Career
A right-handed pitcher, he worked in 38 games in the Major Leagues, all but two in relief, for the Philadelphia Athletics during the 1943 and 1946 seasons. Born in Pottersville, he was from Tewksbury Township, New Jersey. Fagan stood 6 feet (18 m) tall and weighed 195 pounds (88 kg) during his playing career.
His career extended from 1940–1943 and 1946–1947, with two full seasons missed due to United States Army service during World World War World War II However, during his two Major League stints (which included all of the 1946 season), he lost seven of nine decisions (including both of his 1943 starting assignments), allowing 88 hits and 38 bases on balls, with 21 strikeouts, in 821⁄3 innings pitched.