Richard Nicolls was an English soldier, royal courtier, and colonial administrator who became the first English governor of New York after the capture of New Netherland in 1664. He introduced the Duke's Laws, reorganized colonial courts and local government, and governed until 1668 before returning to military service and dying at the Battle of Solebay in 1672.
Background
Richard Nicolls was born in 1624 at Ampthill, Bedfordshire, England, the fourth son of Francis Nicolls, a barrister of Ampthill, and Margaret Bruce, daughter of Sir George Bruce. His family was connected with the local gentry and with the royalist cause that shaped his early adult life.
The English Civil War began while Nicolls was still young. He commanded a troop of horse for the royal side, and two of his brothers also served the Stuarts. After the parliamentary victory, Nicolls followed the exiled royal family to France, where his military and household service brought him into the circle of James, Duke of York.
Education
Nicolls appears to have begun on an academic path but left it for military service; no confirmed matriculation at Oxford or Cambridge is recorded. In 1663, the University of Oxford conferred on him the degree of Doctor of Civil Law, recognizing his standing in the royal service and public administration.
Oxford was one of England's ancient universities and, during the seventeenth century, an important institution for law, theology, and the education of members of the governing elite. Nicolls's Oxford degree was honorary or otherwise conferred without a documented conventional university course, and it did not represent a recorded period of student residence.
Nicolls began his public career as a royalist military commander during the English Civil War, leading a troop of horse against parliamentary forces. During the Stuart exile he served in the household of James, Duke of York, and also served under James in the French army commanded by Marshal Turenne. His military experience established the basis for the rank of colonel by which he was subsequently known.
After the Restoration of the monarchy in 1660, Nicolls became a groom of the bedchamber to the Duke of York. In 1664 Charles II granted James, Duke of York, the territory occupied or claimed by the Dutch on the North American seaboard. James appointed Nicolls to lead the expedition against New Netherland and made him deputy governor of the territory.
Nicolls sailed from England in May 1664 with four warships and approximately 450 soldiers. The English force blockaded New Amsterdam in August, and Peter Stuyvesant surrendered on August 27 or 29, 1664, after Nicolls offered favorable terms. Nicolls then became the first English governor of New York and oversaw the occupation of other Dutch settlements without a major battle.
As governor from 1664 to 1668, Nicolls introduced English authority gradually. He retained many Dutch inhabitants in local offices, protected property arrangements, and sought to maintain peace among Dutch, English, and Indigenous communities. His administration operated within the proprietary authority granted to the Duke of York, which did not provide for an elected colonial assembly.
In 1665 Nicolls convened the Hempstead Convention and promulgated the Duke's Laws, a colonial code compiled with the assistance of Secretary Matthias Nicolls from English, Dutch, and New England legal materials. The code provided for trial by jury, local courts, Courts of Sessions, and a Court of Assizes, while retaining strong executive authority. On June 12, 1665, Nicolls extended the system to New York City through a charter establishing a mayor, aldermen, and sheriff appointed by the governor.
Nicolls also served on the royal commission sent to investigate conditions and hear complaints in the New England colonies. He joined the other commissioners in Boston in 1665, but the Massachusetts authorities resisted the commission's attempt to increase royal oversight. Nicolls resigned the governorship in 1668 and returned to England, where he resumed service in the Duke of York's household.
When the Third Anglo-Dutch War began in 1672, Nicolls volunteered for naval service under the Duke of York. He was killed by a cannon shot on May 28, 1672, during the Battle of Solebay, known in English sources also as the Battle of Southwold Bay, in the North Sea off the Suffolk coast.
Achievements
Nicolls led the English expedition that captured New Netherland in 1664 and established English rule over the colony that became New York.
He directed the transition from Dutch to English administration while retaining Dutch officials and accommodating existing local arrangements, helping prevent bloodshed and preserve order.
Under Nicolls's direction, the Duke's Laws were promulgated in 1665, establishing courts, trial by jury, taxation rules, and a framework for local government in the early English colony.
He issued the 1665 charter that organized New York City's government around a mayor, aldermen, and sheriff and extended the Duke's Laws to the city.
Politics
Nicolls was a royal appointee rather than a documented member of a political party. His public career developed within the Stuart restoration, when royal governors represented the authority of the Crown and of James, Duke of York, whose proprietary grant covered New Netherland. As governor, Nicolls combined centralized authority with pragmatic accommodation of Dutch and English settlers, while declining to establish a representative colonial assembly under the Duke of York's instructions.
Personality
Contemporary descriptions emphasized Nicolls's prudence, fairness, and ability to maintain peace among communities of different national and cultural backgrounds during the transition from Dutch to English rule.
Quotes from others about the person
Samuel Maverick described Nicolls as having rendered substantial service to the king and the Duke of York and praised his prudent management in keeping people of different judgments and nations peaceful during a period of widespread war.
Interests
Politicians
James, Duke of York
Connections
Nicolls was the son of Francis Nicolls, a barrister, and Margaret Bruce, daughter of Sir George Bruce. He was closely connected to James, Duke of York, serving in the duke's household, military command, colonial administration, and later naval service.
Father:
Francis Nicolls
Barrister of Ampthill, Bedfordshire, and father of Richard Nicolls.
Mother:
Margaret Bruce
Daughter of Sir George Bruce and mother of Richard Nicolls.
The Duke of York's Laws, 1665–75
Primary-source edition of the legal code compiled under Nicolls's direction for the government of the English colony of New York.