He was the only Republican to be twice elected mayor of Evansville until the 2015 re-election of Lloyd Winnecke. In 1961 Lloyd was appointed attorney for the Legal Aid Society of Vanderburgh County. Evansville citizen Julia Van Orden had a history as a "constant complainer" according to city police and had claimed harassment from officials inspecting her home.
On March 18, 1980, Van Orden had thrown a brick at a city inspector"s vehicle windshield when he came to inspect an addition to her house.
The following morning, Julia Van Orden, believing Lloyd was still the mayor (his term had actually expired in January of that year), arrived at his home. She shot Lloyd four times with a handgun, in the head, neck and shoulders, in a fit of anger after a brief argument.
Van Orden fled and Lloyd was taken to the hospital, where a brain scan indicated brain death. Doctors announced "there is no hope" shortly before turning off Lloyd"s medical ventilator.
Though Van Orden"s attorney argued she was too mentally ill to have understood her actions, she was nonetheless convicted and sentenced to between 20 to 40 years in prison.
Days before what would have been her release in 2000, she was committed to Logansport State Hospital in Logansport, Indiana, where on August 22, 2006 she allegedly stabbed a hospital employee and was charged with attempted murder. Lloyd"s son, Lloyd, Junior., served as mayor of Evansville from 2000 to 2004.