery in Cincinnati.