Specter reproducing the assumed alignment of the single bullet theory. The subsequent revelation that Texas Governor John Connally's seat in the Presidential limousine had been elevated with respect to John Kennedy's corroborated this theory
Specter, while he was being interviewed by Margot Adler for an episode of Justice Talking on "Presidential signing statements". Photo: Kyle Cassidy ( identity confirmed )
Arlen Specter was an American lawyer, author, and politician who represented Pennsylvania in the U.S. Senate from 1981 to 2011. A former Philadelphia district attorney and Warren Commission assistant counsel, he chaired three Senate committees and became known for his centrist politics, long Senate service, and work on public policy.
Background
Specter was born in Wichita, Kansas, to Harry and Lillie (née Shanin) Specter, Jewish parents whose families came from the Russian or Ukrainian region. His father grew up in Bachkuryne village in Cherkasy Oblast, Ukraine. Specter wrote that his father's family was the village's only Jewish family.
The family lived on South Emporia Street in Wichita before moving to Russell, Kansas. His father had served in the U.S. infantry during the First World War and was badly wounded. During the Great Depression he worked as a fruit peddler and tailor and owned a junkyard. Specter later recalled that his father weighed items from the junkyard on scales owned by Doran Dole, whose son Bob became a fellow politician; Specter's brother Morton and Dole's brother Kenny were friends and contemporaries. The family moved to Philadelphia when Specter's sister Shirley was of marriageable age, because Russell had no other Jewish families.
Education
Specter graduated from Russell High School in 1947. He first attended the University of Oklahoma in 1948, then transferred to the University of Pennsylvania, where he studied international relations and graduated in 1951. His undergraduate education in international relations preceded his military service and legal training.
Specter received his law degree from Yale Law School in 1956. While there, he served as an editor of the Yale Law Journal. The legal education and journal work formed part of his preparation for a career in private practice, prosecution, and public office.
He was elected to Phi Beta Kappa and belonged to Pi Lambda Phi fraternity.
Specter served in the United States Air Force from 1951 to 1953 during the Korean War. He was a first lieutenant and an officer in the Air Force Office of Special Investigations. After law school, he opened the Philadelphia practice Specter & Katz with Marvin Katz, later a federal district judge. Specter represented Ira Einhorn, known as the 'Unicorn Killer,' and helped him obtain low bail on a murder charge; Einhorn subsequently fled while on bail.
In 1959 he became an assistant district attorney in Philadelphia under James C. Crumlish Jr., serving until 1963. He then worked as assistant counsel to the Warren Commission, which investigated President John F. Kennedy's assassination, on the recommendation of Representative Gerald Ford, a member of the commission. Specter and other commission staff developed the single-bullet explanation for wounds sustained by Kennedy and Texas governor John Connally. The House Select Committee on Assassinations reported in 1979 that its forensic pathology panel's conclusions were consistent with that theory.
Specter served as a magisterial investigator for the Commonwealth of Pennsylvania in 1965. In that year, after Democratic leaders declined to support his candidacy, he switched to the Republican Party and defeated his former employer, incumbent district attorney James C. Crumlish Jr., by 36,000 votes. Crumlish called him 'Benedict Arlen.' Specter served two four-year terms as Philadelphia district attorney, leaving office in 1973 after losing his bid for a third term to criminal defense attorney F. Emmett Fitzpatrick. Although he supported capital punishment, he questioned the fairness of Pennsylvania's death-penalty law in 1972. In 1967 he was the Republican standard-bearer alongside city controller candidate Tom Gola in the Philadelphia mayoral campaign against incumbent James Tate; their slogans included 'We need THESE guys to watch THOSE guys' and 'They're younger, they're tougher, and nobody owns them!'
After his district attorney service, Specter practiced with Dechert, Price & Rhoads in Philadelphia. He lost the 1976 Republican Senate primary to John Heinz and the 1978 Republican primary for governor to Dick Thornburgh. In 1980 he won the Republican nomination after incumbent Richard Schweiker retired, defeated former Pittsburgh mayor Pete Flaherty by a 2.5 percent margin, and took office as senator in January 1981. Voters reelected him in 1986, 1992, 1998, and 2004. His 1992 and 1998 victories came in difficult years for Republicans. In the 2004 Republican primary, he narrowly defeated conservative congressman Pat Toomey, receiving 51 percent; he then defeated Democrat Joe Hoeffel, with minor candidates taking 5.39 percent of the vote between them.
During three decades in the Senate, Specter became Pennsylvania's longest-serving senator. He chaired the Senate Select Committee on Intelligence from 1995 to 1997, the Committee on Veterans' Affairs from 1997 to 2001 and again from 2003 to 2005, and the Senate Judiciary Committee from 2005 to 2007. In 1988 he co-sponsored an amendment to the Fair Housing Act that strengthened enforcement and extended protected classes to people with disabilities and families with children. He voted for the Senate's 2002 Iraq War authorization and, in 1999, for the Comprehensive Test Ban Treaty, which the Senate rejected. In 2002 a PoliticsPA yearbook-style feature named him 'Toughest to Work For'; the Pennsylvania Report later called him one of a dwindling number of moderate Republicans and characterized his approach as middle-of-the-road 'Pennsylvania first' politics.
After the 2004 election, Specter addressed the prospects of Supreme Court nominees who might seek to overturn Roe v. Wade. Conservative groups interpreted his remarks as a warning to President George W. Bush; Specter said he was making a prediction. Following meetings with Republican senators and assurances to them, he was recommended for the Judiciary Committee chairmanship and assumed it when the 109th Congress convened on January 4, 2005. In 2006, Time selected him as one of America's ten best senators.
During his committee chairmanship, Specter wrote a provision in the 2006 revision of the USA PATRIOT Act changing rules for interim U.S. attorney appointments. The amendment permitted the administration to appoint interim U.S. attorneys without time limits or Senate confirmation; the Bush administration used the provision for at least eight appointments in 2006. Specter said staff member Brett Tolman had added the changes. He opposed President Bush's warrantless wiretapping of U.S. citizens, called it inappropriate and categorically wrong, and sought hearings in 2006. In April 2006 he said the president owed the American people a specific explanation about the administration's disclosure of classified intelligence. He nevertheless supported the 2008 Foreign Intelligence Surveillance Act amendments that placed federal electronic searches largely within the executive branch.
Specter also pursued oversight and legislation beyond the Judiciary Committee. He wrote to NFL commissioner Roger Goodell during the 2007–08 season about the destruction of New England Patriots' Spygate tapes, asking whether they had any connection to the Patriots' 2005 Super Bowl victory over Specter's Philadelphia Eagles. Goodell said the tapes had confirmed what he already knew. Specter urged the NFL to conduct an independent investigation and said Congress might act if the league left the matter unresolved. Beginning in 2007 he sponsored legislation to permit more service members convicted by courts-martial to appeal to the U.S. Supreme Court. He co-sponsored the Equal Justice for United States Military Personnel Act in 2007 and again in 2009; the earlier bill failed in the 110th Congress. In December 2008, his use of Polish jokes while speaking at the Rainbow Room in New York prompted controversy.
Specter voted for the American Recovery and Reinvestment Act on February 10, 2009, one of three Republican senators to support it. His vote drew calls from Republican supporters to remove him from office. He helped secure an additional $10 billion for the National Institutes of Health over the following two years, and in August 2009 joined Representative Jason Altmire in leading a congressional hearing on whether the federal government should support a national vaccine-production center. In 2009 he introduced a bill to televise Supreme Court proceedings. He introduced the Comprehensive Immigration Reform Act of 2006, which passed the Senate in May but stalled in the House; he also supported the Healthy Americans Act and voted for the Affordable Care Act. He held a Judiciary subcommittee hearing in March 2010 about covert webcam images taken of students at home by two Pennsylvania high schools, and introduced a bill to clarify that capturing silent images inside another person's home was illegal.
In April 2009, facing a difficult Republican primary challenge from Toomey, Specter returned to the Democratic Party. He said the Republican Party had moved increasingly to the right and that he was more aligned with Democratic philosophy. The switch changed the balance of the Senate and briefly placed Democrats on the verge of a 60-seat majority. His new colleagues did not preserve his committee seniority, however, reducing his influence. In 2010 he sought reelection as a Democrat, received the state party's endorsement with more than 77 percent of committee members' votes, but lost the May primary to former Navy vice admiral Joe Sestak. Specter endorsed Sestak, who lost the general election to Republican Pat Toomey. Specter's Senate service ended on January 3, 2011.
After leaving the Senate, Specter taught at the University of Pennsylvania Law School in fall 2011 as an adjunct professor, offering a course on Congress and the Supreme Court, with attention to separation of powers and the confirmation process. The National Jurist included him among 23 professors to take before one dies. On December 21, 2011, he donated nearly 2,700 boxes of papers and memorabilia from his work as Philadelphia district attorney and U.S. senator, including Warren Commission materials, to Philadelphia University, now Thomas Jefferson University. The University of Pittsburgh jointly houses, organizes, and manages the collection, and the two universities collaborate on educational programming across Pennsylvania. The collection supports the nonpartisan Arlen Specter Center for Public Service at Thomas Jefferson University, which promotes research, educational programs, and exhibitions concerning domestic and foreign public policy. The center is managed by the Paul J. Gutman Library and located in Roxboro House. Parts of the house date to 1799; it was expanded in 1810, was once owned by anatomist Caspar Wistar, and was added to Philadelphia's historic-building register in 1965. The university purchased it in 1998 after it had been used as a bed-and-breakfast.
Specter had surgery to remove a brain tumor in 1993. He announced an advanced form of Hodgkin lymphoma in February 2005 and continued Senate work during chemotherapy, which ended July 22. In April 2008 he announced a recurrence at a less advanced stage and completed a second course of chemotherapy on July 14. On August 28, 2012, he was reported to be hospitalized with a serious form of cancer diagnosed six weeks earlier; he left a Philadelphia hospital on September 7, with further treatment expected. Specter died at his Philadelphia home on October 14, 2012, aged 82, from complications of non-Hodgkin lymphoma. Condolences came from President Barack Obama and his wife, Vice President Joe Biden and his wife, Pennsylvania's governor, and colleagues and former opponents at federal, state, and city levels. Despite criticism that his positions and party changes alienated both parties, many in public life regarded him as a principled statesman. Obama ordered flags at public institutions and military bases in Washington and across the country lowered to half-staff on the day of Specter's interment.
As assistant counsel to the Warren Commission, helped formulate the single-bullet theory concerning the wounds sustained by President John F. Kennedy and Governor John Connally; a later House investigative panel found its forensic conclusions consistent with the theory.
Represented Pennsylvania in the United States Senate for 30 years, becoming the state's longest-serving senator.
Co-sponsored the 1988 Fair Housing Act amendment, strengthening enforcement and extending coverage to people with disabilities and families with children.
As Judiciary Committee chairman, wrote a provision in the 2006 USA PATRIOT Act revision concerning interim appointments of U.S. attorneys.
Helped secure an additional $10 billion for the National Institutes of Health in the 2009 economic recovery legislation.
Donated nearly 2,700 boxes of career papers and memorabilia to support the Arlen Specter Center for Public Service and collaborative archival and educational programs.
Works
book foreword
Flying Blind: How Political Correctness Continues to Compromise Airline Safety Post 9/11
(Specter wrote the foreword to Michael A. Smerconish's book.)
(Memoir written with Frank J. Scaturro about Specter's can...)
2008
sourcebook
Status Offenders: A Sourcebook
(Co-authored with John P. Murray, H. Ted Rubin, and Milton...)
1983
Religion
Specter was Jewish and wrote that his father's family was the only Jewish family in the Ukrainian village where his father grew up. His family's Jewish identity was part of his personal and family history.
Politics
Specter was a Democrat from 1951 to 1965, a Republican from 1965 until 2009, and a Democrat again from 2009 until his Senate career ended. He first changed parties in 1965 to pursue the Philadelphia district attorney's office after Democratic leaders opposed his candidacy; in 2009, he said that the Republican Party had moved too far to the right and that he was increasingly at odds with its philosophy. His political course reflected both electoral calculation and his position near the center of Pennsylvania politics. As a Republican senator, he was often characterized as a moderate, though he was also described as a partisan Republican; after his switch, his voting alignment with Democrats increased substantially.
Specter ran for president as a Republican in 1995, presenting himself as an alternative to the party's religious-conservative image. He criticized Pat Buchanan, Pat Robertson, and Ralph Reed as too conservative, and emphasized balancing the federal budget, strict crime laws, and relations with North Korea. With support from Pennsylvania senator Rick Santorum and other Republicans who hoped to limit the influence of the party's far-right wing, he suspended his campaign in November 1995 and endorsed Bob Dole before the primaries.
His Senate record combined positions from across the political spectrum. He supported a woman's right to choose while saying he was personally opposed to abortion; he received a 20 percent rating from NARAL Pro-Choice America in 2005 based on certain votes concerning abortion regulation and a 100 percent rating in 2008. On LGBT rights, he voted to prohibit employment discrimination based on sexual orientation and co-sponsored the Matthew Shepard Hate Crimes Prevention Act. He opposed same-sex marriage but supported civil unions and opposed a federal prohibition on same-sex marriage. He had supported the Defense of Marriage Act in 1996, later called for its repeal in 2009, and voted to repeal 'Don't Ask, Don't Tell' during the lame-duck session of the 111th Congress. He opposed most gun-control measures, voting against the Brady Bill, background checks at gun shows, the assault-weapons ban, and handgun trigger locks.
Specter supported civil-rights legislation, affirmative action, an increase in the federal minimum wage, immigration reform with a route to citizenship and a guest-worker program, and federal support for a Public Service Academy. He voted to establish Martin Luther King Jr. Day as a federal holiday and supported the Civil Rights Restoration Act of 1987, including overriding President Reagan's veto, and the Civil Rights Act of 1991. The NAACP gave him a 76 percent rating in 2008. He opposed the nomination of Robert Bork to the Supreme Court but supported those of Clarence Thomas, John Roberts, and Samuel Alito; he called Anita Hill's testimony during Thomas's confirmation hearings 'perjurious in its entirety.' He was the only Republican senator to vote in 1995 to limit tax cuts to people earning less than one million dollars, opposed CAFTA, and supported raising the federal minimum wage.
Specter criticized the Republican Party's impeachment of Bill Clinton, arguing that Clinton had not received a fair trial and invoking the Scottish-law verdict 'not proven'; the Senate recorded his vote as not guilty. He voted for the Comprehensive Test Ban Treaty in 1999, one of four Republican senators to do so, and supported the 2002 authorization of the Iraq War. He backed the 2009 economic stimulus, helping secure an additional $10 billion for the National Institutes of Health, and voted for the Affordable Care Act. On health policy he initially opposed a government-run public insurance plan, later said a single-payer system should not be ruled out, and co-sponsored the Healthy Americans Act. His positions on labor legislation shifted: after opposing cloture on the Employee Free Choice Act in 2009, he later told unions he supported card-check legislation.
As Judiciary Committee chair, Specter criticized warrantless surveillance of Americans, called for hearings, and had Attorney General Alberto Gonzales answer questions, though he did not require testimony under oath. He said that the president owed the public an explanation concerning the leaking of classified intelligence, but voted for 2008 amendments to the Foreign Intelligence Surveillance Act that placed federal electronic searches largely within the executive branch. He introduced legislation to require televised Supreme Court arguments and proposed amending federal wiretap law after a school district's webcam surveillance of students at home. He also sponsored measures concerning appeals by service members convicted at courts-martial, introduced comprehensive immigration legislation in 2006, and supported federal legislation addressing cancer research and organ trafficking. His political outlook combined a strong interest in civil liberties and institutional oversight with support for national security measures, including the Iraq War authorization.
Views
Specter's public outlook emphasized constitutional institutions, legislative oversight, and the rights and privacy of individuals. He argued that Americans should be able to see and hear Supreme Court arguments because the Court's decisions directly affect their rights. Following the covert webcam surveillance of students in their homes, he maintained that privacy protections should extend to the home and introduced legislation to restrict such surveillance.
Membership
Specter belonged to the American, Pennsylvania, and Philadelphia bar associations, as well as the Phi Beta Kappa honor society and Pi Lambda Phi fraternity. His participation extended to advisory and civic bodies concerned with public service, criminal justice, youth, and alcoholism. These organizations and committees connected his legal and political work with professional practice and public policy.
American Bar Association
,
United States
Pennsylvania Bar Association
,
United States
Philadelphia Bar Association
,
United States
Elected to the honor society after graduating from the University of Pennsylvania.
Phi Beta Kappa
,
United States
1951
Member while an undergraduate at the University of Pennsylvania.
Pi Lambda Phi
,
United States
National Advisory Committee on the Peace Corps
,
United States
1969
Participant.
White House Conference on Youth
,
United States
1971 - 1971
Governor's Justice Commission
,
United States
Regional Planning Council
,
United States
National Advisory Commission on Criminal Justice Standards and Goals
,
United States
Criminal Rules Committee of the Supreme Court of Pennsylvania
,
United States
Judicial Council of Philadelphia
,
United States
National Council on Alcoholism
,
United States
Personality
Specter was characterized by a persistent, forceful approach to work and public life. During chemotherapy he continued his Senate duties, and his memoir described his determination to keep working through serious illness. His 2008 cancer memoir used the phrase 'Never give in' as a guiding expression of that resolve.
Physical Characteristics:
Chemotherapy temporarily caused Specter to lose his hair. Senator John Sununu shaved his own head in solidarity with him.
Quotes from others about the person
In 2003, the Pennsylvania Report called Specter one of the 'vanishing breed of Republican moderates' and described his approach as 'Pennsylvania first' middle-of-the-road politics, while also noting his reputation as a committed Republican partisan. In a 2004 yearbook-style feature, PoliticsPA named him 'Toughest to Work For.'
In a blurb for Never Give In, Michael J. Fox praised the book's account of Specter's tenacity and candor. Orrin Hatch wrote that Specter remained an asset to Pennsylvania and the Senate during personal illness, while Patrick Leahy praised his endurance and Joe Biden called the book an account of courage. Tom Harkin wrote that Specter did not give up in the face of adversity.
Interests
Specter was a longtime and devoted Philadelphia Eagles fan. During his cancer treatment he maintained a nearly daily squash routine. The Arlen Specter US Squash Center in Philadelphia, built by US Squash, began construction in 2019 and was completed in 2021.
Sport & Clubs
Squash; Philadelphia Eagles football
Connections
Specter married Joan Lois Levy in 1953. She was elected in 1979 to one of Philadelphia City Council's two minority-party at-large seats and served four terms, until losing reelection to Frank Rizzo Jr. in 1995. They had two sons, Shanin and Stephen.
Specter practiced law with Marvin Katz, his partner in Specter & Katz; Katz later served as a federal district judge in Philadelphia and died in October 2010. Representative Gerald Ford recommended Specter for work with the Warren Commission. In the Senate, he corresponded with NFL commissioner Roger Goodell about the destruction of Patriots' Spygate tapes and collaborated on legislative initiatives with senators including Dianne Feinstein, Hillary Clinton, and Russ Feingold. His 1996 presidential campaign was supported by Pennsylvania senator Rick Santorum. Senator John Sununu shaved his head in solidarity during Specter's chemotherapy. In 2009 Specter worked with Pennsylvania congressman Jason Altmire on a hearing about federal support for vaccine production.
Father:
Harry Specter
Grew up in Bachkuryne village in Cherkasy Oblast, Ukraine; served in the U.S. infantry during World War I and later worked as a fruit peddler, tailor, and junkyard owner.
Mother:
Lillie Shanin Specter
Jewish; born into a family with roots in the Russian or Ukrainian region.
Son:
Shanin Specter
Son:
Stephen Specter
Wife:
Joan Lois Levy
Philadelphia City Council member from 1979 to 1995.
colleague:
Marvin Katz
Specter's law partner in Specter & Katz and later a federal district judge in Philadelphia; died in October 2010.
colleague:
Gerald Ford
Recommended Specter for assistant counsel work with the Warren Commission.
colleague:
Ira Einhorn
Client represented by Specter in a murder case; Einhorn subsequently fled while on bail.
Awarded by Northeast Catholic High School in 1973.
Awarded by Northeast Catholic High School in 1973.
Congressional Award,
United States
Awarded by the American Society of Nephrology in 1998.
Awarded by the American Society of Nephrology in 1998.
Legislation of the Year Award,
United States
Awarded by the National Association of Alcoholism & Drug Abuse Counselors in 1999.
Awarded by the National Association of Alcoholism & Drug Abuse Counselors in 1999.
Public Policy Leadership Award,
United States
Awarded by the American Cancer Society in 2000.
Awarded by the American Cancer Society in 2000.
Special Recognition Award,
United States
Awarded by the American Heart Association in 2003.
Awarded by the American Heart Association in 2003.
Lead On! Award,
United States
Awarded by the National Organization on Disability in 2004.
Awarded by the National Organization on Disability in 2004.
Public Service Award,
United States
Presented in May 2012 by New York-Presbyterian Hospital, Columbia University Medical Center, and Weill Cornell Medical College for his work expanding mental health care.
Presented in May 2012 by New York-Presbyterian Hospital, Columbia University Medical Center, and Weill Cornell Medical College for his work expanding mental health care.