(Memoir co-written with Ralph de Toledano. Felt defended J...)
Memoir co-written with Ralph de Toledano. Felt defended J. Edgar Hoover and the FBI and criticized the Church Committee, civil-liberties advocates, and the Freedom of Information Act and Privacy Act of 1974.
Mark Felt was an American FBI officer who served as the bureau’s deputy director and became publicly known in 2005 as “Deep Throat,” the confidential source who gave Washington Post reporters information about Watergate. His career also encompassed FBI investigations of organized crime and the Weather Underground, a criminal conviction for warrantless searches, and a presidential pardon.
Background
Felt was born in Twin Falls, Idaho, to Rose R. Dygert and Mark Earl Felt, a carpenter and building contractor. His paternal grandfather was a Free Will Baptist minister. His maternal grandparents were born in Canada and Scotland, and through his maternal grandfather he was collaterally descended from Nicholas Herkimer, a New York general in the American Revolutionary War.
Education
Felt graduated from Twin Falls High School in 1931 and attended the University of Idaho in Moscow. He joined the Gamma Gamma chapter of Beta Theta Pi, served as its president, and received a Bachelor of Arts degree in 1935. While students at the university, he met Audrey Robinson, whom he later married.
After moving to Washington, D.C., Felt studied law at George Washington University at night and earned a law degree in 1940. He was admitted to the District of Columbia Bar in 1941.
After graduating from the University of Idaho, Felt went to Washington, D.C., and worked in the office of Democratic U.S. senator James P. Pope. He remained with Pope’s successor, Senator David Worth Clark of Idaho, and later served as an administrative assistant in Clark’s Senate office from 1938 to 1941. In 1941 Felt joined the Federal Trade Commission as an attorney. He disliked the work, which included investigating whether a toilet-paper brand called “Red Cross” misled consumers into thinking it had the American Red Cross’s endorsement. His inquiry involved days of travel and hundreds of interviews; he later joked that it established both that people used toilet tissue and that they disliked being questioned about it. He applied to the FBI in 1941 and was accepted.
Following sixteen weeks of training at the FBI Academy in Quantico, Virginia, and at FBI Headquarters in Washington, Felt spent three months each in the Houston and San Antonio field offices. He then joined the Espionage Section of the Domestic Intelligence Division at headquarters, working on the Major Case Desk. During the Second World War, the section pursued spies and saboteurs. Felt directed the “Peasant” counterintelligence case, in which German agent Helmut Goldschmidt, held in England, operated under that codename. Under Felt’s direction, German handlers were led to believe that Goldschmidt had reached the United States and were given false information about Allied plans. The Espionage Section was dissolved after V-E Day in May 1945.
Felt was assigned to the Seattle field office after the war. Following two years of general investigative work, he spent another two years as a firearms instructor and was promoted from agent to supervisor. After the Atomic Energy Act created the U.S. Atomic Energy Commission, the Seattle office conducted background investigations of workers at the Hanford plutonium plant near Richland, Washington; Felt oversaw those checks. In 1954 he returned briefly to Washington as an inspector’s aide, then became assistant special agent in charge in New Orleans. Fifteen months later he moved to Los Angeles in the same rank.
In 1956 Felt became special agent in charge of the Salt Lake City office, whose jurisdiction included Nevada. He oversaw some of the FBI’s early organized-crime investigations, including assessments of Mob operations in casinos in Reno and Las Vegas. At the time, FBI director J. Edgar Hoover maintained that the Mob did not exist. After an underworld gathering at Apalachin, New York, in November 1957, Hoover changed his view. Felt moved in February 1958 to Kansas City, Missouri, where he directed further organized-crime investigations; in his memoir he called that office “the Siberia of field offices.”
Felt returned to Washington in September 1962 as an assistant to the assistant director in charge of the Training Division, helping oversee the FBI Academy. In November 1964 he became an assistant director, chief inspector, and head of the Inspection Division, which monitored compliance with bureau rules and conducted internal investigations. On July 1, 1971, he became deputy associate director, assisting Deputy Director Clyde Tolson. Hoover selected him while Tolson’s health was failing and the bureau was dealing with William C. Sullivan’s unofficial domestic-surveillance operations. Richard Gid Powers wrote that Hoover wanted Felt to restrain Sullivan. Felt recalled Hoover saying that Sullivan was getting out of hand and that he needed someone to control him. Ronald Kessler later characterized Felt’s approach to Hoover as tactful and his dealings with agents as firm; Curt Gentry described Felt as Hoover’s favored new subordinate, while observing that John P. Mohr, rather than Felt, was then the bureau’s effective third-ranking figure.
During the early 1970s, Felt supervised FBI investigations of the Weather Underground, a group responsible for bombings at the Capitol, the Pentagon, and the State Department building. He also supervised Operation COINTELPRO, the FBI program initiated under Hoover to investigate and disrupt political organizations and movements, including the civil-rights and anti-war movements, the Black Panthers, and the New Left. The bureau’s investigation of the Weather Underground was later dismissed after a court found that illegal FBI practices, including unauthorized wiretaps, break-ins, and mail interceptions, had tainted it. Federal prosecutor William C. Ibershof said Felt and Attorney General John Mitchell had initiated the illegal activity.
Hoover died on May 2, 1972. His deputy, Tolson, was nominally in charge until the next day, when President Richard Nixon appointed L. Patrick Gray acting director. Tolson resigned and Felt succeeded him as deputy director, the FBI’s number-two position. Felt served as an honorary pallbearer at Hoover’s funeral. On May 4, Hoover’s longtime secretary, Helen Gandy, turned over twelve boxes of “Official/Confidential” files to Felt. The boxes held 167 files and 17,750 pages, including derogatory material on people Hoover had investigated; Felt kept them in his office. Gray publicly denied that the bureau had dossiers or secret files and said he had taken steps to protect the files. Felt told Gray that the FBI had no secret files and later accompanied him to Hoover’s office, where they found Gandy boxing papers. Felt said Gray glanced at an open drawer and approved her work; Gray later denied doing so. Gandy kept Hoover’s separate personal file and destroyed it.
In 1975 the House of Representatives questioned Felt about the destruction of Hoover’s papers. He said he saw no serious problem in losing some papers. Gandy testified that she had destroyed Hoover’s personal files after Gray approved it, and Gray submitted a letter emphatically denying that he had given permission; both statements appeared in the committee’s final report. Felt’s memoir criticized Gray’s frequent absences from headquarters, including travel to field offices and his commute from Stonington, Connecticut. Gray visited every field office except Honolulu, and in 1975 a permanent FBI resident agency opened in Guam, the bureau’s westernmost investigative office. Gray was hospitalized from November 20, 1972, to January 2, 1973, and Felt was effectively in charge of the bureau for much of his final year there. Bob Woodward later wrote that Gray held the director’s title while Felt did the work. Felt argued that Nixon had chosen a politician to turn the FBI into an extension of the White House. Gray’s supporters viewed his field visits as a way to improve morale and described his leadership as comparable to a naval captain’s division of responsibilities; Felt considered the visits distracting and indicative of weak leadership. Other career FBI managers who had served under Hoover also objected to Gray’s methods.
As deputy director, Felt received information about the Watergate investigation before it reached Gray. The investigation began after the June 17, 1972, break-in at the Democratic National Committee’s Watergate offices. Agent in Charge Charles Nuzum sent findings to Investigative Division head Robert Gebhardt, who passed them to Felt. Felt became a key channel for the FBI’s Watergate information until the investigation was largely complete in June 1973. He learned on June 19 that E. Howard Hunt, who had ties to Nixon, was implicated; the burglars’ address book contained Hunt’s White House telephone number.
Felt had met Washington Post reporter Bob Woodward at the White House in 1969 or 1970, when Woodward was an aide to Admiral Thomas Hinman Moorer, chairman of the Joint Chiefs of Staff, and delivered papers to the White House Situation Room. They stayed in touch, and Woodward sometimes sought information from Felt for newspaper stories. Felt’s information, provided on the understanding that Woodward would not reveal its source, contributed to several stories, including a May 18, 1972, report about Arthur Bremer, who had shot George Wallace. When the Watergate story broke, Woodward contacted Felt. The Post’s editor, Howard Simons, gave the confidential source the nickname “Deep Throat,” drawing on the title of a well-known pornographic film and on the deep-background basis of the information. Woodward described the source as an executive-branch figure with access to information about the White House and the Committee to Re-elect the President. Felt’s information also reached the Post through the newspaper’s Watergate reporting; former agents later told Kessler that the newspaper’s accounts closely reproduced material from FBI interview reports. Woodward’s notes from interviews with Felt were marked “M.F.”; Woodward later said the initials were not effective concealment, as they could also stand for “My Friend.”
Woodward described a system of signals for arranging meetings: he moved a flowerpot bearing a red flag on his apartment balcony, while Felt circled a page number in Woodward’s copy of The New York Times and drew clock hands to indicate a meeting time. Woodward lived at 617 Webster House, 1718 P Street NW. Adrian Havill questioned the account in his 1993 biography, arguing that the balcony could not be seen from the street and that the newspaper was not delivered in apartment-marked copies. Woodward said the courtyard had been enclosed after he lived there and that the balcony could be seen from nearby apartments and offices; he also considered, without claiming certainty, whether FBI surveillance near the Iraqi embassy might have monitored the signal. Woodward’s account and a former neighbor disputed Havill’s claim about the newspaper delivery.
The White House discussed the possibility of press leaks soon after the burglary. On June 23, 1972, chief of staff H. R. Haldeman told Nixon that Felt might cooperate because he was ambitious. In an October 19 taped conversation, Haldeman said he had heard that Felt was speaking to the press and warned that confronting Felt could lead him to disclose everything he knew about the FBI. Haldeman said John W. Dean had told him Felt had committed no crime and could not be prosecuted. Gray confronted Felt in January 1973 after returning from sick leave, saying Attorney General Richard G. Kleindienst had urged him to remove Felt because White House staff suspected him of leaking to Woodward and Bernstein. Felt denied leaking. Gray said he had defended Felt as competent and loyal, while Kleindienst had thanked him for not moving Felt.
Nixon nominated Gray as permanent FBI director on February 17, 1973. When Gray resigned on April 27 after it emerged that he had destroyed a file from Hunt’s White House safe, he recommended Felt as his successor. Kleindienst also urged Nixon to appoint Felt, but Nixon instead chose William Ruckelshaus as acting director. Nixon said he wanted someone outside the bureau’s old guard and internal disputes. In a May 11 conversation with Alexander Haig, Nixon called Felt a “bad guy” and discussed his suspected leaks to The New York Times. Ruckelshaus and Felt had a difficult relationship. After the Times published stories about wiretaps Hoover had ordered, Ruckelshaus believed the information had come from the FBI. A caller claiming to be a Times reporter accused Felt, and Ruckelshaus confronted him privately on June 21, 1973. Felt denied leaking and resigned the following day, ending 31 years with the bureau. In a 2013 interview, Ruckelshaus said the caller might have been a hoax but that he had regarded Felt’s resignation as an admission of guilt. Ruckelshaus was later replaced by Clarence M. Kelley, Nixon’s nominee confirmed by the Senate.
In 1976 Felt publicly acknowledged ordering warrantless FBI break-ins, also known as “black bag jobs,” and said he would do so again to prevent bombings. In 1972 and 1973, he and Edward S. Miller ordered agents to enter homes without warrants on nine occasions, at five addresses in New York and New Jersey belonging to relatives and acquaintances of Weather Underground members. The searches did not capture fugitives. The Supreme Court had ruled the use of such warrantless searches unconstitutional in the Plamondon case. Felt said he had acted to protect the public and should not punish agents who followed orders; he also said Gray had authorized the entries, which Gray denied. The investigation of the Weather Underground was dismissed after the court concluded that the FBI’s illegal methods had compromised it. The Citizens’ Commission to Investigate the FBI and the congressional Church Committee subsequently exposed illegal bureau activities, prompting investigations of many agents.
On April 10, 1978, a federal grand jury charged Felt, Miller, and Gray with conspiring to violate the constitutional rights of U.S. citizens by conducting warrantless searches. Felt said he was shocked by the indictment and told biographer Ronald Kessler that he had believed his actions served the country’s interests. The three men were arraigned in Washington on April 20; about 700 current and former FBI agents gathered outside the courthouse in support. Gray’s case was dropped for lack of evidence on December 11, 1980. Felt and Miller offered to plead guilty to misdemeanors involving searches without warrants, but the government rejected the offer in 1979. Their trial began in the U.S. District Court for the District of Columbia on September 18, 1980, after eight postponements. Former President Nixon testified for the defense on October 29, his first courtroom appearance since before Watergate. He said he had authorized break-ins for foreign intelligence under presidential directives dating to 1939. Nixon contributed to Felt’s defense fund, whose legal expenses had exceeded $600,000. Former attorneys general Mitchell, Kleindienst, Herbert Brownell Jr., Nicholas Katzenbach, and Ramsey Clark also testified that warrantless searches in national-security cases had been common and understood not to be illegal; Mitchell and Kleindienst denied authorizing the particular searches. The FBI argued that the Weather Underground was working for Cuba.
A jury found Felt and Miller guilty on November 6, 1980, two days after the presidential election. On December 15, Judge William B. Bryant fined Felt $5,000 and Miller $3,500 but imposed no prison sentence. Attorney Roy Cohn argued in a New York Times opinion piece that the men had been scapegoated and that the searches were a final Nixon-administration abuse without personal motive. The Times praised the convictions, observing that zeal did not excuse unconstitutional conduct. Felt and Miller appealed.
On January 30, 1981, Edwin Meese encouraged President Ronald Reagan to pardon the two men. Reagan signed pardons on March 26, which were not publicly announced until April 15 because of the March 30 assassination attempt. Reagan cited the men’s long service and their belief that their actions protected national security. Nixon sent them champagne with a note saying that justice ultimately prevailed; the Times criticized the pardon as an unjustified rewriting of the record. Prosecutor John W. Nields Jr. said the pardon decision-makers had not read the trial record and complained that prosecutors had not been consulted. Felt said the pardon lifted a heavy burden. Miller said he owed Reagan, while former attorney general Griffin Bell said he did not object because the trial had upheld constitutional principles. The men pursued appeals to remove the convictions from their records and avoid their use in civil suits. In 1982 the court of appeals allowed their appeals to proceed, and Felt’s law license was restored on the basis of Reagan’s pardon. In June 1982, Felt and Miller testified to a Senate Judiciary subcommittee on security and terrorism that Attorney General Edward H. Levi’s restrictions on the FBI threatened national security.
Felt wrote The FBI Pyramid: From the Inside with Hoover biographer Ralph de Toledano; published in 1979, the book’s copyright notice credited de Toledano, though his name was not on the cover. De Toledano later said he had written most of it because Felt’s manuscript read like The Autocrat of the Breakfast-Table. Felt strongly defended Hoover and the bureau, criticized the Church Committee and civil-liberties advocates, and argued that the Freedom of Information Act and Privacy Act of 1974 impeded government work and helped criminals. He opened with a line attributed to Justice Robert H. Jackson: “The Bill of Rights is not a suicide pact.” De Toledano said Felt had denied being Deep Throat and denied leaking to the Post; the book sold poorly. Library Journal’s 1980 review called it interesting but not sensational and said Felt assigned the Deep Throat identity elsewhere. The New York Times Book Review criticized the book’s defense of Hoover and noted factual errors. Curt Gentry later called Felt the keeper of Hoover’s legacy.
Felt’s identity as Deep Throat was debated for decades. In 1974, The Wall Street Journal reported his denial that he was the source and quoted his description of Deep Throat as a composite; in 1975 George V. Higgins noted that Felt knew many reporters and that some suspected him. Assistant Attorney General J. Stanley Pottinger reportedly identified Felt as Deep Throat during a 1976 grand-jury investigation, but the proceedings remained secret. James Mann of the Post named Felt as a possibility in a 1992 Atlantic Monthly essay, while saying he could not confirm it. In 1995, former White House aide Alexander P. Butterfield told the Hartford Courant that he thought the source was Felt. In 1999, the Courant identified Felt based on a young man’s account of what Carl Bernstein’s son Jacob had said at camp; Felt denied it, and Bernstein said his son did not know the identity. Nora Ephron, Bernstein’s former wife, had independently guessed Felt’s identity from the initials “M.F.” in All the President’s Men and told her sons and others, but few believed her. Leonard Garment, Nixon’s former law partner and later White House counsel, rejected Felt as the source in his 2000 book, reasoning that Deep Throat’s apparent access to White House information did not fit Felt’s position. In 2002, Kessler wrote that he had suspected Felt while researching The Bureau, partly because of Woodward’s efforts to conceal a 1999 meeting. In 2005, reports that Woodward had prepared Deep Throat’s obituary, along with speculation about Supreme Court Chief Justice William Rehnquist, renewed public interest; Rehnquist had served in the Justice Department’s Office of Legal Counsel before joining the Court.
On May 31, 2005, Vanity Fair published attorney John D. O’Connor’s account identifying Felt as Deep Throat. Felt said, “I’m the guy they used to call Deep Throat.” Former Post editor Benjamin C. Bradlee confirmed the identification the next day, and Woodward and Bernstein also confirmed it. Felt’s family had urged him to reveal the secret before his death and hoped that resulting book and film opportunities could help pay for his grandchildren’s education. The family had not known the truth for many years; they later connected it with Felt’s friendship with Woodward. Felt was suffering from dementia and had previously denied being the source. Nixon aide Charles Colson accused him of breaking an oath to protect national secrets, while a Los Angeles Times editorial distinguished political cover-up information from genuine national-security secrets. De Toledano said Felt’s son had negotiated to buy his share of the memoir’s copyright in 2004 but had not paid as agreed; after threatening legal action, de Toledano received a check shortly before the Vanity Fair disclosure and accused the family of deceiving him.
As an FBI counterintelligence supervisor during the Second World War, directed the “Peasant” operation, which used captured German agent Helmut Goldschmidt to feed German handlers disinformation about Allied plans.
Served as a confidential source for Washington Post reporters Bob Woodward and Carl Bernstein during Watergate, providing information that contributed to their reporting on the scandal. His identity as “Deep Throat” remained secret until Felt confirmed it in 2005.
Published a memoir of his FBI career, The FBI Pyramid: From the Inside, in 1979 and later issued an updated account, A G-Man’s Life, in 2006.
(Memoir co-written with Ralph de Toledano. Felt defended J...)
1979
Views
In The FBI Pyramid, Felt defended the authority of government investigations and argued that the Freedom of Information Act and Privacy Act of 1974 obstructed government work and benefited criminals. He invoked Justice Robert H. Jackson’s statement that the Bill of Rights was not a “suicide pact.” His defense of warrantless searches rested on the view that preventing bombings and protecting national security could justify actions he acknowledged were outside ordinary legal procedures.
Personality
Felt was a reserved and guarded source who insisted that Woodward protect the origin of his information. He maintained for years that he was not Deep Throat, including in his memoir, before acknowledging the identity at age 91. His memoir reveals a strong defense of Hoover and the FBI and a belief that aggressive action could be justified to protect the public, even when legal authority was disputed. He said he would repeat the warrantless searches if necessary to prevent bombings. He also expressed ambivalence about Gray, faulting his frequent absences and approach to directing the bureau while recognizing that Gray worked hard.
Quotes from others about the person
Ronald Kessler said Felt managed to satisfy Hoover through tact while being tough with agents; Curt Gentry portrayed him as Hoover’s favored subordinate but noted that Felt lacked independent power in the bureau’s leadership. Nixon’s chief counsel Charles Colson accused Felt of violating his oath by revealing secrets, while a Los Angeles Times editorial argued that political information about Watergate was not equivalent to national-security secrets. After the conviction, Roy Cohn called Felt and Miller scapegoats; The New York Times praised the verdict as establishing that zeal did not excuse constitutional violations. Curt Gentry later characterized Felt as the keeper of Hoover’s legacy.
Connections
Felt married Audrey Robinson on June 15, 1938. They had met while studying at the University of Idaho; she was from Gooding, Idaho, and later worked for the Internal Revenue Service in Washington. Their wedding was officiated by the chaplain of the U.S. House of Representatives, the Reverend James Shera Montgomery. They had two children, Joan and Mark Jr.
Joan graduated from high school in Kansas City in 1961 while her father was assigned there, attended the University of Kansas for two years, and transferred to Stanford University to study drama. Felt settled in Alexandria, Virginia, while she was an undergraduate and he held a post connected with the FBI Academy. Joan later received a master’s degree in Spanish from Stanford and went to Chile on a Fulbright scholarship, where she became friends with Marxist revolutionary Andrés Pascal Allende, nephew of Salvador Allende. Her political views moved sharply to the left, creating conflict with her conservative father. She later joined a counterculture community in the Santa Cruz Mountains. A visit by her parents left them appalled by her lifestyle and drug use, and she ended most contact with them. She was consequently unaware of her father’s legal difficulties during Watergate.
Joan became a follower of Adi Da, founder of the new religious movement Adidam in San Francisco. She had three sons: Ludi, later known as Will, and Rob and Nick, whose father was another Adidam devotee whom she did not marry. Felt and Audrey met Ludi during a visit in 1974. After Audrey’s death, Felt visited Joan and his grandsons annually, and they also visited him and his new girlfriend. In 1990 he moved permanently to Santa Rosa, bought a house, lived with Joan, and helped care for the boys while she taught at Sonoma State University and Santa Rosa Junior College. Felt had suffered a stroke before 1999. In mid-1999, Woodward unexpectedly visited him at home and took him to lunch; Joan recalled that Woodward arrived in a white limousine parked near a schoolyard and asked whether he could share a martini with Felt.
The demands of Felt’s career, which kept him away from home for long periods, preceded Audrey’s nervous breakdown in 1954 while the family lived in Seattle. She attended the first day of his 1980 trial but could not bear to return. On July 20, 1984, she died by suicide using Felt’s revolver. Felt and their son told Joan that Audrey had died of a heart attack; Joan learned the truth in 2001.
Father:
Mark Earl Felt
Carpenter and building contractor.
Mother:
Rose R. Dygert Felt
Son:
William Mark Felt Jr.
Officer in the U.S. Air Force; he flew Air Force Two for Vice President George H. W. Bush.
Daughter:
Audrey Joan Felt
Studied drama at Stanford University and Spanish at graduate level, received a Fulbright scholarship to Chile, and taught at Sonoma State University and Santa Rosa Junior College.