Career
Keeley joined Tottenham Hotspur as an apprentice in January 1974. The central defender made his senior debut against Birmingham City on 20 October 1976. Keeley made a total of six appearances in the season of 1976-1977 in which the Spurs were relegated.
In December 1977 he was granted a free transfer to Sheffield United and went on to feature in 28 fixtures.
After leaving Bramall Lane on a free transfer he signed for Scunthorpe United in July 1981 and made a further 77 appearances and scored once from the penalty spot.