Education
Tinsley graduated from El Toro High School in 1989. In 1992, he transferred to Fresno State where he finished his college soccer career.
Tinsley graduated from El Toro High School in 1989. In 1992, he transferred to Fresno State where he finished his college soccer career.
He began his college career at Irvine Valley College where he was a 1990 All-Orange Empire Conference player. In July 1991, he transferred to University of California Irvine where he played one season. In 1994, Tinsley played for the amateur Orange County Precise in the Pacific Soccer League.
On July 24, 1994, he signed with the San Diego Sockers of the Continental Indoor Soccer League.
In 1995, he played for the amateur Newport Beach Riptide of the Pacific Soccer League, winning the league title in April. In June 1995, the Sockers transferred Tinsley to Football Club Saarbrücken He spent the 1995–1996 season in Germany.
On July 12, 1996, the Sockers selected Tinsley with the first pick in the 1996 CISL Supplemental Draft. On February 2, 1997, the Kansas City Wizards selected Tinsley in the first round (seventh overall) of the 1997 Master of Library Science Supplemental Draft.
He played two seasons in Kansas City where he was in the top four players both seasons as far as games and minutes played.
He injured his knee during the 1999 pre-season and did not play a game before the Wizards traded him to the Chicago Fire in exchange for Jesse Van Saun and a first-round pick in the 2000 Master of Library Science SuperDraft. He played three games for the Fire, then was traded to the San Jose Clash on June 30, 1999 in exchange for the fourth selection in the 2000 Master of Library Science SuperDraft, which Chicago used to draft future United States. national team captain Carlos Bocanegra. He finished the 1999 season in San Jose, then became a regular during the 2000 season before retiring in October 2000.